Class Notes (1,100,000)
CA (620,000)
Dal (4,000)
SOSA (200)
Lecture 4

SOSA 2042 Lecture Notes - Lecture 4: Social Forces, Counterintuitive, Upper Class

by

Department
Soc & Social Anthropology
Course Code
SOSA 2042
Professor
Prof.L.Du Bois
Lecture
4

This preview shows pages 1-2. to view the full 6 pages of the document.
!"#$%&'()*+,%-%. /
Society(
#0,+%*'(1%*'+%234%05%61768673(92%(17%40,+%*'(1%*'+%234%05%6*2%)(,*2
:(2%2*,3;*3,+<%2=2*+4
$5%=03%70%>?'(*+8+,%=03%96@+>%=03%?699%96@+9=%A+%)3*%61*0%(1%612*6*3*601%
B4)0?+,2%(17%;012*,(612
&(1%A+%(9*+,+7<%23A8+,*+7%.01+%;(1%8609(*+%,39+2<%A3*%10*%,(17049=
C0;6(9%612*6*3*601%
C=4A096;%61*+,1(*601(9624%
Theory
#(;D+07E%20;6(9%50,;+2%*'(*%2'()+%86+?2%05%*'+%?0,97%(17%?'(*%62%)0226A9+
BF)9(612%;011+;*601%A+*?++1%968+7%+F)+,6+1;+2% 05%61768673(92%(17%*'+%2=2*+4%G5(;*0,2%
A+=017%*'+%61768673(9H%(17%'0?%*'+=%64)61I+%01%+(;'%0*'+,
J0%10*%1++7%*0%7,(?%01%01+%*'+0,=<%A3*%;(1%32+%4(1=
J655+,+1*%*'+0,6+2%'+9)%=03%2++%7655+,+1*%*'61I2K%;(2*%7655+,+1*%96I'*2%01%*'+%2(4+%
2=2*+4L),0A9+4
J655+,+1*%*'+0,6+2%(17%961@2%(,+%)0226A9+
J655+,+1*%+4)'(2+2%61%7+2;,6)*601
M0%7655+,+1*%+172
J655+,+1*%+F)9(1(*6012%(,+%),073;+7
Thinking(Theoretically
"0*%N32*%(A03*%9+(,161I%*'+0,6+2
J0+21O*%'(8+%*0%'(8+%(1%.624
"0*%(A03*%A+61I%0A2;3,+L*00%*'+0,+*6;(9%
&04)(,(*68+
P2+2%2*376+2%05%*'+%,+(9%?0,97%(2%,(?%4(*+,6(9
:+9)2%32%317+,2*(17%*'+%,+239*2%05%03,%2*376+2%05%*'+%,+(9%?0,97
BF)9(612%+8+1*2<%),0;+22+2%A+=017%03,%;01*,09
&(1%'+9)%32%*,(125+,%?'(*%?+>8+%9+(,1+7%61%01+%26*+%*0%(10*'+,
M'+0,=%50,%317+,2*(1761I<%10*%*'+0,6+2%2(@+
QRSTE%U,0317+7%61%,+(9%+F)+,6+1;+2
!77,+22%V3+2*6012%05%?'=%(17%'0?
Theoretical(Thinking(in(Sociology(and(Social(Anthropology
W6+?%=03%'(8+%82X%5(;*
&031*+,.61*36*68+K%A,+(@2%?6*'%;04401%2+12+
C3)+,56;6(9%86+?2%70%10*%4(*;'%?6*'%7++)%618+2*6I(*601
"+6*'+,%)3,+9=%2*,3;*3,(9%10,%61768673(9K%4(@+2%961@2%(17%2)+;656+2%'0?%*'+=%?0,@
!%?(=%05%4(@61I%2+12+%05%)3YY9+2
M'+0,6+2%(17%6150,4(*601%;(1%A+%())96+7%*0%0*'+,%26*3(*6012
&()(A9+%05%+F)9(6161I%0*'+,%26*3(*6012
T,36*539K%I+1+,(*+2%1+?%67+(2%(17%53,*'+,%,+2+(,;'
Theoretical(Framework
!%9+12%*',03I'%?'6;'%*0%86+?%*'+%?0,97
Z(26;%(2234)*6012%(A03*%*'+%1(*3,+%05%*'+%?0,97%(17%(A03*%)+0)9+
J+5616*601%05%),0A9+42<%V3+2*6012%*0%A+%(2@+7<%)0226A9+%2093*6012
C+*%05%;(*+I0,6+2<%;01;+)*2%*'(*%2)+;65=%(2)+;*2%05%20;6+*=%*'(*%(,+%64)0,*(1*<%(%50;32%
50,%03,%(**+1*601
The(Problem(for(MacLeod
C*(,*2%03*%?6*'%20;6(9%,+),073;*601%*'+0,=%*'(*%(77,+22+2%*'+2+%V3+2*6012
['=%70%?0,@61I%;9(22%@672%I+*%?0,@61I%;9(22%N0A2
['=%70+2%61+V3(96*=%+F62*%(17%?'=%70+2%6*%)+,262*
:0?%62%6*%),073;+7%(17%,+),073;+7
Functionalist(Approach(to(Our(Problem
T31;*601(962*%V3+2*601%),073;+2%531;*601(962*%(12?+,
C0;6(9%612*6*3*6012%+F62*%*0%2098+%20;6(9%),0A9+42
!2234)*601E%'(,401=%05%8(,6032%612*6*3*6012%),073;+2%2*(A9+%?0,97
B(,9=%+73;(*601%61%*'+%PC
Q,0A9+4E%;'697,+1%(,+%10*%,+(7=%?'+1%*'+=%;04+%*0%2;'009
\3+2*601E%;0,,+;*%7=2531;*601(9%)(,*2
B(,9=%+73;(*601%61%*'+%PC
C093*6012E%;0,,+;*%7=2531;*601(9%)(,*2
&01;+)*2E%,09+<%2=2*+4<%531;*601
Q6+;+4+(9%.(2234+2%,+2*%05%4(;'61+%?0,@2%?'+1%56F%01+%)(,*
!2234+2%+V3(9%(;;+22%*0%'+(7%2*(,*%),0A9+4%
J0+21O*%(77,+22%?'=%.*'+%203,;+%05%*'+%),0A9+4%62%462261I%
!2234+2%26469(,6*=%(401I%@672%.*'+=%(99%'(8+%*'+%2(4+%),0A9+4
!2234+2%2=2*+4%62%31+V3(9%(17%432*%?0,@%*0%,+73;+%61+V3(96*=%
U()2%(17%A9617%2)0*2
Liberal(Individualist(Approach
$1768673(92%23;;++7%01%0?1%4+,6*%.=03%767%6*
$2%*'62%*,3+]%M'+,+%(,+%0*'+,%,+(2012%)+0)9+%23;;++7%0,%5(69
!2234)*6012E%*'+,+%(,+%10%20;6(9%2*,3;*3,(9%A(,,6+,2
!,+1>*%;()(A9+<%701O*%*,=<%61()),0),6(*+%;39*3,+L8(93+2<%'(8+%7655+,+1*%I0(92
Q,0A9+4E%?'=%70%204+%5(69]%
B8+,=%2*37+1*%'(2%*'+%0))0,*316*=<%+8+,=%;'697%;(1%23;;++7
M+(;'%@672%>*0092%*0%23;;+22>%(17%08+,;0461I%*'+6,%762(78(1*(I+2%
BF)9(612E%)'69020)'=%05%2;'009
M'+,+%(,+%0*'+,%,+(2012%)+0)9+%701O*%23;;++7%0*'+,%*'(1%(2)6,(*6012%(17%'(,7%
?0,@
Q3YY9+E%?'=%62%5(693,+%10*%,(1704L)(**+,1+7
Marxist(Approach
C6469(,%*0%531;*601(962*%61%204+%?(=
$1+V3(96*=%61*,6126;%*0%20;6+*=
B8+,=01+%?0,@2%50,%204+01+
!2234)*6012E%20;6+*=%62%76867+7%(17%0,I(16Y+7%A=%;9(22
^+=%&01;+)*2E%;9(22<%)0?+,
D0*2%05%+550,*%)3*%61*0%*'62
#+76(%0?1+7%A=%?+(9*'=%.;044316;(*+%*'+6,%67+(92%*0%32
P))+,%;9(22%61768673(92%G_`H%2++@%*0%4(61*(61%2*(*32
Q+0)9+%701O*%317+,2*(17%?'(*%62%I007%50,%*'+4<%70%10*%2++%?'(*%*'+=%
2'0397%2++
[0,@61I%;9(22%4(=%'(8+%5(92+%;012;60321+22
Q,0A9+4E%['=%70+21>*%*'+%4(N0,6*=%;'(1I+%*'+%2=2*+4%20%*'(*%6*%?0,@2%40,+%61%*'+6,%
61*+,+2*2]
&+,*(61%?+(9*'%4+(12%6*%70+21O*%4(**+,%'0?%=03%70%61%2;'009%.=03%?699%
23;;++7%,+I(,79+22
D0?.61;04+%5(4696+2%'(8+%*0%'+9)%?6*'%>2+;017%2'65*>%'04+%?0,@<%70%10*%
'(8+%*64+%(17%96A+,*6+2%5,04%6*%*0%2)+17%*64+%01%2;'009%(17%23;;++7
C*,3;*3,+7%531761I%*',03I'%61;04+%*(F+2%
$1+V3(96*=%61%2;'009%531761I>2%.'0?%43;'%401+=%I0+2%*0%?'6;'%2;'0092%61%
?'6;'%(,+(2%62%61*+1*601(9
$1%*+,42%05%2;'00961I
BF)9(612
R+73;*68+
Z61(,=
J0+21O*%+F)9(61%+F;+)*6012%.'0?%)+0)9+%204+*64+2%;,022%*'+2+%961+2%
Q3YY9+2
Some(Concepts(in(ANM$
!%A07=%05%67+(2%,+59+;*61I%*'+%20;6(9%1++72%(17%(2)6,(*6012%05%(1%61768673(9%
I,03)<%;9(22%0,%;39*3,+
$7+090I=
$1*+,)9(=a
Z61(,=%.20;6(9%.20;6+*=<%(I+1;=%.61768673(92
M+12601%A+*?++1%'0?%20;6(9%612*6*3*6012%),+7+*+,461+%?'(*%62%I061I%*0%
'())+1%(17%'0?%43;'%61768673(92%;(1%;'002+
#(;D+07%62%61*+,+2*+7%61%*'+%61*+,(;*6012
C*,3;*3,+%(17%(I+1;=
Different(Theoretical(Approaches(in(ANMI
#(;D+07%7+2;,6A+2%(%;01*61334%A+*?++1%7+*+,46162*6;%(17%;39*3,(9%407+92%
