Class Notes (835,107)
Canada (508,933)
Law (1,967)
LAWS 2301 (138)
Lecture

Desiree Hayward

3 Pages
105 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Law
Course
LAWS 2301
Professor
Saunders- Carleton University
Semester
Fall

Description
October 1 2012 LAWS2301A Chapter 2- Lecture 4 Purposes/goals/principles - LLCR proposed goals and principles (law reform commission of Canada) - Mere offenses versus real crimes - Ouimet - Smith principles (put together to deal with sexual offenses) - Costs of over criminalization - Role/influence of perspectives *Purposes and principles are meant to address the problems we have in the CJS * Law reform commission’s job was to restrain the CJS: Did come up with 4 main principles until they were replaced during the Mulroney era with the Law commission of Canada:(also underfunded) NOTE: Section 2.5 on historical perspectives in text: Skipped What are some purposes and goals of criminal law? (Class examples) - Maintain order/ social control - Deterring people from committing crimes - Control behavior - Justice - Ensure public safety - Protect (society, rights and freedoms) What do other people think should be the goal(s)?- Purposes of law according to LRC - Retribution: Argument- There are people who commit public wrongs out there and they should be punished for it- LRC rejects this idea of retribution as a principle of law - Enforcing morality- Should criminal law be used to enforce morality?- LRC rejects this idea on the basis that it’s too individual: Different people have different morals - Protection from harm: What’s a problem with having the right to protect yourself?- How do we define harm? HOWEVER we can use techniques of social self-defense in cases of undesirable activities(threatening with the criminal law)- LRC supports this - LLRC’s most important goal to criminal law has to do with the Underlying values approach- LRC says you have essential values in society, and you have values which are necessary for the type of society we want to have but do not necessarily need; And as such, we need to create laws that help protect these values when they are being threatened When these values are threatened, the law needs to; 1) Respond 2) Articulate 3) Inculcate values 4) Provide reassurance – That justice will be done Therefore, according to LRC, what we put in criminal law should only be the most essential laws and values MORALITY= PREVENTION, RETRIBUTION: PUNISHMENT, PROTECTION FROM HARM= SOCIAL SELF- DEFENSE, UNDERLYING VALUES= ESSENTIAL VALUES However, the LRC had to ask what regular people would want to be a criminal law, and came up with the distinction between; MERE OFFENSES V. TRUE CRIMES - Mere offenses violate useful rules while crimes violate essential rules- But what are useful rules? Parking violations for example are not worth criminalizing, same with hunting regulations - Crimes are wrong of a greater generality than mere offenses: Crimes that aren’t being committed in a specific area (a butcher serving tainted meat) - Crimes are more obvious wrongs than mere offenses- You need to have an identifiable victim/ direct identifiable harm - Was the crime purposive? Ouimet Committee; -The basic purpose of criminal law is to protect all members of society, including the offender, from serious, harmful and dangerous conduct - The basic principles of criminal law should be carried out with no more interference on the freedom of individuals than is necessary - Recognition of the innocent must be assured at all stages of the criminal justice process: PROBLEM as soon as someone is charged of a crime people generally assume they are guilty => leads to wrongful convictions - No conduct should be defined as cr
More Less

Related notes for LAWS 2301

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit