Class Notes (838,386)
Canada (510,872)
History (652)
HIST 3209 (11)
B.S.Elliot (11)
Lecture 4

Week 4 Lecture 1 Planning Neighbourhoods.docx

9 Pages
Unlock Document

HIST 3209

Week 4 Lecture 1 Planning Neighbourhoods, cities, and capitals Feb 3 2014 Planning neighbourhoods: elite enclaves to ideal suburbs Vernacular city did have planning – focus on panning the neighbourhood and a focus on Harris’ idea of the elite enclaves; the traditional suburb • Suburbs in 1960s – a realization for the many • Suburb is a place and also an idea • Suburbia is a low density middle or upperclass area for commuters; rather green with large houseson the edge of a city • Ideal suburb as a product of 200 years, but only the past 50-60 years saw it as a reality • Modern suburb is also a state of mind • Advocates about it connecting to nature, or for others, it connects towards the city • Modern suburb as anti-modern reaction to industrial city o Idea of the suburbs (19C) o Transportation revolution  realization 1960s o Began to disappear within a decade because of rising land servicing costs o 1980s – a second anti-modern fourer into the past; the small country-town became the model  New Urbanism o This gave into less utopian conceptions such as smart growth and intensification o Ideal suburb for most of tis history was really one type of suburb – the ‘Exclusive enclave’ termed by Harris o Edinburgh in Scotland  Originally just one long street  Narrow lanes running at right angles of it – became the residence of hundreds of families in the side streets  Its compactness was due to the limits of walking as the only transportation – poor lived on the side and outskirts  Cities often grew in ribbon development o Montreal 1757  Original town within defensive walls – the extensive suburbs developed outside the gates of the city  Developed somewhat organically along major axis roads o As cities grew, there was concern of public open space – open space as a luxury for the rich  i.e. gardens in Georgians squares o Park – originally meant the pleasure ground attached to wealthy estates  Hyde Park in Toronto • History of the idea: o The old walking city and the working class suburb o Cemeteries and parks (Frederick Law Olmsted)  Prototype of the park as the pulic cemetery – i.e. Mt. Auburn Cemetery Cambridge, Mass 1831  Row cemeteries began an important place to come and visit, enjoy the monuments and trees  Eventually they wanted to do this without the dead people – city park developed  Most famous of city parks as Central Park in New York by Olmsted  Departed from the geometric, French landscape design – more natural  Exclusive suburbs would grow out of these more natural parks – curvilinear road ways, enhancement of natural features  Olmsted set this standard  First Canadian city park: Mcdonald Park in Kingston that had been a former military ground – 1853 it was turned over  These parks were oasis from the overcrowding – not really solutions to the overcrowding  The ideal of the country estate – instead of laying villas along the main axis, the idea became laying out a small subdivision like a park  1850s, Downing’s work of aying out houses was influential  Downing’s idea was a large par that would be owned in common by the villas known as Residential Parks o Roadside villas o Residential parks (Llewellyn Park, N.J. 1853 – 57)  A picturesque ravine is laid out as a park with wandering pathways  Around it, there are a series of large residences (private) o Exclusive Enclave (Riverside, Illinois 1868)  Laid out on the railway, nine miles west of Chicago by Olmsted  These were commuter suburbs  Plan is different – Olmsted found that Downing’s parks lacked privacy  Has a number of small parks dispersed through the plan  House plots not standard since they don’t follow a grid pattern – each family provided with a little property  Curvilieaner street pattern and attention to nature is what distinguished these suburbs in later generations  First Canadian plans of suburbs from Riverside – i.e. Rosedale • Ideal vs. reality – Canada c.1900 • Early Canadian examples o Rosedale, Toronto, 1854 – English roots: Park Village (John Nash 1823)  Based off the Riverside plan  The only problem is that it was actually surveyed in 1854 making it a contemporary with Llewelyn park rather than Riverside  Where did the planning model actually come from? For both Canada and U.S.?  Answer in the newspaper about the property of Rosedale  Advertisement on Rosedale talks about natural beauty, gentle slopes, trees, winding roads, etc – based off suburns in London  Development of Riverside also influenced by London  This English park is actually Regent’s Park in London by John Nash • Large stuccoed terraces of rowhousing • Attraction fo Regent’s park for the wealthy is that the terrace house would face onto this open parkland • Expensive • Model also adopted in Princess park, and Birkenhead park  1823 – Nash laid out the lot of Regent park for single family along a winding road  Rosedale – the lots sold slowly; difficult to sell because the Toronto women felt that it was too far out and were afraid they wouldn’t be able to get maids  1860s – horse drawn carriage though  It shows that in this period, there were still opportunities to build large houses in downtown Toronto  1865 – most of the Rosedale property was let out as a commercial pleasure ground – became a outdoor privately owned park until there was enough demand to buy the house lots  1903 – Community formed an association – managed to build a vision for the subdivion o Park Village East & West 1870 – single family homes along this roadway o Park Village East – John Nash 1824 o Rockcliffe, Ottawa, 1864  Rockcliffe takes its name from a country villa – by D.R. Macnab 1837  Rockcliffe wasn’t developed on the Macnab, but the Mackay Property  MAckay bought land in the Gloucester township, built sawmills and laid out a village for mill workers he named Edinburgh  Later purchased a generation later for the governor of the capital  Thomas Keefer, took over the Mackay Estate after his death (son in law)  Keefer was aware of the importance of railways – also aware of planning movements  An attempt was made in th e1860s to lay out a plan to connect New Edinburgh  Initial idea to lay out rectangular lots – later in the year, the design changed  The second plan shows a more curvilinear street pattern with large lots laid out along the lanes  Put out on the market in 1864 – buyers don’t come  The Horse railway was built – was it also built to move people from New Edinburgh?  Keefer also decides to turn this place for public amusement th o Late 19 century, when streetcars arrive, people start to buy these lots  This subdivision plan was registered and forms the basis for the layout of Rockcliffe up to this day  1951 –original street plan put in place by Keefer for Mackay estate o Many historical accounts see the ‘idea’ of a suburb as a retreat o 1900 – communter suburb as a rare (Harris)  Small town lots as the most profibale to develop land  Very few landscape architects or independent planners at the turn of the last century  Many smaller cities really didn’t need the new form of transit  In form, most subdivisions remained these rectangle grids  Grid patterns which were designed for ease, sometimes weren’t – i.e. you had to blow up a hill to put a road through th  Appearance of planning profession in Canada at turn of 20 century • Planning profession – early 20C influences: o City Beautiful, Daniel Burnham  World’s Colombian Exposition 1893 – important for the movement • The White City as a vision of the city that might be • Large, classically designed buildings lit with electricity • Becomes the prototype for the Beaux Art development spreading across America afterwards  As a reaction to the ugly, overcrowed conditions  Not a rejection of the city  Sees monumental civic buildings, axis  Broad avenues based off Pierre L’enfant’s plan for Washington D.C. – says that dia
More Less

Related notes for HIST 3209

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.