C*0,6+2%82X%*'+%2*(*62*6;2
B4)'(26Y+%2*,3;*3,(9%,+V36,+4+1*2%05%*'+%;()6*(962*%2=2*+4
B4)'(26Y+%20;6(9%2*,3;*3,+
T0;32%01%317+,2*(1761I%05%612*6*3*601(9%0,I(16Y(*601
R+9=%01%2*(*62*6;2
J+*+,46162*6;%407+92
Z+I61%?6*'%+F)+,6+1;+% 05%61768673(92
B4)'(26Y+%(I+1;=%
[(1*%*0%317+,2*(17%+F)+,6+1;+% 05%61768673(92<%+8+1%65%6*%62%)(**+,1+7%
B*'10I,()'6;%
&39*3,(9%407+92
Social(Reproduction(Theories
!"#$%&'()'*()+,'-$'./0()+'1,
#017(=<%b(13(,=%__<%-c_d
_-Eec%Q#

Only pages 1-2 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

!"#$%&'()*+,%-%. /
Society(
#0,+%*'(1%*'+%234%05%61768673(92%(17%40,+%*'(1%*'+%234%05%6*2%)(,*2
:(2%2*,3;*3,+<%2=2*+4
$5%=03%70%>?'(*+8+,%=03%96@+>%=03%?699%96@+9=%A+%)3*%61*0%(1%612*6*3*601%
B4)0?+,2%(17%;012*,(612
&(1%A+%(9*+,+7<%23A8+,*+7%.01+%;(1%8609(*+%,39+2<%A3*%10*%,(17049=
C0;6(9%612*6*3*601%
C=4A096;%61*+,1(*601(9624%
C*,3;*3,+%(17%2*,3;*3,+7%61768673(92%
Theory
#(;D+07E%20;6(9%50,;+2%*'(*%2'()+%86+?2%05%*'+%?0,97%(17%?'(*%62%)0226A9+
BF)9(612%;011+;*601%A+*?++1%968+7%+F)+,6+1;+2% 05%61768673(92%(17%*'+%2=2*+4%G5(;*0,2%
A+=017%*'+%61768673(9H%(17%'0?%*'+=%64)61I+%01%+(;'%0*'+,
J0%10*%1++7%*0%7,(?%01%01+%*'+0,=<%A3*%;(1%32+%4(1=
J655+,+1*%*'+0,6+2%'+9)%=03%2++%7655+,+1*%*'61I2K%;(2*%7655+,+1*%96I'*2%01%*'+%2(4+%
2=2*+4L),0A9+4
J655+,+1*%*'+0,6+2%(17%961@2%(,+%)0226A9+
J655+,+1*%+4)'(2+2%61%7+2;,6)*601
M0%7655+,+1*%+172
J655+,+1*%+F)9(1(*6012%(,+%),073;+7
Thinking(Theoretically
"0*%N32*%(A03*%9+(,161I%*'+0,6+2
J0+21O*%'(8+%*0%'(8+%(1%.624
"0*%(A03*%A+61I%0A2;3,+L*00%*'+0,+*6;(9%
&04)(,(*68+
P2+2%2*376+2%05%*'+%,+(9%?0,97%(2%,(?%4(*+,6(9
:+9)2%32%317+,2*(17%*'+%,+239*2%05%03,%2*376+2%05%*'+%,+(9%?0,97
BF)9(612%+8+1*2<%),0;+22+2%A+=017%03,%;01*,09
&(1%'+9)%32%*,(125+,%?'(*%?+>8+%9+(,1+7%61%01+%26*+%*0%(10*'+,
M'+0,=%50,%317+,2*(1761I<%10*%*'+0,6+2%2(@+
QRSTE%U,0317+7%61%,+(9%+F)+,6+1;+2
!77,+22%V3+2*6012%05%?'=%(17%'0?
