Class Notes (834,627)
Canada (508,661)
Sociology (2,978)
SOC 2070 (342)
Lecture 2

SOC*2070 Readings Week 2

6 Pages
75 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Sociology
Course
SOC 2070
Professor
Linda Hunter
Semester
Winter

Description
Defining Deviance: A Culture of Voyeurism, Reality TV, Growing Up Online, News Programming and Mean World Syndrome On the Sociology of Deviance (Adler Ch 1 pg. 17-24) Studying Deviance - Erikson asserts that deviance and the social reactions it evokes are key focal concerns of every community - deviance leads us to continually redraw the social boundaries of acceptability - the very institutions and agencies mandated to manage deviance tend to reinforce it - society’s expectations that deviants will not reform foster the “self-fulfilling prophesy” - deviant behaviour in social units called “communities” - communities are boundary maintaining: each has a specific territory in the world as a whole - it controls the fluctuation of its consistent parts so that the whole retains a limited range of activity within the larger environment - the only material found in a society for marking boundaries is the behaviour of its members or rather, the networks of interaction which link these members together in regular social relations - boundaries are made clear through confrontations which occur when persons who venture out to the edges of the group are met by policing agents - confrontations between deviant offenders and the agents of control have always at- tracted a good deal of public attention - newspapers, radio and television offer much the same kind of entertainment as public hangings - boundaries are never a fixed property of any community, they are always shifting as the people of the group find new ways to define the outer limits of their universe - deviant behaviour is not a simple kind of leakage which occurs when the machinery of society is in poor working order but may be, in controlled quantities, an important con- dition for preserving the stability of social life - if we grant that human groups often derive benefit from deviant behaviour, can we then assume that they are organized in such a way as to promote this resource? - the criminal trial is the most obvious example of a commitment ceremony - an important feature of these ceremonies in our own culture is that they are almost ir- reversible An Integrated Typology of Deviance Applied to Ten Middle Class Norms (Adler Ch 2 pg. 25-40) - by cross-tabulating the dimensions of underconformity and overconformity with that of social evaluation, positive and negative, Heckert and Heckert yielded 4 types of de- viance: negative deviance, rate-busting, deviance admiration and positive deviance - this chapter applies this typology to a list of 10 middle-class norms - issues such as lying, disloyalty, hedonism, irresponsibility and invasion of privacy are “negative deviance” evaluated to see how such acts might translate into their deviance admiration, positive deviance and rate-busting counterparts A Typology of Deviance Integrating Normative and Reactivist Perspectives - cross-classified the significance of both norms and reactions, creating four possible scenarios - on the one hand, under-conformity or nonconformity that results in negative reactions - on the other hand, rate busting is over-conformity that is negatively evaluated - deviance admiration is underconformity or nonconformity that is positively approached - positive deviance is overconformity that receive positive reactions Negative Deviance - underconformity or nonconformity that is negatively evaluated - the “Jeffrey Dahmer phenomenon” - negative deviants can range from most criminals to the mentally ill to substance abusers Rate Busting - negatively appraised overconformity - the “Geek Phenomenon” - gifted students are often rejected by their peers - blond women are subjected to epic stereotyping, especially related to their intellectual capacity Deviance Admiration - underconformity or nonconformity that is favourably assessed - “John Gotti Phenomenon” - a fair number of criminals have been transformed from thugs to icons - e.g. Robin Hood, Billy the Kid - redheads Positive Deviance - overconformity that is responded to in a confirmatory fashion - “Mother Theresa Phenomenon” - good neighbors and saints - the physically attractive - positive reactions and evaluations flow often producing all kinds of added advantages, the response transcends even the norm at stake Normative Explanations Underconformity or Overconformity Nonconformity Social Reactions Negative Evalua- Negative Deviance Rate Busting and Collective Eval- tions uations Positive Evalua- Deviance Admira- Positive Deviance tions tion - this typology recognizes that the traditional distinction between normative expectations and societal reactions involves a false dichotomy and seeks to integrate normative defi- nitions with reactivist definitions - contexts have to be considered as audiences can differently react to the same behav- iour or conditions - e.g. elite tattoo collectors are simultaneously positive deviants to their subculture and negative deviants to the dominant society - deviance is relative and context is critical Norms and Predominant Middle-Class Norms in the United States - most commonly a norm has been defined as “a belief shared to some extent by mem- bers of a social unit as to what conduct ought to be in particular situations or circum- stances” - norms could be dually conceptualized between the idealized and the more realistic - the more idealized are really values: achievement and success, individualism, a
More Less

Related notes for SOC 2070

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit