Class Notes (838,093)
Canada (510,678)
Philosophy (401)
PHIL 120W (84)
Sam Black (30)


4 Pages
Unlock Document

Sam Black

October 24, 2012 – PHIL 1102 Relationship, friendship, now we’re moving onto prostitution Two prostitution articles: 1. Arkes – page 229 2. Ericsson – page 239 Prostitution  Started at 2500 BC o List of permissions included transvestite entertainers, and male/female prositutes  1075 BC – Asserians – “If the wives of a man, or the daughters of a man, their heads shall be veiled. But if the prositutes go onto the street, they shall not be veiled” o Hetaira – female companions, higher up prositutes, accompany higher-up men not necessarily for sex  Pericles had a hetaera named Aspaezia o Lower level – cortizans and prostitutes  Roman period o Rent from brothels = legitimate source of income  What is prostitution – sexual relationships as a result of o Noncoercive o Mutual o Involving neither love or affection o Financial transaction Arkes – Prostitution is morally impermissible  Reaction to Goldman’s idea that sex is just a physical phenomena  His argument: Prostitution is intrinsically bad – something morally wrong with prostitution itself o The act itself is wrong  Doesn’t argue against prostitution using its bad consequences  It’s wrong not because of its bad consequences, but it’s wrong because it is wrong in itself o Goldman said the opposite, that it’s morally neutral  Just because that there’s a rise in pickpocketing during a Yankees baseball game, doesn’t mean that baseball is wrong itself.  Positive part of his account: we traditionally take the word prostitute as a term of contempt, we look down on it (i.e., insulting someone using the word whore which is linked to prostitution)  why we have this contempt for prostitution o The disparity that is related to a loving sexual act, and the kind of sex that is involved in prostitution; prostitution sex isn’t associated with love and all that is related to it. o Sex is deeply personal. It is inextricably linked to love. o Marriage vs. prostitution  Page 233 “Prostitution inescapably implies . . .“ o Animal-like, hydraulic action  play on words  Does not argue against actual prostitution and buying sex, argues more against the lack of genuine affection October 24, 2012 – PHIL 1102  Encases idea of sex within the context of marriage  Not a committed loving relationship so therefore it’s bad.  Looks at Goldman’s example of rape (it’s bad because of how people treat each other, not the actual sex) o Arkes disagrees o Says there is something fundamentally different about sex than other kinds of activities o Different in ways that are morally significant o Sex is not like playing golf or driving a car  Page 236 “There was an awareness. . .”  There’s something about sex that makes it worse than other activities  Rape is worse than other activities in which you are taken advantage of because it involves sex o i.e., Rape is worse than pickpocketing  Why does he bring up rape in his argument for prostitution?  We don’t regard sex as morally on par with other activities; therefore prostitution is morally inferior to other types of sexual activities (the ones involved in marriage). Ericsson – Prostitution is morally permissible Common Charges against Prostitution 1. The conventional morality charge – Common view that prostitution is bad because it is morally bad and should be stopped.  Why do we have this hostile view of prostitution? Sociological reason? o Because of its relationship to reproduction and a monogamous marriage o Prostitution doesn’t cater to monogamy o We follow along with what people think o Sex should best be represented by marriage o Prostitution doesn’t represe
More Less

Related notes for PHIL 120W

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.