Theoretical(Thinking(in(Sociology(and(Social(Anthropology
W6+?%=03%'(8+%82X%5(;*
&031*+,.61*36*68+K%A,+(@2%?6*'%;04401%2+12+
C3)+,56;6(9%86+?2%70%10*%4(*;'%?6*'%7++)%618+2*6I(*601
"+6*'+,%)3,+9=%2*,3;*3,(9%10,%61768673(9K%4(@+2%961@2%(17%2)+;656+2%'0?%*'+=%?0,@
!%?(=%05%4(@61I%2+12+%05%)3YY9+2
M'+0,6+2%(17%6150,4(*601%;(1%A+%())96+7%*0%0*'+,%26*3(*6012
&()(A9+%05%+F)9(6161I%0*'+,%26*3(*6012
T,36*539K%I+1+,(*+2%1+?%67+(2%(17%53,*'+,%,+2+(,;'
Theoretical(Framework
!%9+12%*',03I'%?'6;'%*0%86+?%*'+%?0,97
Z(26;%(2234)*6012%(A03*%*'+%1(*3,+%05%*'+%?0,97%(17%(A03*%)+0)9+
J+5616*601%05%),0A9+42<%V3+2*6012%*0%A+%(2@+7<%)0226A9+%2093*6012
C+*%05%;(*+I0,6+2<%;01;+)*2%*'(*%2)+;65=%(2)+;*2%05%20;6+*=%*'(*%(,+%64)0,*(1*<%(%50;32%
50,%03,%(**+1*601
The(Problem(for(MacLeod
C*(,*2%03*%?6*'%20;6(9%,+),073;*601%*'+0,=%*'(*%(77,+22+2%*'+2+%V3+2*6012
['=%70%?0,@61I%;9(22%@672%I+*%?0,@61I%;9(22%N0A2
['=%70+2%61+V3(96*=%+F62*%(17%?'=%70+2%6*%)+,262*
:0?%62%6*%),073;+7%(17%,+),073;+7
Functionalist(Approach(to(Our(Problem
T31;*601(962*%V3+2*601%),073;+2%531;*601(962*%(12?+,
C0;6(9%612*6*3*6012%+F62*%*0%2098+%20;6(9%),0A9+42
!2234)*601E%'(,401=%05%8(,6032%612*6*3*6012%),073;+2%2*(A9+%?0,97
B(,9=%+73;(*601%61%*'+%PC
Q,0A9+4E%;'697,+1%(,+%10*%,+(7=%?'+1%*'+=%;04+%*0%2;'009
\3+2*601E%;0,,+;*%7=2531;*601(9%)(,*2
B(,9=%+73;(*601%61%*'+%PC
C093*6012E%;0,,+;*%7=2531;*601(9%)(,*2
&01;+)*2E%,09+<%2=2*+4<%531;*601
Q6+;+4+(9%.(2234+2%,+2*%05%4(;'61+%?0,@2%?'+1%56F%01+%)(,*
!2234+2%+V3(9%(;;+22%*0%'+(7%2*(,*%),0A9+4%
J0+21O*%(77,+22%?'=%.*'+%203,;+%05%*'+%),0A9+4%62%462261I%
!2234+2%26469(,6*=%(401I%@672%.*'+=%(99%'(8+%*'+%2(4+%),0A9+4
!2234+2%2=2*+4%62%31+V3(9%(17%432*%?0,@%*0%,+73;+%61+V3(96*=%
U()2%(17%A9617%2)0*2
Liberal(Individualist(Approach
$1768673(92%23;;++7%01%0?1%4+,6*%.=03%767%6*
$2%*'62%*,3+]%M'+,+%(,+%0*'+,%,+(2012%)+0)9+%23;;++7%0,%5(69
!2234)*6012E%*'+,+%(,+%10%20;6(9%2*,3;*3,(9%A(,,6+,2
!,+1>*%;()(A9+<%701O*%*,=<%61()),0),6(*+%;39*3,+L8(93+2<%'(8+%7655+,+1*%I0(92
Q,0A9+4E%?'=%70%204+%5(69]%
B8+,=%2*37+1*%'(2%*'+%0))0,*316*=<%+8+,=%;'697%;(1%23;;++7
M+(;'%@672%>*0092%*0%23;;+22>%(17%08+,;0461I%*'+6,%762(78(1*(I+2%
BF)9(612E%)'69020)'=%05%2;'009
