POLI 347 Lecture Notes - Lecture 1: John Stuart Mill, Critical Legal Studies, Legal Education

23 views2 pages
8 Aug 2016
Sep 9
Plato: The Tyrant, The Rule of Law, and The Philosopher-Ruler
-Contrasts law w/tyranny; the problem with tyranny is that there are no citizens. The fear
developed by tyrants eliminates the possibility of civilization.
-Law provides as a framework for diversity and is therefore important.
-Law allows for: diversity, citizens, and civilization.
-Concerns for the future/critiques of law:
oPeople don’t appreciate what they have.
oPutin  wants to re-create the Soviet Union. Marx  communism/no need for
law/capitalist: The ruler of men becomes replaced with the administration of things
oRadical feminists: law is just male power
oCritical legal studies (neomarxist): Law is about organized power
oLegal education is training for the hierarchy. What classes can make you money?
-2 theories of law:
1) Law is a neutral system of rules that provides peace and order w/options (Hyek)
Letwin favors this one
2) Law has a purpose that creates a certain kind a citizen with a certain kind of life. A
form of education that pushes you in a direction (Aristotle)
Plato’s Life: 427-347 BC; Athens: The death of Socrates. Plato vs Pericles
Plato on Law: a) The Crito; b) The Republic; c) The Statesman, The Laws
-Democracy is a problem. It is the enemy of philosophy.
-Tyranny is the worst regime, democracy is the second worse.
-Democracy leads to tyranny because it breaks down by the equality of everyone’s opinions.
-Democracy makes us think of the public good
-It doesn’t force us to do anything
-No ruling class
-Plato on democracy: A democratic man is selfish and doesn’t care about the public good
How many Platos? A) Letwin on 2 theories of law in Plato; b) Plato’s development and
possibly 3 approaches to law in Plato
-Young Plato (Crito)
1) Not really what Plato believed in. And instead what he thought that Socrates or
someone that he admired would approve of.
-Middle and Old Plato
1) Starts developing his own ideals
2) In the Republic, there are ‘true’ things and there are ‘truths’. In contrast w/Crito and
the ideals of Socrates, where he believes that there isn’t a definite answer.
3) Law is a utopian idea
4) Plato favors which regime? Spartan regime
Plato’s basic premise and critique of democracy:
a) rule by a tyrant is unacceptable but the alternative is not democracy
b) Athenian democracy means absolute equality and unlimited freedom under: law which
leads to anarchy and then tyranny
find more resources at oneclass.com
find more resources at oneclass.com
Unlock document

This preview shows half of the first page of the document.
Unlock all 2 pages and 3 million more documents.

Already have an account? Log in

Get access

$10 USD/m
Billed $120 USD annually
Homework Help
Class Notes
Textbook Notes
40 Verified Answers
Study Guides
1 Booster Class
$8 USD/m
Billed $96 USD annually
Homework Help
Class Notes
Textbook Notes
30 Verified Answers
Study Guides
1 Booster Class