PHL232H1 Lecture Notes - Lecture 3: If And Only If
Wednesday, October 5, 2016
1
PHL232 Tutorial Notes
Counterfactuals and Nozick
S-L Semantics: Is a semantics about the counterfactual
p counterfactual q”: If it would be the case that p it would be the case that q is true at a
world where iff: There is a world x in which p^q is true that is closer to the w than any
world y in which p^notq is true.
@is used as a symbol for the actual world.
There is a world x in which p^q is true that is closer to @ than any world y in which
p^notq is true.
Closer means more similar. Is this similarity based on some objective feature? Yes. S-L
say that similarity is an objective feature that worlds have. This needs to be objective for
the account not to be circular.
Nozick
Nozicks theory on what consitutes knowledge (4 conditions)—Nozicks account does
not relate to the sceptic on their terms but is supposed to explain to those of us who are
not sceptics how to determine what knowledge is.
1. It is true that P
2. I believe that P
3. Subjunctive: If P wasnt true then I wouldnt believe P.
1. There is a world in which I dont believe P and P is not true, that is closer then
any world in which P isnt true but I believe P.
4. If P is true then I would believe P.
1. Do I know that I have hands?
1. It is true that I have hands
2. I believe that I have hands
find more resources at oneclass.com
find more resources at oneclass.com
Document Summary
@is used as a symbol for the actual world. There is a world x in which p^q is true that is closer to @ than any world y in which p^notq is true. S-l say that similarity is an objective feature that worlds have. This needs to be objective for the account not to be circular. Wednesday, october 5, 2016: if i didn(cid:1685)t have hands then i wouldn"t believe that i did. > there is a world in which i have hands and believe that i do that is closer than any world in which i have hands but i don(cid:1685)t believe that i do. **remember that we are looking at a world that is distinct from the actual world. The last proposition is true because the world in which i do and i believe that i do is closest to the actual world.