NUR 80A/B Lecture Notes - Lecture 11: Jargon, Imrad
Document Summary
Nur80 week 11 chapter 17: criiquing research reports. Student is expected to be comprehensive with atenion paid to all ive dimensions of a report, which include: substanive and theoreical, methodologic, ethical, interpreive, and presentaional. Student criiques are comprehensive to an extent because they are not required to be suiciently knowledgeable about the content. Students are also not expected to evaluate the qualiicaions of a research team, which is more prevalent in other types of criiques: conducted by other researchers (peer reviewers) to assist journal editors with publicaion decisions. Known as refereed journals, which are oten more presigious than non-refereed journals. A blind review, involves two or more anonymous peers who are experts in the ield criiquing a study. i. Ideniies of the authors and peer reviewers are not disclosed. Focuses on methodologic and indings of related studies. For example, a meta-analyst would focus more on the quality of the evidence than on ethical aspects of the studies reviewed.
