Class Notes (836,147)
Canada (509,656)
POLS 3710 (15)
Jordi Diez (15)
Lecture

oct 24 .docx

6 Pages
58 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Political Science
Course
POLS 3710
Professor
Jordi Diez
Semester
Fall

Description
Oct 24 notes Identity Politics and the Politics of Recognition - what is identity politics? - identity, inclusion and citizenship - the meaning of citizenship - Iris Young’s concept of ‘differential citizenship’ - inclusive Understandings of human development - sexual citizenship - 3 types of sexual rights - Isaiah Berlin’s concept of negative & positive rights - the evolution of identity politics - context - 2 -wave feminism - gay and lesbian mobilization - identity politics and transition Identity Politics - rise of movements gave rise to literature - trying to explain emergence of movements - idea of an identity – different from other movements - new social movements – involve class, collective identities - developed through social organization and mobilization - talking about objectives/strategies to become a collective identity - struggles against oppression - citizenship – who belongs? Who has right to exercise rights? - creates categories - mobilize around collective identities - bring about change - mode of organization, intimately connected that some social groups are oppressed - makes one vulnerable to cultural domination - makes who you are, oppressed – racial profiling - identity = group membership, belonging - also about what has excluded you, and turning into the driving force * self through consciousness raising - one of the most marginalized – transgendered people - only live til 33 (average) - Argentina – demedicalized, decriminalized gender - consciousness raising - build a community - followed what women, African American and gay/lesbian have done - realized they all had similar situations/needs/experiences - realized collectiveness - gay/lesbian different than black – because they are oppressed at the home as well – no output or support in private life - group formation, share experiences, needs, desires - variety of numerous groups - creation of subjects Oct 24 notes - new entity seeking rights  becomes a subject - before was invisible - based on characteristics based in the past the oppress them - demand for respect as one for being different - criticisms: 1) push of demanding rights based on collective identity, urges people to mobilize around 1 axes, identify self with those characteristics – their defining feature and how they will interact with society - applies pressure to identify self with the identifying features - concept of intersectionality - overlapping of identities people have - come from queer theory - we can develop multiple identities 2) has a disciplinary effect – in order to gain some rights you have to enhance those traits that have formed the basis for your exclusion, but those will discipline you as an individual - becomes repetitive - also dictating them self understanding of how they should be - may inhibit autonomy - replacement of one tyranny with another - those who don’t conform to group are marginalized Identity, Inclusion and Citizenship - new forms of belonging - citizenship = rights - citizenship = belonging, membership in a group then comes rights & responsibilities - who belongs, who doesn’t? - core of political science - North America – if born on soil, you are a citizen - Europe – who you are related to, not until you are 18 - core of identity politics – its about rights, new type of membership into a society - relationship between individuals and state - Iris Young - differentiated citizenship: some people can only be fully citizens/integrated into society if their differences are taken into account - equality only guaranteed through the affirmation of group - distinctive needs - state has responsibility to take actions to encourage mechanisms of group representation and adopt group differentiation policies - ie. Need a certain number of women in your workplace – assign quotas based on those characteristics/traits to ensure they are included - criticisms: - idea of differentiated group rights violates principle of equality – which is the core of democracy - arbitrary, no objective way to determines which groups are deserving - leads to mistrust Oct 24 notes - inclusive development – include people by lifting ‘unfreedoms’ so they can freely participate in society - state has responsibility to intervene directly in lifting these unfreedoms Sexual Citizenship - recognition of alternative forms of sexuality and being legitimate - state sanctioning of alternative sexuality - expansion of rights - in order to participate equally in polity - sexual rights - theorization of rights - scholars theorize - jurice prudence – court rulings support - 3 main levels: 1) practice - right to practice - forms of sexual expression - impersonal relationships - right to be able to practice ones sexuality 2) expression - self-expression - development of identities - right to express ones right freely - public space - gay pride 3) relationship - most recent - rights to recognition of relationships that aren’t heteronormative - reform of institutions such as marriage - gay marriage - challenge heteronormativity, challenge to norms - Berlin’s – “two concepts of liberty” - negative and positive freedoms - positive – when state extends a right to you (gay marriage) - negative – righ
More Less

Related notes for POLS 3710

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit