PHIL-330 Lecture Notes - Lecture 1: Glaucon, Humanism, James V. SchallPremium
2 pages44 viewsWinter 2017
This preview shows half of the first page. to view the full 2 pages of the document.
Jaes “hall o Plato: hy is his ork still orth studyig? Ee if soe arguets lak sophistiatio hat akes it good
1)Plato’s ritig produes ore truth tha falsity
2)The actual practice of Platonic philosophy: what makes the dialogue (main speaker + interlocutors) attractive as a
-philosophy is brought to life—you are iersed i the atio/ ie the speaker addresses as you
-a drama, not a declarative treatise; includes themes, imagery, motifs, can prove more interesting to read even in non
The Republic will provide a concept of philosophy: how do we define it? What constitutes practicing it?
-for every philosopher they write within a context even if they make their arguments out of context like Descartes does
(context often has tones of social debate or is rooted in history)
-for Plato, the context is during a period of radical humanism
-radical humanism: The human mind has a conflict in itself. It will either give in to an authority or ask questions. In order for a
society to thrive it should follow the latter path.
-a period during which the Sophists taught rhetoric: taught how to win arguments in a way in which the
atual truth alue proed irreleat koledge ithout truth
-whe huas egi to e ale to hoose their truth skeptiis ill arise: ie does oe aept or rejet the
conception of god, or of religion on a whole
-politial hage as also ourrig: ay hages to the fae of deoray, ad differig eliefs o what
exactly democracy should include and preclude
-radical humanism dominates today, making Platonic works highly relevant: the human determines their
-sophism abound: advertising is a type of sophism (does not matter what you say so long as you make it
convincing; likewise with writing papers—often about how you say it, not what you say
Philosophy from the beginning: The Republic begins immediately with speech; the colon right after Socrates name makes the
work immersive—it laks a true itrodutio, suh as a thesis or positio
-piece begins with a story/ line of thought
-uses images/motifs: interplay between being down and up—ie “orates ats to head up to Athes, ut this ill lead to
-port imagery: first scene involves religious celebration/worship at the port/pier: a port being a place where new things arrive,
an image/symbol for the arrival of new ideas
HISTORY AND CONTEXT FOR THE REPUBLIC
The Republic is encyclopediac, addressing in great depth and with wide reach the domains and spheres of philosophy, from
education, to ethics, to politics, and beyond. Among the fundamental questions to ask in reading the text is why Plato deemed all
these topics essential to the question of the just.
About a third of the The Republic is dedicated to a fierce criticism of Athenian poets and their mythologies - why would a book
about justice dedicate so much attention to art? For a book ostensibly about politics, why spend so much time talking about
education? The Republic, which heavily criticizes myth, ends with a myth of its own known as the “Myth of Er” – what are we to
make of this and how does this shape our understanding of Plato’s critique of mythology and the success of Socrates and his
interlocutors in responding to Thraysmachus’ challenge?
Some Important Events
All dates are BCE (before common era).
c. 470: Socrates born
431: Peloponnesian War between Athens and Sparta begins
430/29: Plague in Athens kills approximately 1/4 of the population
find more resources at oneclass.com
find more resources at oneclass.com
You're Reading a Preview
Unlock to view full version
Loved by over 2.2 million students
Over 90% improved by at least one letter grade.