Class Notes (836,424)
Canada (509,786)
Philosophy (142)
PHIL 330 (7)
E.L. (7)
Lecture 5

PHIL 330 Lecture 5: PHIL 330 Lecture 5

2 Pages
Unlock Document

PHIL 330

find more resources at Thrasymachus: heis name means bold in battle -▯ot a▯ a▯▯ide▯tal ▯hara▯ter ▯hoi▯e ▯wild ▯east▯, ▯lio▯▯. Is a▯gry soo▯ as he ▯egi▯s—why? He does▯’t agree with Socrates views and behaviour. Thrasymachus believes he knows best; he is angry because Polemarchus would no longer hire him to teach rhetoric and receive payment, when Polemarchus pledges allegiance to philosophy. The loss of a wealthy customer to philosophy. -Thrasymachus insists that Socrates gives a definition himself, rather than setting others up to fail: sets parameters of justice being the right, the beneficial, the advantageous [336D]. Socrates insists he cannot provide a definition on those terms, because he is not sure that justice is NOT the advantageous and the beneficial. -Socrates likely already knows what his definition of justice is, but he does not know it to be true; but also he has been prevented from using words he would use. Socrates has informed Polemarchus of his own ignorance in the Socratic style -Thrasymachus will give his own definition but will include the words he just banned Socrates from using. Socrates claims he cannot give the definition of justice in compliance with these terms. Thrasymachus characterization: he is hypocritical, petty. Intellectual dishonesty: undermining the rules set by oneself. Sophistry: winning the argument is most important, not getting to the truth Thrasymachus defines justice as:. So justice is what is advantageous to the stronger. - obedience to laws, rules, and customs [nomoi]. Citizens are obligated to obey these rules which are in the best interest of the ruler, who is the stronger of the two parties Obedience out of fear of punishment; and the reward of not being punished when one is obedient. Just individuals (rule followers) benefit the rulers the most—they only benefit themselves in the sense that they avoid punishment -psychology: conventional morality; a non natural form of morality in which one acts to avoid certain things. Justice is conventional in the sense that the stronger party makes the rules -nomos: the greek word for law, which can be translated as both law and custom -Thrasy▯a▯hus ▯o▯▯edes that rulers ▯a▯ ▯ake ▯istakes: they ▯ake rules or laws whi▯h are i▯ their ▯ow▯ i▯terest▯ ▯ut a▯tually u▯der▯i▯e their ▯est i▯terests/receiving some sort of harm -according to this: rulers can do what is both advantageous and disadvantageous to oneself by acting justly Pole▯ar▯hus takes the side of “o▯rates; Cleitopho▯ takes Thrasy▯a▯hus’ side. Why does Cleitophon interject only this one time?—rejects Socrates refutation on the grounds that he has understood it wrong 340b: Cleitophon defines justice as what the ruler BELIEVES IS BEST FOR HIM (in this sense, the definition is purely power based—a dangerous view that power and control define justice) -Thrasymachus argues Cleitophon is also wrong: will make a statement about the ruler as a ruler The ruler, in a philosophical manner: the ruler is a ruler in so far as he acts like a ruler (the notion of genuine rule is a type of knowledge, a type of techne) A ruler who makes a mistake is a failure in the concept of ruler based on his failure. [341a] When the ruler is deficient in knowledge only then will he make a mistake; at this point, he would not e a skilled worker of his craft -Thrasymachus has conceded we all make mistakes; but real ruling would then be impossible because no one can never make mistakes. Thus justice is impossible sinc
More Less

Related notes for PHIL 330

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.