Class Notes (835,754)
Canada (509,376)
Sociology (803)
SOC345 (18)

Dr. Mookerjea - Cultural Studies 10

4 Pages
Unlock Document

Sourayan Mookerjea

SOCIOLOGY 345 Politics of Meaning & Technology - Marshall McLuhan Insofar as McLuhan theorizes this new global consciousness ie TV internet etc. (the global village/noosphere) as a consciousness of CULTURAL BORDER-LINES. for innis too the ideas of the margins of empire was important in thinking about technology and communications. INTERPRET MCLUHAN: if you construct a story of human history that is a story of major moments in the centers of empires ie greece to rome to Great Britain to usa, that if that is the line of history and its major moments, we see both in mcluhan and innis that we must think about historical change in a NON-LINEARWAY. if it is the case that we move from one high point to yet another high point, then there must be a history of the margins of those events and places. they want to write history from other points of view, not the victors, but the losers and the ordinary people. this is counter-environment. think of counter-environments are historically those processes of subalternization, the ways people become marginalized. they don't disappear from history but persist in their ways and contribute to the official histories in their invisible ways. RESONATING INTERVAL idea from music - to hear a melody, there must be a relation in time between two notes or more. as one note is struck, it fades away as anotehr note is struck. you hear the second note in relation to the first note. instead of being a linear succession of one note after another, you have an ebb and flow relation between one note in time and another note in time. in gestalt psychology it is yes there is a succession of notes, but your mind turns it into meaningfull music (as opposed to just sound) by taking the succession and uniting it as a whole. - this is the idea McLuhan is using to discuss history. - this is why he calls this television world (unlike print culture) acoustic space because it calls for our brains to be active in a different way. - the resonating interval of television and new medias, this acoustic space, is a new way for us to actually experience life, a new way of thinking! compare to Kant on Space and Time as conditions for the possibility of intuition (transcendental aesthetics). SEMIOTICS STUART HALL & ROLAND BARTHES We will connect the ideas of Myth to the ideas of Ideology. ENLIGHTENMENT Truth / Error : Science / Religion : Modern / Primitive : Science / Myth in relation to this kind of scheme that our ordinary usage of myth as errors etc comes from. but we also have another common usage of the meaning myth: greek mythology etc like important stories to a culture. Compare back to Maurice Charland's use of the word myth to describe technological nationalism. Claude Leví-Strauss - an anthropologist influenced by linguistic structuralism / semiology (Saussure). He had an anti-racist argument debunking 19c theories of race, saying that the savage mind is no different than the most industrially advanced engineer because human minds work in terms of binary oppositions universally. the difference between the savage mind and the engineer is that they deal with different issues and try to solve different problems. the deeper logic of reasoning, however, is the same. In this respect, myth is no longer simply falsehood or error but the way in which we make the world meaningful. Barthes creates a theory of ideology discussing myth in the same way as Levi-Strauss discusses myth but with reference to the contemporary world of spectacle. Semiotics believes there is a dimension of meaning grounded in matter in some kind of way. Barthes: If the world of matter, of material production, has a politics of production like marx outlined, then there is a politics of the production of meaning. SEMIOTICS TOWARD A MATERIALISTPOLITICS OF MEANING REPRESENTATION re-present-ation present in time, present in space. re-presentation means to repeat that presence. • art • language, linguistics, literature • politics • meda • knowledge, science, philosophy in the domain of art one discusses representation in terms of meaning: what does this work mean? ie nonfigural paintings like malevich's white on white - what does this represent? at this time so much was happening in painting that there was a crisis of representation. does painting represent or not represent. with the birth of photography, a technology that can capture mimetically an object with great precision, it is no longer and aesthetic challenge to paint an apple perfectly. this is when the impressionists emerge and modernism. music is the thorniest of them all: does music represent anything? in politics, when it comes to our basic attempts to articulate what we mean by democracy, representation is crucial. it is governemtn by representation of the people by elected officials. so unless your interests are represented you don't have democratic legislation. - once unions are legalized and you have legalized collective bargaining (this only happens after the Second World War), you have the representation of labour and capital in bourgeois liberal democracies. both interests are now lega▯y represented. but what happens when the labour movement sells out women and immigrants and a bunch of workers, you have a crisis of representation there too. in media, what kinds of people are represented in the media, how are women represented, marginalized groups, etc. in terms of knowledge, science, philosophy, after descartes there's a new definition of knowledge where knowledge is no longer what is revealed to you in some way but rather knowledge is a representation of an object to a subject. knowledge has to be of something, it has to represent that something, whether it is an apple or the structure of an atom, or the anatomy of a human, and has to be represented to a human mind. the word REPRESENTATION cuts across all these different domains of inquiry. the word lets us therefore think about the relations between all these different domains? ie how is art connected to knowledge or media connected to language etc. since cultural studies looks at rep
More Less

Related notes for SOC345

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.