M'+,+%(,+%0*'+,%,+(2012%)+0)9+%701O*%23;;++7%0*'+,%*'(1%(2)6,(*6012%(17%'(,7%
?0,@
Q3YY9+E%?'=%62%5(693,+%10*%,(1704L)(**+,1+7
Marxist(Approach
C6469(,%*0%531;*601(962*%61%204+%?(=
$1+V3(96*=%61*,6126;%*0%20;6+*=
B8+,=01+%?0,@2%50,%204+01+
!2234)*6012E%20;6+*=%62%76867+7%(17%0,I(16Y+7%A=%;9(22
^+=%&01;+)*2E%;9(22<%)0?+,
D0*2%05%+550,*%)3*%61*0%*'62
#+76(%0?1+7%A=%?+(9*'=%.;044316;(*+%*'+6,%67+(92%*0%32
P))+,%;9(22%61768673(92%G_`H%2++@%*0%4(61*(61%2*(*32
Q+0)9+%701O*%317+,2*(17%?'(*%62%I007%50,%*'+4<%70%10*%2++%?'(*%*'+=%
2'0397%2++
[0,@61I%;9(22%4(=%'(8+%5(92+%;012;60321+22
Q,0A9+4E%['=%70+21>*%*'+%4(N0,6*=%;'(1I+%*'+%2=2*+4%20%*'(*%6*%?0,@2%40,+%61%*'+6,%
61*+,+2*2]
&+,*(61%?+(9*'%4+(12%6*%70+21O*%4(**+,%'0?%=03%70%61%2;'009%.=03%?699%
23;;++7%,+I(,79+22
D0?.61;04+%5(4696+2%'(8+%*0%'+9)%?6*'%>2+;017%2'65*>%'04+%?0,@<%70%10*%
'(8+%*64+%(17%96A+,*6+2%5,04%6*%*0%2)+17%*64+%01%2;'009%(17%23;;++7
C*,3;*3,+7%531761I%*',03I'%61;04+%*(F+2%
$1+V3(96*=%61%2;'009%531761I>2%.'0?%43;'%401+=%I0+2%*0%?'6;'%2;'0092%61%
?'6;'%(,+(2%62%61*+1*601(9
$1%*+,42%05%2;'00961I
BF)9(612
R+73;*68+
Z61(,=
J0+21O*%+F)9(61%+F;+)*6012%.'0?%)+0)9+%204+*64+2%;,022%*'+2+%961+2%
Q3YY9+2
Some(Concepts(in(ANM$
!%A07=%05%67+(2%,+59+;*61I%*'+%20;6(9%1++72%(17%(2)6,(*6012%05%(1%61768673(9%
I,03)<%;9(22%0,%;39*3,+
$7+090I=
$1*+,)9(=a
Z61(,=%.20;6(9%.20;6+*=<%(I+1;=%.61768673(92
M+12601%A+*?++1%'0?%20;6(9%612*6*3*6012%),+7+*+,461+%?'(*%62%I061I%*0%
'())+1%(17%'0?%43;'%61768673(92%;(1%;'002+
#(;D+07%62%61*+,+2*+7%61%*'+%61*+,(;*6012
C*,3;*3,+%(17%(I+1;=
Different(Theoretical(Approaches(in(ANMI
#(;D+07%7+2;,6A+2%(%;01*61334%A+*?++1%7+*+,46162*6;%(17%;39*3,(9%407+92%
C*0,6+2%82X%*'+%2*(*62*6;2
B4)'(26Y+%2*,3;*3,(9%,+V36,+4+1*2%05%*'+%;()6*(962*%2=2*+4
B4)'(26Y+%20;6(9%2*,3;*3,+
T0;32%01%317+,2*(1761I%05%612*6*3*601(9%0,I(16Y(*601
R+9=%01%2*(*62*6;2
J+*+,46162*6;%407+92
Z+I61%?6*'%+F)+,6+1;+% 05%61768673(92
B4)'(26Y+%(I+1;=%
[(1*%*0%317+,2*(17%+F)+,6+1;+% 05%61768673(92<%+8+1%65%6*%62%)(**+,1+7%
B*'10I,()'6;%
&39*3,(9%407+92
Social(Reproduction(Theories
!"#$%&'()'*()+,'-$'./0()+'1,
#017(=<%b(13(,=%__<%-c_d _-Eec%Q#
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version