Class Notes (835,674)
Canada (509,327)
Philosophy (644)
PHIL 2101 (14)
Lecture

PHIL 2101 January 21, 2014.docx
Premium

4 Pages
133 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Philosophy
Course
PHIL 2101
Professor
Gordon Davis
Semester
Winter

Description
Nicomachean ethics: end of all things -Ch. 4, book I, Aristotle •There is one purpose that we all serve, but we don't know what it is •Happiness and what is happiness: compares different types of lives, o Life of pleasure, happiness If a "Unity" of virtue Then WISDOM is key o Makes virtue either teachable (in Protagoras) or Knowable (see memo) o Hit-and-miss "midwifery" o Key to happiness •Means to and end, In Protagoras, instrumentality, instrumental to something like virtue which is one •Philosophers try to crystallise dilemma o 5 and 1 cases, killed 5 to save one • Ex. If you have to go only one island while the tide is coming in and you can save the island with only 1 or 5 people, which would you go to o Is it your decision to kill people though? • Action vs. inaction • Dwells on the idea -> would you push one stranger to save others?  Question of what you would do vs. what you should do.  It is a psychological question • Bringing us back to the Greeks -> only your weight would be sufficient -> would you jump to save the 5 people? o Idea of not just moral rightness, but heroism o Heroism is the means, ends, calculation • Aristotle talks about the use of mean "mean" in the sense of medium o Finding a middle point between emotional extremes is ethnically valuable • Why does he think that?  There is no doctrine of the mean -> mean is not more important than a mean or extreme •Greek words help foster your understanding for the English language o Eudaimonia -> Happiness (Eu -> meaning you) o Arete -> aristo or aristocracy -> meaning the best o Telos -> aiming or directing or transporting something o Psuche -> psyche, phycology o Ergon -> ergometer , rowing machine o Logos -> Reasoning/'rational principle' [rule] logic, logarithms o Kalos -> noble/fine, beautiful, kalosethtics •Use these words and relate them to see Aristotle's overall account of statics •Which of these definitions accounts for the other? •Plato gains credit; almost unheard of that men and women should be equal in society before his writing o That is what he states in the Republic o Astonishing because we do not know where it came form, except for the possibility that it comes from Diotima o To write down in one of his most famous works that men and women should be equal is remarkable • Must have been open minded, get the sense form all the Greeks that they may have been racist  Racist against everyone, really, definitely against Blonde Europeans, uncouth, hairy, axe-wielding lunatics  All these people are essentially inferior • Sometimes they admired the freedom loving part of these crazy loving people for better or worst o Plato was definitely different o Aristotle was Macedonian -> Macedonians were around the zone where the Greeks met and the 'scary' part of the Europeans, they weren't counted as Greek, though they spoke a kind of Greek language • Plato gave them full rights within the Academy (His own academy) • Some people think Plato was authoritarian • Was hierarchical and not democratic o Are democratic, there is some sort of value on free speech, long explanation of what is wrong with pirates o Criticizes tyranny • Not as narrow minded about things like poetry and religion • May have been squished into the Pythagorean cult, may have had an interest in mystical forces o In the Republic, book 4, there is a famous division of the soul • Does not think of just immaterial intellect and physical body  Believes that the soul includes 3 elements  Intellect and use of reason  Passion and emotion  Appetite, part of organic nature with impact on our mental life o Some part of Plato's ideal is to bring the 3 parts into harmony, interpretive problem • Why we should see passion as something in between and not just reducible to appetite • Aristotle tries to incorporate all these different aspects of the soul in a slightly different way • Cleaner divide between intellect and everything else Discussion of the Unity of Virtue -> Aristotle and Plato disagree o Socrates initially voices equating the different virtues that deal with their opposites being the same • Argument that can be challenged o 4 themes of Protagoras, [taylor translate virtue (Greek
More Less

Related notes for PHIL 2101

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit