Class Notes (1,100,000)
CA (620,000)
UOttawa (30,000)
CMN (2,000)
Lecture 12

CMN4105 Lecture 12: Tab 8


Department
Communication
Course Code
CMN 4105
Professor
Mark Lowes
Lecture
12

This preview shows pages 1-3. to view the full 12 pages of the document.
!"#$%&'#('#)%*+,-(
!
!"#$%&%'()
./0+1(-/2'#31(',(+,3(4/",-(
!
!*&*%&%'+,"&
5/,64#"0'-+(7/#*(/7(3+'&",)(",(-8"1($'1+9(28"$8("1(,/-($/0+#+3(%,3+#(-8+(!!:(!','3"',(
1+-
!'-+)/#"+1(;(-/(<
!'-+)/#=(>("1(-8+#+(-+'$8(1'"3(=/%(3/(-8"1((
?8/1+(;;(@%3"$"'&(#+0"+21(2/%&3(,/-(8'0+(A++,($/4"+3(A=(-8+(&"A(4'-#/,1("7(
-8+=(2+#+,B-(#+C%+1-
!!:(D+#0"$+(2'1('-(-8+(#+C%+1-(/7(-8+(&'2=+#1(E(4'-#/,1
!
F,(-8"1($'1+(-8+1+(1-%3+,-1(2+#+(,/-(#+C%+1-",)(-8+($/4"+1(
!
G,(-8+(C%+1-"/,(/7(-8+($%1-/*(48/-/$/4=(1+#0"$+(-8'-H1(28+#+(!!:(!','3"',(3"77+#1(
7#/*(I&A+#-'($'1+J
!!:(',3(I&A+#-'($'1+(-8+=('#+('A1/&%-+&=(3"1-",)%"18'A&+(7#/*(-8+(7'$-1(',3(
$/,-+K-(/7(+3%$'-"/,(
!
?8+(0+#=(,'-%#+(/7(+3%$'-"/,("1(1%$8(-8'-(0+#=($/,-+K-(/#($/,$+4-(/7(-+'$8",)("1(
1%$8(-8'-(-+'$8+#1('1(4'#-(/7(-8+"#(@/AE+3%$'-"/,'&(+,0"#/,*+,-9(2"&&(*'L+(
$/4"+1('11"),(-8+*(-/(1-%3+,-1(+-$J
!
F,(-8'-($/,-+K-(1-%3+,-1(2"&&(#+C%+1-(-+'$8+#1(-/(*'L+($/4"+1
!
F-H1('(7'&1+(3"1-",)%"18*+,-(-8+,(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#(
!
?8+(3"$8/-/*=(AE2(-+'$8+#1(',3(1-%3+,-1(
!
M8+-8+#(/#(,/-(-8+#+("1(",(7'$-('(A/,'(7"3+(3"1-",)%"18'A&+(/7(@%3)+*+,-(",(!!:(
I(3"1-",$-($/,$+4-%'&"N'-"/,(/7(-+'$8+#1(',3(-8+"#(#/&+1(",(-8+($/,-+K-(/7(+3%$'-"/,
G,(-8+(/,+(1"3+(=/%(8'0+(-+'$8+#1(-8+,(-8+#+("1('(1+4'#'-+($/,$+4-%'&"N'-"/,(/7(-8+(
1-%3+,-
M8'-(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(3/+1(",('$$+4-",)('$$+11($/4=#")8-B1('#)%*+,-1(
?8'-H1(-8+(1+-(%4(",(-+#*1(/7(28'-('$$+11($/4=#")8-("1('#)%",)
!
D/(-+'$8+#(',3(1-%3+,-(28'-('#+(-8+"#(#/&+1(
!
?8+=('#+(*'L",)(-8+(48/-/$/4"+1
!
O"-8+#('-(-8+(#+C%+1-(/7(-8+(1-%3+,-1(/#('-(-8+"#(/2,(","-"'-"0+
!
I,3(-8+,(3"1-#"A%-",)(-8/1+($/4"+1(-/(1-%3+,-1((
!
?8+(7"#1-('44#/K"*'-"/,("1(@%1-(%,3+#1-',3(-+'$8+#E$/4"+#
!
?8+#+7/#+("7(=/%(8'0+(-8'-(3"1-",$-"/,(-8+,(1-%3+,-1(2/%&3(A+(-8+(
%1+#1
!
!*",-*.)"/),%0+*.
1$#2*3$/)"/)#/*./))
?8+"#(#/&+1(+11+,-"'&&=("1P
!
?8+(7"#1-($/,$+4-%'&(3"1-",$-"/,("1(AE2(-+'$8+#(',3(1-%3+,-(
I$$+11(1'=1(-+'$8+#1(*'L+($/4"+1(/7(A//L1(-8'-(-8+=(8'0+(#")8-1(-/(
!
F-1(,/-(8/2(-8+=('#+(*'L",)(-8+($/4"+1("1(-8+(4#/A&+*("-1(8/2(-8+=('#+(3+'&",)(
-8+($/4"+1
!
I$$+11("1(1'=",)(-+'$8+#1('#+(+,)')",)(",(%,7'"#(3+'&",)
!
4,,*//)5%0(.+'-$)
?'&L",)(4#/4/#-"/,1
!
?8+('*/%,-(/7(3+'&",)("1($/,$+#,+3(2"-8(4#/4/#-"/,'&"-=
!
Q/%(-'L+(-8+(2/#L(",(C%+1-"/,9(2/#L(-8'-("1(A+",)(3+'&-9(28'-("1(-8+(4#/4/#-"/,(
/7(2/#L(-8'-("1(A+",)(3+'&-(',3("1("-(',(%,7'"#('*/%,-(/7(-8'-(2/#LR
!
F7(=/%('#+(1-#+'*",)('(4#+0"+2(/7('(1/,)(-8'-("1(S(*",(-8'-("1(%,7'"#(4#/4/#-"/,(/7(
-8+(2/#L(",(3+'&",)
!
T++4(",(*",3(-8+(&/)"$(/7(8/2(-8+('*/%,-(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#9(8/2("-(
2'1('44&"+3(28+,(2+(1-%3"+3(4#+0"+21(
!
Q/%(-'L+(-8'-(&/)"$(-8+,(=/%(A#",)("-(-/(I&A+#-'(+3%$'-"/,9(28'-(=/%(8'0+(-8+,("1(
'($/4=#")8-+3(2/#L(-8'-("1(A+",)(3+'&-(2"-8
!
M8+,(=/%(8+'#("6%#3$ /7(-8+(2/#L(",(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#
F1(-8+(2/#L(2/#-8(3"11+*",'-",)(
!
F,(-8"1($'1+(28'-("1(-8+(,'-%#+(/7(-8+(2/#L(",(-8"1($'1+(
!
?8"1(2'1(,/-(/,+(/7(-8+(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(3+'&-(2"-8(*'@/#"-=(",(-8+(D!!
!
M8'-("1(-8+(3"$#.* /7(-8+(2/#L(-8+,R
?8"1("1(-8+(*/1-(1"),"7"$',-(/,+
?8"1("1(28+,(2+($/*+(",-/(-8+("3+'(/7(%,3+#1-',3",)(-8+(#/&+(/7(-8+(
-+'$8+#(',3(-8+(#/&+(/7(-8+(1-%3+,-
?8+(#/&+(/7(-8+(-+'$8+#("1(-8+($/4"+#9(#/&+(/7(-8+(1-%3+,-("1(%1+#
?8+(4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(=/%(8'0+(-/(&//L(',3($/,1"3+#(28'-("1(-8+(
4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(
M8+,(=/%('#+('44&=",)(-8"1(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#(/7(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(
"-H1(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+9(7#/*(28/1+(4+#14+$-"0+(3/(2+($/,1"3+#(",(-8+(3+'&",)(
',3(28+-8+#("-1(7'"#
U1+#1(#")8-1($/,$+4-
!
F,(DG!I5(0J(V+&&(2"-8(-8+(*%1"$(4#+0"+219(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+(=/%(-'L+("-H1(-8+(
4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-8+(+,3(%1+#J(
M8+,(=/%(8'0+(-8+(4#/A&+*(/7(*%1"$(4#+0"+21(-8+1+(A%1",+11+1(-8'-(
'&&/2(4+/4&+(-/(4#+0"+2(1/,)1(A+7/#+(4%#$8'1",)(-8+*9(-8'-(1-"&&(3+'&",)(
",(-8+($/4=#")8-+3(2/#L1
F,(DG!I5(0J(V+&&(!','3'(-8+(/&3(A%1",+11(*/3+&(2'1(-'L",)(7#/*(-8+(/&3(
7'18"/,(",(1-/#+(&"1-+,",)(-/(4#+0"+21(-/(/,&",+(1-#+'*",)(/7(4#+0"+21J
?8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3($/,$&%3+3(-8+(-+'$8+#('1(-8+($/4"+#(
?+'$8+#('1($/4"+#9(-8'-(A+$/*+1(-8+(3/*",',-(4+#14+$-"0+
7#.0%/*)
!
.'@/#"-=('33#+11+1(>(/7(-8+(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(",(-8"1($'1+(
?8+(-+'$8+#('1('($/4"+#(
!
5/2(2+(8'0+(-/(&//L('-(-8"1(7#/*(-8+(#/&+(/7(-8+(-+'$8+#
!
?8"1(7/$%1(/,(-8+(-+'$8+#(#+1%&-1(",(-8+(1$+,'#"/(28+#+A=(-8"1("1(,/-('(3+'&",)(7/#(
-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(.*/*".,-)%.)789:4!;)1!<=>J
!
?8+(4+#14+$-"0+(-8'-(2'1('3/4-+3(A=(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(2'1P
M8'-('$$+11($/4=#")8-('#)%+3(',3($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(')#++3
!
5/9(-8+=('#+(1%A@+$-(-/(#/='&-"+1(
M8+,(=/%(-'L+(4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#(',3(-/(3+-+#*",+(28+-8+#(/#(
,/-(-8+(48/-/$/4"+1(3"1-#"A%-+39("1(-8'-(7'"#(3+'&",)R
!
I&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(/7(7'"#(3+'&",)("1(#+1+'#$8(/#(4#"0'-+(1-%3=
!
M8+,(=/%('3/4-(4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#(=/%(,/(&/,)+#(8'0+(#+1+'#$8(
',3(1-%3=J
!
?8+(L+=(-+#*(-8+(2'=("-1($/,$+4-%'&"N+3("1(=/%(8'0+(",1-#%$-"/,
!
?8+(1-'-+(/7('77'"#(2'1('3/4-+3(',3('$$+4-+3(A=($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(',3(
1%A1+C%+,-&=(W+3+#'&($/%#-(/7('44+'&
!
M8'-(2+(8'0+(8+#+("1(',(",1-#%$-"/,9(-+'$8+#(48/-/$/4=",)(',3(8',3",)(-/(
1-%3+,-1(-/(1++(',3(#+'$8(-8+(48/-/$/4=9(-8+=('#+(1'=",)(-8'-H1(',(",1-#%$-"/,
!
D!!(3"3(,/-('#-"$%&'-+(",1-#%$-"/,('1(A+",)('&&/2'A&+(%1+39("-1(,/-('(7'"#(3+'&",)
!
F7("-1(,/-(7'"#(3+'&",)(-8+,('$$+11($/4=#")8-(2",1J(
!
M8'-("1(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(R
?8'-(3"1-",$-"/,(2'1(#+@+$-+3(A=(D!!(
!
F*4(-/(%,3+#1-',3(3"77+#+,$+(AE2(-8/1+(S($/,$+4-%'&"N'-"/,(/7(-+'$8+#('1('($/4"+#(
',3(1-%3+,-('1('(%1+#
?8"1(8'1(+0+#=-8",)(-/(3/(2"-8(%,3+#1-',3",)(-8+(+K4',1"0+(",-+#/4+#'-"/,()"0+,(-/(
+3%$'-"/,(A=(-8+(*'@/#"-=(/7(D!!(",(-8"1($'1+9(-8+=(8'0+(-'L+,(-8"1($/,$+4-(/7(1-%3=J
?8+(3+7","-"/,(/7(#+1+'#$8('1(',('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(2'1(A#/'3+,(-#+*+,3/%1&=(",(
DG!I5(0J(V+&&
F-(A+$/*+1(-8+($/#+(",-+&&+$-%'&($'1+(
!
Q/%($',-(8'0+(4#"0'-+(1-%3=("7(-8+#+B1(,/(4%A&"$(1-%3=
!
F-($',(/,&=(+K"1-(",(/44/1"-"/,(-/(1/*+-8",)(+&1+
!
5/2(2+(4"$L(%4(/,(4#"0'-+(1-%3=
X+4+,3",)(",(-8+(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-9(4#"0'-+(/#(4%A&"$(1-%3=("-1('&&(-8+(1'*+
!
F,1-#%$-"/,(7/&31(",-/(-8+($/,$+4-(/7(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(
!
?8"1("1(",(',(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-
!
?8+#+('#+(/-8+#($/,-+K-(=/%($/%&3(&//L('-(28+#+A=(-8+(#+'1/,",)(',3(4#+$+3+,-(
1+-(",(-8"1($'1+(*'=(,/-(A+('$$+4-+3
!
M8+,(2+('#+(3+'&",)(2"-8($/,$+4-(/7(+3%$'-"/,(-8+,(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(',3(
",1-#%$-"/,('#+(-8+(1'*+(-8",)
!
?8'-H1(/,+(/7(-8+(L+=('14+$-1(/7(D!!(",(-8"1($'1+(28+#+(-8+=($/##+$-+3('(0+#=(
1"),"7"$',-&=(%,#+'1/,'A&+(/%-$/*+(/7(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3B1(3+$"1"/,(
!
F-1($#%$"'&(-8'-(",1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-(1+4'#'-+3(7#/*("-1(A#/'3+#($/,$+4-(
!
X#"0",)('(2+3)+(AE2(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#(',3(1-%3+,-('1(%1+#(-8'-H1('#-"7"$"'&( ',3(
3'*')",)(',3($',,/-(1-',3J(
!
M8'-(-8+(/%-$/*+(/7(-8"1(@%3)+*+,-(3/+1(2"-8(#+14+$-(/7(*'@/#"-=(/7(D!!
D+4'#'-"/,("1(1/*+8/2(3"77+#+,-(7#/*(-+'$8",)('$$/#3",)(-/($/4=#")8-(A/'#3
!
?8+('#)%*+,-("1(A=(*'L",)(-8+1+($/4"+1(/,(-8+"#(/2,(","-"'-"0+9(8',3",)(-8+(-/(
1-%3+,-1(-8'-("1('(7/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,
!
I,3(D!!(#+@+$-1(-8"1('#)%*+,-(
!
93/$.#,$+%3)"1(1"),"7"$',-(8+#+
F-H1('(2'=(",(1%$8(-8'-($/,$+4-%'&"N",)(-8+($&'11#//*(',3(-8+(7/#*(/7(1-%3=(",(
1%$8(4&'$+
!
F,1-#%$-"/,(",(1/*+(3"1-",$-('$-"0"-=("1(4#/A&+*'-"$(
!
?8+('*%'."0-( /7(-8+($&'11#//*
M8+,(=/%(4%-("-(",(',(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-(-8+,(",1-#%$-"/,9(4#"0'-+(/#(4%A&"$(1-%3=("-1(
'&&(-8+(1'*+(-8",)(
M8'-(=/%(8'0+("1(",('(1$8//&(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-(",1-#%$-"/,(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=9(
-8+=('#+(-'%-/&/)"$'&9(-8+=(3/,H-(1+4'#'-+J
!
?8+(2+3)+(-8'-("1(1+4'#'-+3(AE2(",1-#%$-"/,(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(A=($/4=#")8-(
A/'#3("1(#+@+$-+3(A=(D!!J
!
!/4=#")8-(A/'#3(1'=1(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1('#+(+,)')+3(",('(7/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,(A=(
-8+(,'-%#+(/7(8/2(-8+=('#+(3+'&",)(2"-8(-8+($/4"+1J
!
F,1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-(',('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(7/#(7'"#(3+'&",)(%,3+#(-8+(!!:(!','3"',(
-+1-
!
W/#(7'"#(3+'&",)(-8+#+(8'1(-/(A+(/,+(/7(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+19(2+(8'0+(/,&=(
A++,($/,$+#,+3(2"-8(#+1+'#$8(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=J(
!
W/#(1-+4(;(-8+#+(2'1(,/(4#/A&+*9("-1('44&=",)(-8+(&/)"$(/7(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(-/(-8+(
7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(-8+*1+&0+1(
!
F-H1(-8+('44&"$'-"/,(7/(-8+($/,$+4-(/7(4#"0'-+(1-%3=
!
F-H1(-8+(7'"#,+11(+&+*+,-(-8'-H1('-("11%+
!
F-1(8/2(",(/-8+#(2/#31(28+-8+#(/#(,/-(3+'&",)("1(7'"#('-("11%+
!
?"+.)2*"&+3'
I$-(/7(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1
.'3+(A=(-+'$8+#1(-/(3"1-#"A%-+(-/(1-%3+,-1
I-(-8+(-+'$8+#B1(","-"'-"0+;J
Y/(A'$L(-/(!!:
!
:/2(=/%($/,$+4-%'&"N+(-8+(0+#=(,'-%#+(/7(1+#0"$+1(
!
M/#3(#+C%+1-("1($#%$"'&
!
I-(-8+(1-%3+,-B1(#+C%+1-(SJ
S('$-1
!&'11(",1-#%$-"/,
F1(-8"1('$-"0"-=('&&/2'A&+(7/#(-8+(4%#4/1+1(/7(-8+(7'"#(3+'&",)(+K$+4-"/,
Z'1-(1+,-+,$+
!
7".")@)0'A)@B)C-+'-&+'-$)&"$*.D
:/2('1(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#('$$+4-+3('1('($'-+)/#=
!
U,3+#1-',3(3"77+#+,$+(AE2($'-+)/#"+1(;6<(',3($'-+)/#=(>
!
;6<("1(&"-+#'&&=(28+#+(-8+=(#+$/#3(48/-/$/4"+1(*'3+(A=(-+'$8+#1(A%-(*'3+('(
#+C%+1-(/7(-8+(1-%3+,-1
!
Y/(A'$L(-/(!!:(-/(%,3+#1-',3(-8+(1"*"&'#(4#'$-"$+( 28+#+A=(-8+(1",)&+($/4"+1(/7(
-8+($/4=#")8-+3(&+)'&(2/#L1(",(!!:(*'3+('-(-8+(#+C%+1-(/7(-8+(4'-#/,1(
!
?8'-('14+$-(/7(!!:(!','3"',
!
7".")E
!'-+)/#=(>(
!
!/4"+1(2+#+(*'3+('-(-+'$8+#1(","-"'-"0+1(
!
7".")F
!/,$&%1"/,(/7($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(
!
F3+'(/7('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+1
!
V/'#3($/,$&%3+3(-8'-($'-+)/#=(>($/4"+1(2+#+(*'3+('-(-+'$8+#B1(","-"'-"0+(',3("-(
2'1(7/#(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(/7(#+1+'#$8(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=([1-+4(;\
!
V%-(28+,(=/%(*/0+(-/(1-+4(S(/7(!!:(-+1-9($'-+)/#=(>($/4"+1(3"3(,/-($/,1-"-%-+(
7'"#(3+'&",)(',3(2+#+(-8+#+7/#+(1%A@+$-(-/(#/='&-=
!
7".")G
?8+(7+3+#'&($/%#-(/7('44+'&($/,$&%3+3(-8'-($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(",(-+#*1(/7(8/2(
-8+=(3+'&-(2"-8($'-+)/#=(>('-(-8+(-+'$8+#1(","-"'-"0+9(-8+=(2+#+(,/-(7'"#(3+'&",)(
',3(-8+=(1'"3(-8'-(3+-+#*",'-"/,(A=($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(2'1(-/-'&&=(#+'1/,'A&+
!
7".")@H
D!!(1'"3(-8+1+('#)%*+,-1('#+(%,#+'1/,'A&+
!
?8+(*'@/#"-=(D!!(')#++(2"-(-8+($/'&"-"/,('#)%*+,-
!
?8+=(3/(,/-('$$+4-('$$+11($/4=#")8-1('#)%*+,-1('$$+4-+3(A=($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(
',3(%48+&3(A=(-8+(7+3+#'&($/%#-(/7('44+'&(
!
7".")@@
5/2(2+('#+(*/0",)(",-/(/-8+#(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#
F-(2'1(-8+(C%+1-"/,(/7(-8+('44&"$'-"/,(/7(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(A=(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(-8'-(
'#+('-("11%+J
?8+(D!!(')#++1(2"-8(I&A+#-'(+3%$'-"/,($/'&"-"/,(-8'-(-8+(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(2+#+(
",$/##+$-&=('44&"+3(A=(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3J
?8+(A"))+1-(',3(*/1-(4#/A&+*'-"$("1(-8+(0#.0%/*)7'$-/#J(
]+0"+2(/7(!!:(!','3"',(-+1-
!
7".")@I
F-H1(-8+(*'@/#"-=(@%3)+*+,-(-8'-(3+-+#*",+1(8/2(-8",)1(2/#L(
V")($/,$+#,("1()/",)(-/(A+(*',')",)(3")"-'&(*'-+#"'&1(',3(*',')",)(-8+($#+'-/#1(',3(
%1+#1(#")8-1J
I44#+$"'-",)(-8+("*4&"$'-"/,1(/7(-8+(D!!(",(-8+($/,-+K-(/7(%1+#1(#")8-1(",(',(
+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-J
?8+("*4&"$'-"/,1(/7(-8+(@%3)+*+,-('#+(1%$8(-8'-(",(',(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-(28'-(3/+1(
-8'-(*+',(
?8+(3"1-",$-"/,(AE2(4#"0'-+(',3(4%A&"$(1-%3=("1(+77+$-"0+&=(+#'1+3(A=(D!!(
^'#'(;<6S_(*/1-("*4(7/#(3+-+#*",",)(7'"#(3+'&",)(
W"#1-(1-+4(7'"#(3+'&",)P(28+-8+#("-("1(7/#(4%#4/1+(/7(#+1+'#$8(/#(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(;J
?8+(7"#1-(1-+4(-8+(&',)%')+(#+1+'#$8(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=('#+(,/-(',("11%+(/#(
$/,$+4-%'&(4#/A&+*1
!
M8+#+(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(A+$/*+1('($/,$+4-%'&(4#/A&+*("1('-(1-+4(S(/7(-8+(!!:(
!','3"',(-+1-(28+#+A=(2+(3+-+#*",+(28'-B1(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(7'"#(3+'&",)
!
?8'-H1(28=(2+(8'0+('(!/4=#")8-(A/'#3(',3('$$+11($/4=#")8-('#)%",)(-8+(
)+/)#'48"$'&('14+$-(/7(-8+($&'11#//*
!
W/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,P(,/,64#"0'-+(1-%3=(
!
?8+($/,$+4-(/7(",1-#%$-"/,('1("-('44&"+1(8+#+(A/-8($/,,/-+1(',3(3+,/-+1('(4%A&"$(
7/#*(/7(1-%3=(-8'-(-'L+1(4&'$+(",(-8+($&'11#//*9(",(-8+($/,-+K-("-1(,/-(4#"0'-+J(
!
?8+(4/",-("1("-1(,/-(`4#"0'-+`
!
F,1-#%$-"/,(-8+#+7/#+(",('($&'11#//*(-8'-(7/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-(4#"0'-+(
!
Y+,+#'&&=("-1('$$+4-+3(-8'-(/L(-8+#+B1(,/("11%+(8+#+(/,('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(/7(
#+1+'#$8(',3(1-%3=9(-8'-H1(,/-(-8+("11%+J(M8'-($/*+1(-/("11%+("1(-8+(2/#3(
`4#"0'-+`(
!
?8+(3"1-",$-"/,(1+-(%4(A=(-8+(A/'#3(
?8"1("1('(7/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,9(,/-(4#"0'-+(1-%3=
!
7".")@B
M8'-B1(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)("-1+&7SJ
F,(DG!I5(0J(V+&&(!','3'(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(",(-8'-($'1+(2'1(1-#+'*",)(
,/-(3/2,&/'3",)J([-8'-H1("*4\
!
M8'-("1(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(",(-8"1($'1+P(0-%$%,%0(+3'
!
Q+1("-("1(A+$'%1+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)("-1(48/-/$/4=",)
^8/-/$/4=",)('1(',('$-"0"-=(",(',(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,$+4-("1('$$+4-'A&+(7/#(
4#"0'-+(1-%3=(/#(#+1+'#$8J(
?8'-H1(28=(-8+#+B1(,/-('(4#/A&+*('-(1-+4(;(
Q/%(8'0+(-/(7/$%1(/,(-8+("3+'(/7(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)P(
48/-/$/4=",)(",(-8+(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-
W/#(-8+(7"#1-(4'#-(/7(!!:9(1'=1("1(-8+(3+'&",)(7/#(/,+(/7(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+1R
!
M8+#+("-(A+$/*+1(-8+(4#/A&+*(28"$8(+11+,-"'&&=($+,-#+3(/,(-8+(S,3(1-+4(/7(-8+(
-+1-
!
M8+-8+#(-8+($'-+)/#=(>($/4"+1([$/4"+1('-(-8+(","-"'-"0+(/7(-8+(-+'$8+#\(2+#+(7'"#J(
!
?8+=('#+(1'=",)(-8'-("1(,/-(7'"#(3+'&",)(A+$'%1+(28+,(=/%(&//L('-(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(
-8+(3+'&",)(28'-B1(-8+(7"#1-(-8",)(=/%(8'0+(-/($/,1"3+#9(D!!(1'"3(28/1+(
4+#14+$-"0+("1(-8"1(7#/*J(
!
^+#14+$-"0+(/7(-8+(-+'$8+#('1(-8+(48/-/$/4"+#9(',3(",1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-('(7'$-/#(/7(
7'"#,+11(",(!!:9(-8+#+7/#+("-1(,/-(',('&&/2'A&+(%1+('$$/#3",)(-/('$$+11($/4=#")8-(
'1(-8+=(1'=("-1(,/(28+#+(",(8+#+
!
F,1-#%$-"/,(",(-8"1($/,-+K-("1('(,/,64#"0'-+(1-%3=(-8+#+7/#+(-8+=(",0/L+(-8+(
$/,$+4-(/7(-8+()+/)#'48=(/7(-8+($&'11#//*(',3(-8+(,'-%#+(/7(-8+(",1-#%$-"/,(
-8'-(-'L+1(4&'$+(-8'-(&+'31(-/(-8+(%,#+'1/,'A&+($/,3%$-(A=(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(
',3(#/='&-"+1(*%1-(A+(4'"3('1(-8+=(3+-+#*",+("-1(,/-(7'"#(3+'&",)J
!
D!!(1'"3(-8+=('#+(2#/,)(
D+4'#'-"/,(AE2(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1(',3(-'L",)(",1-#%$-"/,(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(',3(
1+4'#'-",)(
!
?8+,(=/%('#+(4#/4+#&=(%,3+#1-',3",)(-8+(0+#=(7%,3'*+,-'&(,'-%#+(',3(
4%#4/1+(/7(+3%$'-"/,
Q/%($',-(1+4'#'-+(-8+*(",(-8"1($/,-+K-('-(&+'1-(
!
F-H1('(1=*A"/-"$(#+&'-"/,18"4(AE2(-+'$8+#1(',3(1-%3+,-1
93/$.#,$+%3)"32)0.+J"$*)/$#2()+/)$"#$%&%'+,"&
!
7".")@K
!'-+)/#=(;6<($/4"+1(2+#+(1-%3+,-(#+C%+1-+3($/4"+1
!
I-("11%+(8+#+('-(-8+(7'"#(3+'&",)(4#/A&+*(2+#+($'-+)/#=(>('1(-8+=(2+#+(,/-('-('(
1-%3+,-(#+C%+1-(-8+#+7/#+(A/'#3($/,$&%3+3(-8'-(-8+=('#+(,/-(7/#(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(
4#"0'-+(1-%3=
!
?8/1+('#+(S(0+#=(3"77+#+,-('$-1(-8'-(8'0+(4#/7/%,3("*4&"$'-"/,1(7/#(8/2(-8+(
$/4=#")8-(A/'#3(1+-(/%-(-/(3+-+#*",+(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(3+'&",)(',3(28+-8+#(-8'-(
3+'&",)(2'1(7'"#(
!
F,(!!:(-8+(48/-/$/4"+1(2+#+('-(-8+(`#+C%+1-`(/7(-8+(4'-#/,1(E(&'2=+#1(
!
D/(A+$'%1+(-8+#+(2'1(,/(1%$8(#+C%+1-(7/#($'-+)/#=(>($/4"+1(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(
",(-8"1($'1+($/,$&%3+(-8'-(-8+(4#+63/*",',-(4%#4/1+(2'1(*'",&=(-8'-(/7(-+'$8+#9(
*'",&=(",1-#%$-"/,(/#(`,/,64#"0'-+(1-%3=`J(
!
D!!(1'"3(-8'-H1(4#/A&+*'-"$('44#/'$8
W#/*(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-+'$8+#('1('($/4"+#
!
M8+,(=/%(7/$%1(/,(1-%3+,-1('1('(%1+#(-8+,(2+('#+(",0/L",)(%1+#B1(#")8-1
!
D!!(",(4#+0"/%1(@%3)+*+,-1(8'1(A++,(0+#=($&+'#(28+,(=/%(&//L('-(DJ(Sa(2"-8(
#+14+$-(-/(7'"#(3+'&",)1([%1+#B1(#")8-1\9(-8+(D!!(8'1(A++,(0+#=(0")/#/%1(",(1+--",)(
'(2'=(7/#2'#3(",('$L,/2&+3)",)(-8'-(%1+#1(#")8-1('#+(4'#'*/%,-(',3(-8+=(8'0+(
-/(A+(#+'3(*L0"3/+J*&(A)[3+#"0+1(7#/*(!!:9(?8+A+#)+9(DG!I5(0J(V+&&9(+-$J\J(5/-(
,'##/2(",-+#4#+-'-"/,(/7(%1+#1(#")8-19(28"$8(2/%&3(&"L+&=(4#/3%$+('(3"77+#+,-(
/%-$/*+(A+$'%1+("-(2/%&3($/,1-#'",(-8+(1$/4+(/7(28'-($/,1-"-%-+1('(4#"0'-+(
1-%3=J(
!
F7(=/%(7/$%1(/,(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1(4+#14+$-"0+("-(1+-1(%4(-8+(7'&1+(3"$8/-/*=9(
-8'-(2+3)+(AE2(-+'$8+#1(',3(1-%3+,-1J
!
D!!(1'"3(2+(8'0+(-/(7/&&/2(-8+(#+'1/,",)(1+-(",(DG!I5(0J(V+&&9(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(
-8+(3+'&",)(*%1-(A+(%,3+#1-//3(7#/*(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-8+(+,3(%1+#
!
?8+,($&+'#&=(-8+('#-"7"$"'&(2+3)+(AE2(-8/1+(S(3"1'44+'#1(',3(=/%(8'0+(
-'%-/&/)"$'&(#+&'-"/,18"4(',3(-8+#+7/#+("-(A+$/*+1(%,-+,'A&+(-/(1+4'#'-+(
",1-#%$-"/,(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=J(
M8+,(=/%(7/$%1(1-%3+,-('1(%1+#9("-(3/+1,H-(*'--+#(28+-8+#(-8+(1-%3+,-('1L+3(
7/#('(48/-/$/4=(/#(-+'$8+#(/,(-8+"#(/2,(","-"'-"0+(48/-/$/4"+3(',3(3"1-#"A%-+3(
-/(1-%3+,-19(-8'-H1(28'-(-+'$8",)("1(",('(A#/'3+#($/,-+K-9(',3(-8'-H1('(0"-'&(
$/,-+K-J
!
!'-+)/#=(>(2'1(1'"3(-/(A+(%,7'"#('$$/#3",)(-/(-8+(A/'#3(2'1(A+$'%1+("-(2'1(7/#('(
,/,64#"0'-+(1-%3=J
!
F,1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-(1+4'#'-+(7#/*(4#"0'-+(1-%3=P(D!!
!
7".")@M
<(L",31(/7($'1+1(
!
<(",1-',$+1(28+#+(=/%(8'0+(
!
I--+*4-1(A=($/**+#$"'&(%,3+#-'L",)
!
V+$'%1+(-8+#+("1(',(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+(/7(-8+(4%A&"18+#19(+,-"-"+1(-8'-('#+(
3+'&",)(2"-(-8+1+(2/#L1J(?8+=('#+(1'=",)(-8+(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+("1($/**+#$"'&(
A+$'%1+(=/%($',-(4#/7"-(",(-8"1($/,-+K-J(
?8'-(4#/7"-(*/-"0+("1(4#/A&+*'-"$
?8"1($/,$+4-(/7(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+("1('44&"+3(-/(-8"1($'1+(
?8+($/%#-1(",(+'$8(/7(-8/1+($'1+1('&&($/,$&%3+3(-8'-('&-8/%)8(-8+(3+'&",)(*'=(
/1-+,1"0+&=(A+(7/#(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(/7(#+1+'#$8(/#(4#"0'-+(1-%3=9(28+,(=/%(
*/0+(-/(-8+(7'"#,+11($/*4/,+,-(/7(-8+(-+1-([28+-8+#(-8'-(3+'&",)("1(7'"#\(-8+=(
'#+(,/-J(
!
7".")@E)$%)@N
The$court$held…rejecting$argument
!
It$could$not$be$contended…nor$if$an$author$produced…
!
7".")@F
!/%#-(#+@+$-1('&&(-8/1+(<($'1+1('1(-8/1+('%-8/#"-"+1(8'0+(,/(2+")8-(",(-8"1(
",1-',$+
!
This$expressly$contradicts$CCH…
!
Research$is$not$limited$to$non=commercial$or$private$context
!
?8"1("3+'(-8'-(4#"0'-+($/,-+K-(28+,(=/%(&//L('-(!::9(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(
%,3+#(-8+(7'"#(3+'&",)(4#/0"1"/,19(!!:("1(28+,(2+(",-+#4#+-(#+1+'#$8("-1(,/-(
&"*"-+3(,/,6$/**+#$"'&(/#(4#"0'-+($/,-+K-J
!
?8"1("1(@%1-"7"$'-"/,(7/#(,++3(-/(1-+4(A'$L
!
W'"#(3+'&",)(',3(%1+#1(#")8-1(*%1-(A+()"0+,(*L0"3/+J*)",-+#4#+-'-"/,J
!
7".")@G
<&$*.+%.)6%$+J*
!
F,(-8"1($'1+(4%#4/1+(/7(48/-/$/4=",)([-8'-H1(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)\9(
C%+1-"/,("1(28+-8+#(/7(,/-(-8"1(48/-/$/4=",)(7'"#
!
?8+1+('#+(,/-(1-+419(-8+=('#+('44&"+3
?8+=('#+(,/-(1-'-%-/#=(#+C%"#+*+,-1(
?8+=('#+(1%A@+$-(/7(7'$-/#1(-8'-('#+(-8+#+(-/(A+('44&"+3(#+&'-"0+&=(
1%A@+$-"0+&=
M8"$8("1(28=(/,&=(>(/7(-8+*(-8'-('#+('-("11%+(-#+'-+3(A=(*'@/#"-=('-(D!!(
F,(!::9(D!!('3/4-+3(-8+(%1+(/7(b(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(
!
F,(-8"1($'1+(-8+(-+'$8+#1(3/(,/-(3"14&'=(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+19(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(
3+'&",)9(48/-/$/4=",)c-8+#+B1(,/(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+
!
F-H1('($'1+(28+#+A=(=/%(8'0+(-+'$8+#1(+,)')",)(",(",1-#%$-"/,
!
D!!(28+-8+#(",1-#%$-"/,(/#(,/-9(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(',3(",1-#%$-"/,('#+(1'*+(+11+,-"'&(
'$-"0"-=(-8'-(*'L+(%4(A'1"$(+K+#$"1+1( ",('(1-',3'#3(+3%$'-"/,(
!
7".")IH
W'"#(3+'&",)("1(',(+K$+4-"/,9("-('&&/21(=/%(-/(+1$'4+(&"'A"&"-=(7/#($/4=#")8-(",7#",)+*+,-
./1-("*4(/,+(",(-8+(+,-"#+(#+'3",)(
!
7".")IIO)IBO)IKO)IM
F*4($/*4',"/,($'1+(
!
5++3(-/(#+'3(-8"1(/,+(",($/,@%,$-"/,(2"-8(DG!I5(0J(V+&&(!','3'
!
?8+(L+=(-+#*(8+#+("1(P.*&*J"3$)0*./0*,$+J*P
!
M8'-("1(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(3+'&",)P("-($/*+1(3/2,(-/(#+&+0',-(4+#14+$-"0+
!
?8'-H1(28+#+(D!!(1+-1(/%-(
!
W'"#(3+'&",)("1('(%1+#1(#")8-(
!
D-%3+,-1(
?8+(1-%3+,-1('#+(%1",)(-8+(*'-+#"'&1(-8+#+7/#+(-8+(%&-"*'-+(+,3(%1+#(
2/%&3(A+(-8+(1-%3+,-(
?8+#+7/#+(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+(=/%(-'L+(28+,($/,1"3+#",)(1-%3+,-19(-8+"#(%1+1(
/7(-8+(3+'&",)1(-8'-(3+-+#*",+1(/,(8/2(=/%($/*+(3/2,(-/(-8+(C%+1-"/,(
/7(8/2(=/%(%1+(-8+(3+'&",)(
M8/('#+(-8+(%1+#1(",(-8"1($'1+R
!
7".")II
I&A+#-'(O3%$'-"/,(A+",)(3"1-",)%"18+3(7#/*(-8/1+(<($'1+1(-8'-(I$$+11(2'1(
#+&=",)(/,
!
?8+(4%A&"18+#1('1($/4"+#1([",(-8/1+(<($'1+1\("1(3"1-",)%"18'A&+(7#/*(-+'$8+#1('1(
$/4"+#1
!
^%A&"18+#('1($/4"+#1
F,(-8/1+(<($/*4',"/,($'1+1("-H1(-8+(4%A&"18+#1(-8'-('#+($/*4"&",)(-8+1+(1-%3=(
)%"3+1(',3(+K'*1(-/(1+&&(-/(1-%3+,-1
!
:+#+(2+(8'0+(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1
!
?8+=('#+(+,)')+3(",('(7%,3'*+,-'&&=(3"77+#+,-('$-"0"-"+1(
!
?+'$8+#1(8'0+(,/(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+(28+,(4#/0"3",)($/4"+1(-/(1-%3+,-1(
!
I,(+,-"#+($8'4-+#($/4"+3(A=(-+'$8+#("1(,/-(7'"#('1(-8+(4#/4/#-"/,(/7(-8+(2/#L(
3+'&",)(2"-8("1(,/-(7'"#(
!
?8+(-+'$8+#1('#+($/4=",)(+K$+#4-1(/7(-8+(2/#L
!
F-1(,/-(-8+(7'$-(-8'-(dee(+K$+#4-1(/7($/4=#")8-+3(2/#L(A+",)(3"1-#"A%-+3(-/(dee(
1-%3+,-19(-8'-H1('))#+)'-+J
!
?8'-H1(,/-(8/2(=/%(7")%#+(/%-(-8+('*/%,-(/7(-8+(3+'&",)
!
M8'-B1(-8+(4#/4/#-"/,(/7(-8'-($8'4-+#(-8'-(-8+(-+'$8+#(48/-/$/4"+3(
]'-8+#(=/%(8'0+(-/(&//L('-(-8+(2/#L(",(C%+1-"/,([+J)J($8'4-+#(<(/7('(A//L\((
!
9$Q/)")R#*/$+%3)%S)$-*)0.%0%.$+%3)3%$)"''.*'"$*A)
!
?8'-H1(,/-(-8+('*/%,-(/7(3+'&",)(-8'-H1(@%1-(-8+(A/%,3'#"+1(
F-1(4%#+('*/%,-9(,/(&/,)+#(4#/4/#-"/,
^%#+('*/%,-("1(,/-(,+)/-"'A&+
F7('(-+K-A//L(8'1(de($8'4-+#19(-8+,("-($',(A+$/*+('(4#/A&+*(28+#+A=('(,/J(/7(
4')+1(-8'-('$$%*%&'-+('(f(/7(4')+19(-8'-($/%&3($#/11(-8+(A/%,3'#"+1
!
M8+,(=/%B#+(3+'&",)(2"-8(4#/4/#-"/,(-8'-H1(,+)/-"'A&+(
!
?8+(4#/4/#-"/,(/7(-8+(2/#L1(A+",)(3"1-#"A%-+3(2+#+(#+'1/,'A&+(4#/4/#-"/,1(/7(
-8+(+K$+4-1(
!
?+K-A//L(4%A&"18+#1('#)%+3(-8'-(-8+('77+$-(/7(-8"1(L",3(/7(3+'&",)([-+'$8+#1(
3"1-#"A%-",)(48/-/$/4"+1(-/(1-%3+,-1\(-8'-(8'#*1(-8+*J
!
?8'-H1(/,+(/7(-8+(7'"#(7'$-/#1
?8+(+77+$-(/7(-8"1(3+'&([48/-/$/4=",)\
!
?8+('$$+11($/4=#")8-("1(1'=",)(/,(A+8'&7(/7(-8+(4%A&"18+#19(-8+=('#+(8%#-",)(
!
7".")IB
Lecture'12'*Tab'8
M+3,+13'=9( X+$+*A+#( S9(Se;d
_P;>(^.

Only pages 1-3 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

!"#$%&'#('#)%*+,-(
!
!"#$%&%'()
./0+1(-/2'#31(',(+,3(4/",-(
!
!*&*%&%'+,"&
5/,64#"0'-+(7/#*(/7(3+'&",)(",(-8"1($'1+9(28"$8("1(,/-($/0+#+3(%,3+#(-8+(!!:(!','3"',(
1+-
!'-+)/#"+1(;(-/(<
!'-+)/#=(>("1(-8+#+(-+'$8(1'"3(=/%(3/(-8"1((
?8/1+(;;(@%3"$"'&(#+0"+21(2/%&3(,/-(8'0+(A++,($/4"+3(A=(-8+(&"A(4'-#/,1("7(
-8+=(2+#+,B-(#+C%+1-
!!:(D+#0"$+(2'1('-(-8+(#+C%+1-(/7(-8+(&'2=+#1(E(4'-#/,1
!
F,(-8"1($'1+(-8+1+(1-%3+,-1(2+#+(,/-(#+C%+1-",)(-8+($/4"+1(
!
G,(-8+(C%+1-"/,(/7(-8+($%1-/*(48/-/$/4=(1+#0"$+(-8'-H1(28+#+(!!:(!','3"',(3"77+#1(
7#/*(I&A+#-'($'1+J
!!:(',3(I&A+#-'($'1+(-8+=('#+('A1/&%-+&=(3"1-",)%"18'A&+(7#/*(-8+(7'$-1(',3(
$/,-+K-(/7(+3%$'-"/,(
!
?8+(0+#=(,'-%#+(/7(+3%$'-"/,("1(1%$8(-8'-(0+#=($/,-+K-(/#($/,$+4-(/7(-+'$8",)("1(
1%$8(-8'-(-+'$8+#1('1(4'#-(/7(-8+"#(@/AE+3%$'-"/,'&(+,0"#/,*+,-9(2"&&(*'L+(
$/4"+1('11"),(-8+*(-/(1-%3+,-1(+-$J
!
F,(-8'-($/,-+K-(1-%3+,-1(2"&&(#+C%+1-(-+'$8+#1(-/(*'L+($/4"+1
!
F-H1('(7'&1+(3"1-",)%"18*+,-(-8+,(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#(
!
?8+(3"$8/-/*=(AE2(-+'$8+#1(',3(1-%3+,-1(
!
M8+-8+#(/#(,/-(-8+#+("1(",(7'$-('(A/,'(7"3+(3"1-",)%"18'A&+(/7(@%3)+*+,-(",(!!:(
I(3"1-",$-($/,$+4-%'&"N'-"/,(/7(-+'$8+#1(',3(-8+"#(#/&+1(",(-8+($/,-+K-(/7(+3%$'-"/,
G,(-8+(/,+(1"3+(=/%(8'0+(-+'$8+#1(-8+,(-8+#+("1('(1+4'#'-+($/,$+4-%'&"N'-"/,(/7(-8+(
1-%3+,-
M8'-(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(3/+1(",('$$+4-",)('$$+11($/4=#")8-B1('#)%*+,-1(
?8'-H1(-8+(1+-(%4(",(-+#*1(/7(28'-('$$+11($/4=#")8-("1('#)%",)
!
D/(-+'$8+#(',3(1-%3+,-(28'-('#+(-8+"#(#/&+1(
!
?8+=('#+(*'L",)(-8+(48/-/$/4"+1
!
O"-8+#('-(-8+(#+C%+1-(/7(-8+(1-%3+,-1(/#('-(-8+"#(/2,(","-"'-"0+
!
I,3(-8+,(3"1-#"A%-",)(-8/1+($/4"+1(-/(1-%3+,-1((
!
?8+(7"#1-('44#/K"*'-"/,("1(@%1-(%,3+#1-',3(-+'$8+#E$/4"+#
!
?8+#+7/#+("7(=/%(8'0+(-8'-(3"1-",$-"/,(-8+,(1-%3+,-1(2/%&3(A+(-8+(
%1+#1
!
!*",-*.)"/),%0+*.
1$#2*3$/)"/)#/*./))
?8+"#(#/&+1(+11+,-"'&&=("1P
!
?8+(7"#1-($/,$+4-%'&(3"1-",$-"/,("1(AE2(-+'$8+#(',3(1-%3+,-(
I$$+11(1'=1(-+'$8+#1(*'L+($/4"+1(/7(A//L1(-8'-(-8+=(8'0+(#")8-1(-/(
!
F-1(,/-(8/2(-8+=('#+(*'L",)(-8+($/4"+1("1(-8+(4#/A&+*("-1(8/2(-8+=('#+(3+'&",)(
-8+($/4"+1
!
I$$+11("1(1'=",)(-+'$8+#1('#+(+,)')",)(",(%,7'"#(3+'&",)
!
4,,*//)5%0(.+'-$)
?'&L",)(4#/4/#-"/,1
!
?8+('*/%,-(/7(3+'&",)("1($/,$+#,+3(2"-8(4#/4/#-"/,'&"-=
!
Q/%(-'L+(-8+(2/#L(",(C%+1-"/,9(2/#L(-8'-("1(A+",)(3+'&-9(28'-("1(-8+(4#/4/#-"/,(
/7(2/#L(-8'-("1(A+",)(3+'&-(',3("1("-(',(%,7'"#('*/%,-(/7(-8'-(2/#LR
!
F7(=/%('#+(1-#+'*",)('(4#+0"+2(/7('(1/,)(-8'-("1(S(*",(-8'-("1(%,7'"#(4#/4/#-"/,(/7(
-8+(2/#L(",(3+'&",)
!
T++4(",(*",3(-8+(&/)"$(/7(8/2(-8+('*/%,-(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#9(8/2("-(
2'1('44&"+3(28+,(2+(1-%3"+3(4#+0"+21(
!
Q/%(-'L+(-8'-(&/)"$(-8+,(=/%(A#",)("-(-/(I&A+#-'(+3%$'-"/,9(28'-(=/%(8'0+(-8+,("1(
'($/4=#")8-+3(2/#L(-8'-("1(A+",)(3+'&-(2"-8
!
M8+,(=/%(8+'#("6%#3$ /7(-8+(2/#L(",(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#
F1(-8+(2/#L(2/#-8(3"11+*",'-",)(
!
F,(-8"1($'1+(28'-("1(-8+(,'-%#+(/7(-8+(2/#L(",(-8"1($'1+(
!
?8"1(2'1(,/-(/,+(/7(-8+(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(3+'&-(2"-8(*'@/#"-=(",(-8+(D!!
!
M8'-("1(-8+(3"$#.* /7(-8+(2/#L(-8+,R
?8"1("1(-8+(*/1-(1"),"7"$',-(/,+
?8"1("1(28+,(2+($/*+(",-/(-8+("3+'(/7(%,3+#1-',3",)(-8+(#/&+(/7(-8+(
-+'$8+#(',3(-8+(#/&+(/7(-8+(1-%3+,-
?8+(#/&+(/7(-8+(-+'$8+#("1(-8+($/4"+#9(#/&+(/7(-8+(1-%3+,-("1(%1+#
?8+(4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(=/%(8'0+(-/(&//L(',3($/,1"3+#(28'-("1(-8+(
4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(
M8+,(=/%('#+('44&=",)(-8"1(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#(/7(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(
"-H1(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+9(7#/*(28/1+(4+#14+$-"0+(3/(2+($/,1"3+#(",(-8+(3+'&",)(
',3(28+-8+#("-1(7'"#
U1+#1(#")8-1($/,$+4-
!
F,(DG!I5(0J(V+&&(2"-8(-8+(*%1"$(4#+0"+219(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+(=/%(-'L+("-H1(-8+(
4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-8+(+,3(%1+#J(
M8+,(=/%(8'0+(-8+(4#/A&+*(/7(*%1"$(4#+0"+21(-8+1+(A%1",+11+1(-8'-(
'&&/2(4+/4&+(-/(4#+0"+2(1/,)1(A+7/#+(4%#$8'1",)(-8+*9(-8'-(1-"&&(3+'&",)(
",(-8+($/4=#")8-+3(2/#L1
F,(DG!I5(0J(V+&&(!','3'(-8+(/&3(A%1",+11(*/3+&(2'1(-'L",)(7#/*(-8+(/&3(
7'18"/,(",(1-/#+(&"1-+,",)(-/(4#+0"+21(-/(/,&",+(1-#+'*",)(/7(4#+0"+21J
?8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3($/,$&%3+3(-8+(-+'$8+#('1(-8+($/4"+#(
?+'$8+#('1($/4"+#9(-8'-(A+$/*+1(-8+(3/*",',-(4+#14+$-"0+
7#.0%/*)
!
.'@/#"-=('33#+11+1(>(/7(-8+(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(",(-8"1($'1+(
?8+(-+'$8+#('1('($/4"+#(
!
5/2(2+(8'0+(-/(&//L('-(-8"1(7#/*(-8+(#/&+(/7(-8+(-+'$8+#
!
?8"1(7/$%1(/,(-8+(-+'$8+#(#+1%&-1(",(-8+(1$+,'#"/(28+#+A=(-8"1("1(,/-('(3+'&",)(7/#(
-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(.*/*".,-)%.)789:4!;)1!<=>J
!
?8+(4+#14+$-"0+(-8'-(2'1('3/4-+3(A=(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(2'1P
M8'-('$$+11($/4=#")8-('#)%+3(',3($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(')#++3
!
5/9(-8+=('#+(1%A@+$-(-/(#/='&-"+1(
M8+,(=/%(-'L+(4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#(',3(-/(3+-+#*",+(28+-8+#(/#(
,/-(-8+(48/-/$/4"+1(3"1-#"A%-+39("1(-8'-(7'"#(3+'&",)R
!
I&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(/7(7'"#(3+'&",)("1(#+1+'#$8(/#(4#"0'-+(1-%3=
!
M8+,(=/%('3/4-(4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#(=/%(,/(&/,)+#(8'0+(#+1+'#$8(
',3(1-%3=J
!
?8+(L+=(-+#*(-8+(2'=("-1($/,$+4-%'&"N+3("1(=/%(8'0+(",1-#%$-"/,
!
?8+(1-'-+(/7('77'"#(2'1('3/4-+3(',3('$$+4-+3(A=($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(',3(
1%A1+C%+,-&=(W+3+#'&($/%#-(/7('44+'&
!
M8'-(2+(8'0+(8+#+("1(',(",1-#%$-"/,9(-+'$8+#(48/-/$/4=",)(',3(8',3",)(-/(
1-%3+,-1(-/(1++(',3(#+'$8(-8+(48/-/$/4=9(-8+=('#+(1'=",)(-8'-H1(',(",1-#%$-"/,
!
D!!(3"3(,/-('#-"$%&'-+(",1-#%$-"/,('1(A+",)('&&/2'A&+(%1+39("-1(,/-('(7'"#(3+'&",)
!
F7("-1(,/-(7'"#(3+'&",)(-8+,('$$+11($/4=#")8-(2",1J(
!
M8'-("1(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(R
?8'-(3"1-",$-"/,(2'1(#+@+$-+3(A=(D!!(
!
F*4(-/(%,3+#1-',3(3"77+#+,$+(AE2(-8/1+(S($/,$+4-%'&"N'-"/,(/7(-+'$8+#('1('($/4"+#(
',3(1-%3+,-('1('(%1+#
?8"1(8'1(+0+#=-8",)(-/(3/(2"-8(%,3+#1-',3",)(-8+(+K4',1"0+(",-+#/4+#'-"/,()"0+,(-/(
+3%$'-"/,(A=(-8+(*'@/#"-=(/7(D!!(",(-8"1($'1+9(-8+=(8'0+(-'L+,(-8"1($/,$+4-(/7(1-%3=J
?8+(3+7","-"/,(/7(#+1+'#$8('1(',('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(2'1(A#/'3+,(-#+*+,3/%1&=(",(
DG!I5(0J(V+&&
F-(A+$/*+1(-8+($/#+(",-+&&+$-%'&($'1+(
!
Q/%($',-(8'0+(4#"0'-+(1-%3=("7(-8+#+B1(,/(4%A&"$(1-%3=
!
F-($',(/,&=(+K"1-(",(/44/1"-"/,(-/(1/*+-8",)(+&1+
!
5/2(2+(4"$L(%4(/,(4#"0'-+(1-%3=
X+4+,3",)(",(-8+(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-9(4#"0'-+(/#(4%A&"$(1-%3=("-1('&&(-8+(1'*+
!
F,1-#%$-"/,(7/&31(",-/(-8+($/,$+4-(/7(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(
!
?8"1("1(",(',(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-
!
?8+#+('#+(/-8+#($/,-+K-(=/%($/%&3(&//L('-(28+#+A=(-8+(#+'1/,",)(',3(4#+$+3+,-(
1+-(",(-8"1($'1+(*'=(,/-(A+('$$+4-+3
!
M8+,(2+('#+(3+'&",)(2"-8($/,$+4-(/7(+3%$'-"/,(-8+,(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(',3(
",1-#%$-"/,('#+(-8+(1'*+(-8",)
!
?8'-H1(/,+(/7(-8+(L+=('14+$-1(/7(D!!(",(-8"1($'1+(28+#+(-8+=($/##+$-+3('(0+#=(
1"),"7"$',-&=(%,#+'1/,'A&+(/%-$/*+(/7(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3B1(3+$"1"/,(
!
F-1($#%$"'&(-8'-(",1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-(1+4'#'-+3(7#/*("-1(A#/'3+#($/,$+4-(
!
X#"0",)('(2+3)+(AE2(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#(',3(1-%3+,-('1(%1+#(-8'-H1('#-"7"$"'&( ',3(
3'*')",)(',3($',,/-(1-',3J(
!
M8'-(-8+(/%-$/*+(/7(-8"1(@%3)+*+,-(3/+1(2"-8(#+14+$-(/7(*'@/#"-=(/7(D!!
D+4'#'-"/,("1(1/*+8/2(3"77+#+,-(7#/*(-+'$8",)('$$/#3",)(-/($/4=#")8-(A/'#3
!
?8+('#)%*+,-("1(A=(*'L",)(-8+1+($/4"+1(/,(-8+"#(/2,(","-"'-"0+9(8',3",)(-8+(-/(
1-%3+,-1(-8'-("1('(7/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,
!
I,3(D!!(#+@+$-1(-8"1('#)%*+,-(
!
93/$.#,$+%3)"1(1"),"7"$',-(8+#+
F-H1('(2'=(",(1%$8(-8'-($/,$+4-%'&"N",)(-8+($&'11#//*(',3(-8+(7/#*(/7(1-%3=(",(
1%$8(4&'$+
!
F,1-#%$-"/,(",(1/*+(3"1-",$-('$-"0"-=("1(4#/A&+*'-"$(
!
?8+('*%'."0-( /7(-8+($&'11#//*
M8+,(=/%(4%-("-(",(',(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-(-8+,(",1-#%$-"/,9(4#"0'-+(/#(4%A&"$(1-%3=("-1(
'&&(-8+(1'*+(-8",)(
M8'-(=/%(8'0+("1(",('(1$8//&(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-(",1-#%$-"/,(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=9(
-8+=('#+(-'%-/&/)"$'&9(-8+=(3/,H-(1+4'#'-+J
!
?8+(2+3)+(-8'-("1(1+4'#'-+3(AE2(",1-#%$-"/,(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(A=($/4=#")8-(
A/'#3("1(#+@+$-+3(A=(D!!J
!
!/4=#")8-(A/'#3(1'=1(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1('#+(+,)')+3(",('(7/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,(A=(
-8+(,'-%#+(/7(8/2(-8+=('#+(3+'&",)(2"-8(-8+($/4"+1J
!
F,1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-(',('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(7/#(7'"#(3+'&",)(%,3+#(-8+(!!:(!','3"',(
-+1-
!
W/#(7'"#(3+'&",)(-8+#+(8'1(-/(A+(/,+(/7(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+19(2+(8'0+(/,&=(
A++,($/,$+#,+3(2"-8(#+1+'#$8(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=J(
!
W/#(1-+4(;(-8+#+(2'1(,/(4#/A&+*9("-1('44&=",)(-8+(&/)"$(/7(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(-/(-8+(
7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(-8+*1+&0+1(
!
F-H1(-8+('44&"$'-"/,(7/(-8+($/,$+4-(/7(4#"0'-+(1-%3=
!
F-H1(-8+(7'"#,+11(+&+*+,-(-8'-H1('-("11%+
!
F-1(8/2(",(/-8+#(2/#31(28+-8+#(/#(,/-(3+'&",)("1(7'"#('-("11%+
!
?"+.)2*"&+3'
I$-(/7(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1
.'3+(A=(-+'$8+#1(-/(3"1-#"A%-+(-/(1-%3+,-1
I-(-8+(-+'$8+#B1(","-"'-"0+;J
Y/(A'$L(-/(!!:
!
:/2(=/%($/,$+4-%'&"N+(-8+(0+#=(,'-%#+(/7(1+#0"$+1(
!
M/#3(#+C%+1-("1($#%$"'&
!
I-(-8+(1-%3+,-B1(#+C%+1-(SJ
S('$-1
!&'11(",1-#%$-"/,
F1(-8"1('$-"0"-=('&&/2'A&+(7/#(-8+(4%#4/1+1(/7(-8+(7'"#(3+'&",)(+K$+4-"/,
Z'1-(1+,-+,$+
!
7".")@)0'A)@B)C-+'-&+'-$)&"$*.D
:/2('1(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#('$$+4-+3('1('($'-+)/#=
!
U,3+#1-',3(3"77+#+,$+(AE2($'-+)/#"+1(;6<(',3($'-+)/#=(>
!
;6<("1(&"-+#'&&=(28+#+(-8+=(#+$/#3(48/-/$/4"+1(*'3+(A=(-+'$8+#1(A%-(*'3+('(
#+C%+1-(/7(-8+(1-%3+,-1
!
Y/(A'$L(-/(!!:(-/(%,3+#1-',3(-8+(1"*"&'#(4#'$-"$+( 28+#+A=(-8+(1",)&+($/4"+1(/7(
-8+($/4=#")8-+3(&+)'&(2/#L1(",(!!:(*'3+('-(-8+(#+C%+1-(/7(-8+(4'-#/,1(
!
?8'-('14+$-(/7(!!:(!','3"',
!
7".")E
!'-+)/#=(>(
!
!/4"+1(2+#+(*'3+('-(-+'$8+#1(","-"'-"0+1(
!
7".")F
!/,$&%1"/,(/7($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(
!
F3+'(/7('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+1
!
V/'#3($/,$&%3+3(-8'-($'-+)/#=(>($/4"+1(2+#+(*'3+('-(-+'$8+#B1(","-"'-"0+(',3("-(
2'1(7/#(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(/7(#+1+'#$8(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=([1-+4(;\
!
V%-(28+,(=/%(*/0+(-/(1-+4(S(/7(!!:(-+1-9($'-+)/#=(>($/4"+1(3"3(,/-($/,1-"-%-+(
7'"#(3+'&",)(',3(2+#+(-8+#+7/#+(1%A@+$-(-/(#/='&-=
!
7".")G
?8+(7+3+#'&($/%#-(/7('44+'&($/,$&%3+3(-8'-($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(",(-+#*1(/7(8/2(
-8+=(3+'&-(2"-8($'-+)/#=(>('-(-8+(-+'$8+#1(","-"'-"0+9(-8+=(2+#+(,/-(7'"#(3+'&",)(
',3(-8+=(1'"3(-8'-(3+-+#*",'-"/,(A=($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(2'1(-/-'&&=(#+'1/,'A&+
!
7".")@H
D!!(1'"3(-8+1+('#)%*+,-1('#+(%,#+'1/,'A&+
!
?8+(*'@/#"-=(D!!(')#++(2"-(-8+($/'&"-"/,('#)%*+,-
!
?8+=(3/(,/-('$$+4-('$$+11($/4=#")8-1('#)%*+,-1('$$+4-+3(A=($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(
',3(%48+&3(A=(-8+(7+3+#'&($/%#-(/7('44+'&(
!
7".")@@
5/2(2+('#+(*/0",)(",-/(/-8+#(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#
F-(2'1(-8+(C%+1-"/,(/7(-8+('44&"$'-"/,(/7(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(A=(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(-8'-(
'#+('-("11%+J
?8+(D!!(')#++1(2"-8(I&A+#-'(+3%$'-"/,($/'&"-"/,(-8'-(-8+(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(2+#+(
",$/##+$-&=('44&"+3(A=(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3J
?8+(A"))+1-(',3(*/1-(4#/A&+*'-"$("1(-8+(0#.0%/*)7'$-/#J(
]+0"+2(/7(!!:(!','3"',(-+1-
!
7".")@I
F-H1(-8+(*'@/#"-=(@%3)+*+,-(-8'-(3+-+#*",+1(8/2(-8",)1(2/#L(
V")($/,$+#,("1()/",)(-/(A+(*',')",)(3")"-'&(*'-+#"'&1(',3(*',')",)(-8+($#+'-/#1(',3(
%1+#1(#")8-1J
I44#+$"'-",)(-8+("*4&"$'-"/,1(/7(-8+(D!!(",(-8+($/,-+K-(/7(%1+#1(#")8-1(",(',(
+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-J
?8+("*4&"$'-"/,1(/7(-8+(@%3)+*+,-('#+(1%$8(-8'-(",(',(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-(28'-(3/+1(
-8'-(*+',(
?8+(3"1-",$-"/,(AE2(4#"0'-+(',3(4%A&"$(1-%3=("1(+77+$-"0+&=(+#'1+3(A=(D!!(
^'#'(;<6S_(*/1-("*4(7/#(3+-+#*",",)(7'"#(3+'&",)(
W"#1-(1-+4(7'"#(3+'&",)P(28+-8+#("-("1(7/#(4%#4/1+(/7(#+1+'#$8(/#(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(;J
?8+(7"#1-(1-+4(-8+(&',)%')+(#+1+'#$8(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=('#+(,/-(',("11%+(/#(
$/,$+4-%'&(4#/A&+*1
!
M8+#+(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(A+$/*+1('($/,$+4-%'&(4#/A&+*("1('-(1-+4(S(/7(-8+(!!:(
!','3"',(-+1-(28+#+A=(2+(3+-+#*",+(28'-B1(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(7'"#(3+'&",)
!
?8'-H1(28=(2+(8'0+('(!/4=#")8-(A/'#3(',3('$$+11($/4=#")8-('#)%",)(-8+(
)+/)#'48"$'&('14+$-(/7(-8+($&'11#//*
!
W/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,P(,/,64#"0'-+(1-%3=(
!
?8+($/,$+4-(/7(",1-#%$-"/,('1("-('44&"+1(8+#+(A/-8($/,,/-+1(',3(3+,/-+1('(4%A&"$(
7/#*(/7(1-%3=(-8'-(-'L+1(4&'$+(",(-8+($&'11#//*9(",(-8+($/,-+K-("-1(,/-(4#"0'-+J(
!
?8+(4/",-("1("-1(,/-(`4#"0'-+`
!
F,1-#%$-"/,(-8+#+7/#+(",('($&'11#//*(-8'-(7/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-(4#"0'-+(
!
Y+,+#'&&=("-1('$$+4-+3(-8'-(/L(-8+#+B1(,/("11%+(8+#+(/,('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(/7(
#+1+'#$8(',3(1-%3=9(-8'-H1(,/-(-8+("11%+J(M8'-($/*+1(-/("11%+("1(-8+(2/#3(
`4#"0'-+`(
!
?8+(3"1-",$-"/,(1+-(%4(A=(-8+(A/'#3(
?8"1("1('(7/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,9(,/-(4#"0'-+(1-%3=
!
7".")@B
M8'-B1(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)("-1+&7SJ
F,(DG!I5(0J(V+&&(!','3'(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(",(-8'-($'1+(2'1(1-#+'*",)(
,/-(3/2,&/'3",)J([-8'-H1("*4\
!
M8'-("1(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(",(-8"1($'1+P(0-%$%,%0(+3'
!
Q+1("-("1(A+$'%1+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)("-1(48/-/$/4=",)
^8/-/$/4=",)('1(',('$-"0"-=(",(',(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,$+4-("1('$$+4-'A&+(7/#(
4#"0'-+(1-%3=(/#(#+1+'#$8J(
?8'-H1(28=(-8+#+B1(,/-('(4#/A&+*('-(1-+4(;(
Q/%(8'0+(-/(7/$%1(/,(-8+("3+'(/7(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)P(
48/-/$/4=",)(",(-8+(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-
W/#(-8+(7"#1-(4'#-(/7(!!:9(1'=1("1(-8+(3+'&",)(7/#(/,+(/7(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+1R
!
M8+#+("-(A+$/*+1(-8+(4#/A&+*(28"$8(+11+,-"'&&=($+,-#+3(/,(-8+(S,3(1-+4(/7(-8+(
-+1-
!
M8+-8+#(-8+($'-+)/#=(>($/4"+1([$/4"+1('-(-8+(","-"'-"0+(/7(-8+(-+'$8+#\(2+#+(7'"#J(
!
?8+=('#+(1'=",)(-8'-("1(,/-(7'"#(3+'&",)(A+$'%1+(28+,(=/%(&//L('-(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(
-8+(3+'&",)(28'-B1(-8+(7"#1-(-8",)(=/%(8'0+(-/($/,1"3+#9(D!!(1'"3(28/1+(
4+#14+$-"0+("1(-8"1(7#/*J(
!
^+#14+$-"0+(/7(-8+(-+'$8+#('1(-8+(48/-/$/4"+#9(',3(",1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-('(7'$-/#(/7(
7'"#,+11(",(!!:9(-8+#+7/#+("-1(,/-(',('&&/2'A&+(%1+('$$/#3",)(-/('$$+11($/4=#")8-(
'1(-8+=(1'=("-1(,/(28+#+(",(8+#+
!
F,1-#%$-"/,(",(-8"1($/,-+K-("1('(,/,64#"0'-+(1-%3=(-8+#+7/#+(-8+=(",0/L+(-8+(
$/,$+4-(/7(-8+()+/)#'48=(/7(-8+($&'11#//*(',3(-8+(,'-%#+(/7(-8+(",1-#%$-"/,(
-8'-(-'L+1(4&'$+(-8'-(&+'31(-/(-8+(%,#+'1/,'A&+($/,3%$-(A=(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(
',3(#/='&-"+1(*%1-(A+(4'"3('1(-8+=(3+-+#*",+("-1(,/-(7'"#(3+'&",)J
!
D!!(1'"3(-8+=('#+(2#/,)(
D+4'#'-"/,(AE2(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1(',3(-'L",)(",1-#%$-"/,(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(',3(
1+4'#'-",)(
!
?8+,(=/%('#+(4#/4+#&=(%,3+#1-',3",)(-8+(0+#=(7%,3'*+,-'&(,'-%#+(',3(
4%#4/1+(/7(+3%$'-"/,
Q/%($',-(1+4'#'-+(-8+*(",(-8"1($/,-+K-('-(&+'1-(
!
F-H1('(1=*A"/-"$(#+&'-"/,18"4(AE2(-+'$8+#1(',3(1-%3+,-1
93/$.#,$+%3)"32)0.+J"$*)/$#2()+/)$"#$%&%'+,"&
!
7".")@K
!'-+)/#=(;6<($/4"+1(2+#+(1-%3+,-(#+C%+1-+3($/4"+1
!
I-("11%+(8+#+('-(-8+(7'"#(3+'&",)(4#/A&+*(2+#+($'-+)/#=(>('1(-8+=(2+#+(,/-('-('(
1-%3+,-(#+C%+1-(-8+#+7/#+(A/'#3($/,$&%3+3(-8'-(-8+=('#+(,/-(7/#(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(
4#"0'-+(1-%3=
!
?8/1+('#+(S(0+#=(3"77+#+,-('$-1(-8'-(8'0+(4#/7/%,3("*4&"$'-"/,1(7/#(8/2(-8+(
$/4=#")8-(A/'#3(1+-(/%-(-/(3+-+#*",+(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(3+'&",)(',3(28+-8+#(-8'-(
3+'&",)(2'1(7'"#(
!
F,(!!:(-8+(48/-/$/4"+1(2+#+('-(-8+(`#+C%+1-`(/7(-8+(4'-#/,1(E(&'2=+#1(
!
D/(A+$'%1+(-8+#+(2'1(,/(1%$8(#+C%+1-(7/#($'-+)/#=(>($/4"+1(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(
",(-8"1($'1+($/,$&%3+(-8'-(-8+(4#+63/*",',-(4%#4/1+(2'1(*'",&=(-8'-(/7(-+'$8+#9(
*'",&=(",1-#%$-"/,(/#(`,/,64#"0'-+(1-%3=`J(
!
D!!(1'"3(-8'-H1(4#/A&+*'-"$('44#/'$8
W#/*(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-+'$8+#('1('($/4"+#
!
M8+,(=/%(7/$%1(/,(1-%3+,-1('1('(%1+#(-8+,(2+('#+(",0/L",)(%1+#B1(#")8-1
!
D!!(",(4#+0"/%1(@%3)+*+,-1(8'1(A++,(0+#=($&+'#(28+,(=/%(&//L('-(DJ(Sa(2"-8(
#+14+$-(-/(7'"#(3+'&",)1([%1+#B1(#")8-1\9(-8+(D!!(8'1(A++,(0+#=(0")/#/%1(",(1+--",)(
'(2'=(7/#2'#3(",('$L,/2&+3)",)(-8'-(%1+#1(#")8-1('#+(4'#'*/%,-(',3(-8+=(8'0+(
-/(A+(#+'3(*L0"3/+J*&(A)[3+#"0+1(7#/*(!!:9(?8+A+#)+9(DG!I5(0J(V+&&9(+-$J\J(5/-(
,'##/2(",-+#4#+-'-"/,(/7(%1+#1(#")8-19(28"$8(2/%&3(&"L+&=(4#/3%$+('(3"77+#+,-(
/%-$/*+(A+$'%1+("-(2/%&3($/,1-#'",(-8+(1$/4+(/7(28'-($/,1-"-%-+1('(4#"0'-+(
1-%3=J(
!
F7(=/%(7/$%1(/,(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1(4+#14+$-"0+("-(1+-1(%4(-8+(7'&1+(3"$8/-/*=9(
-8'-(2+3)+(AE2(-+'$8+#1(',3(1-%3+,-1J
!
D!!(1'"3(2+(8'0+(-/(7/&&/2(-8+(#+'1/,",)(1+-(",(DG!I5(0J(V+&&9(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(
-8+(3+'&",)(*%1-(A+(%,3+#1-//3(7#/*(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-8+(+,3(%1+#
!
?8+,($&+'#&=(-8+('#-"7"$"'&(2+3)+(AE2(-8/1+(S(3"1'44+'#1(',3(=/%(8'0+(
-'%-/&/)"$'&(#+&'-"/,18"4(',3(-8+#+7/#+("-(A+$/*+1(%,-+,'A&+(-/(1+4'#'-+(
",1-#%$-"/,(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=J(
M8+,(=/%(7/$%1(1-%3+,-('1(%1+#9("-(3/+1,H-(*'--+#(28+-8+#(-8+(1-%3+,-('1L+3(
7/#('(48/-/$/4=(/#(-+'$8+#(/,(-8+"#(/2,(","-"'-"0+(48/-/$/4"+3(',3(3"1-#"A%-+3(
-/(1-%3+,-19(-8'-H1(28'-(-+'$8",)("1(",('(A#/'3+#($/,-+K-9(',3(-8'-H1('(0"-'&(
$/,-+K-J
!
!'-+)/#=(>(2'1(1'"3(-/(A+(%,7'"#('$$/#3",)(-/(-8+(A/'#3(2'1(A+$'%1+("-(2'1(7/#('(
,/,64#"0'-+(1-%3=J
!
F,1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-(1+4'#'-+(7#/*(4#"0'-+(1-%3=P(D!!
!
7".")@M
<(L",31(/7($'1+1(
!
<(",1-',$+1(28+#+(=/%(8'0+(
!
I--+*4-1(A=($/**+#$"'&(%,3+#-'L",)
!
V+$'%1+(-8+#+("1(',(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+(/7(-8+(4%A&"18+#19(+,-"-"+1(-8'-('#+(
3+'&",)(2"-(-8+1+(2/#L1J(?8+=('#+(1'=",)(-8+(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+("1($/**+#$"'&(
A+$'%1+(=/%($',-(4#/7"-(",(-8"1($/,-+K-J(
?8'-(4#/7"-(*/-"0+("1(4#/A&+*'-"$
?8"1($/,$+4-(/7(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+("1('44&"+3(-/(-8"1($'1+(
?8+($/%#-1(",(+'$8(/7(-8/1+($'1+1('&&($/,$&%3+3(-8'-('&-8/%)8(-8+(3+'&",)(*'=(
/1-+,1"0+&=(A+(7/#(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(/7(#+1+'#$8(/#(4#"0'-+(1-%3=9(28+,(=/%(
*/0+(-/(-8+(7'"#,+11($/*4/,+,-(/7(-8+(-+1-([28+-8+#(-8'-(3+'&",)("1(7'"#\(-8+=(
'#+(,/-J(
!
7".")@E)$%)@N
The$court$held…rejecting$argument
!
It$could$not$be$contended…nor$if$an$author$produced…
!
7".")@F
!/%#-(#+@+$-1('&&(-8/1+(<($'1+1('1(-8/1+('%-8/#"-"+1(8'0+(,/(2+")8-(",(-8"1(
",1-',$+
!
This$expressly$contradicts$CCH…
!
Research$is$not$limited$to$non=commercial$or$private$context
!
?8"1("3+'(-8'-(4#"0'-+($/,-+K-(28+,(=/%(&//L('-(!::9(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(
%,3+#(-8+(7'"#(3+'&",)(4#/0"1"/,19(!!:("1(28+,(2+(",-+#4#+-(#+1+'#$8("-1(,/-(
&"*"-+3(,/,6$/**+#$"'&(/#(4#"0'-+($/,-+K-J
!
?8"1("1(@%1-"7"$'-"/,(7/#(,++3(-/(1-+4(A'$L
!
W'"#(3+'&",)(',3(%1+#1(#")8-1(*%1-(A+()"0+,(*L0"3/+J*)",-+#4#+-'-"/,J
!
7".")@G
<&$*.+%.)6%$+J*
!
F,(-8"1($'1+(4%#4/1+(/7(48/-/$/4=",)([-8'-H1(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)\9(
C%+1-"/,("1(28+-8+#(/7(,/-(-8"1(48/-/$/4=",)(7'"#
!
?8+1+('#+(,/-(1-+419(-8+=('#+('44&"+3
?8+=('#+(,/-(1-'-%-/#=(#+C%"#+*+,-1(
?8+=('#+(1%A@+$-(/7(7'$-/#1(-8'-('#+(-8+#+(-/(A+('44&"+3(#+&'-"0+&=(
1%A@+$-"0+&=
M8"$8("1(28=(/,&=(>(/7(-8+*(-8'-('#+('-("11%+(-#+'-+3(A=(*'@/#"-=('-(D!!(
F,(!::9(D!!('3/4-+3(-8+(%1+(/7(b(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(
!
F,(-8"1($'1+(-8+(-+'$8+#1(3/(,/-(3"14&'=(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+19(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(
3+'&",)9(48/-/$/4=",)c-8+#+B1(,/(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+
!
F-H1('($'1+(28+#+A=(=/%(8'0+(-+'$8+#1(+,)')",)(",(",1-#%$-"/,
!
D!!(28+-8+#(",1-#%$-"/,(/#(,/-9(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(',3(",1-#%$-"/,('#+(1'*+(+11+,-"'&(
'$-"0"-=(-8'-(*'L+(%4(A'1"$(+K+#$"1+1( ",('(1-',3'#3(+3%$'-"/,(
!
7".")IH
W'"#(3+'&",)("1(',(+K$+4-"/,9("-('&&/21(=/%(-/(+1$'4+(&"'A"&"-=(7/#($/4=#")8-(",7#",)+*+,-
./1-("*4(/,+(",(-8+(+,-"#+(#+'3",)(
!
7".")IIO)IBO)IKO)IM
F*4($/*4',"/,($'1+(
!
5++3(-/(#+'3(-8"1(/,+(",($/,@%,$-"/,(2"-8(DG!I5(0J(V+&&(!','3'
!
?8+(L+=(-+#*(8+#+("1(P.*&*J"3$)0*./0*,$+J*P
!
M8'-("1(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(3+'&",)P("-($/*+1(3/2,(-/(#+&+0',-(4+#14+$-"0+
!
?8'-H1(28+#+(D!!(1+-1(/%-(
!
W'"#(3+'&",)("1('(%1+#1(#")8-(
!
D-%3+,-1(
?8+(1-%3+,-1('#+(%1",)(-8+(*'-+#"'&1(-8+#+7/#+(-8+(%&-"*'-+(+,3(%1+#(
2/%&3(A+(-8+(1-%3+,-(
?8+#+7/#+(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+(=/%(-'L+(28+,($/,1"3+#",)(1-%3+,-19(-8+"#(%1+1(
/7(-8+(3+'&",)1(-8'-(3+-+#*",+1(/,(8/2(=/%($/*+(3/2,(-/(-8+(C%+1-"/,(
/7(8/2(=/%(%1+(-8+(3+'&",)(
M8/('#+(-8+(%1+#1(",(-8"1($'1+R
!
7".")II
I&A+#-'(O3%$'-"/,(A+",)(3"1-",)%"18+3(7#/*(-8/1+(<($'1+1(-8'-(I$$+11(2'1(
#+&=",)(/,
!
?8+(4%A&"18+#1('1($/4"+#1([",(-8/1+(<($'1+1\("1(3"1-",)%"18'A&+(7#/*(-+'$8+#1('1(
$/4"+#1
!
^%A&"18+#('1($/4"+#1
F,(-8/1+(<($/*4',"/,($'1+1("-H1(-8+(4%A&"18+#1(-8'-('#+($/*4"&",)(-8+1+(1-%3=(
)%"3+1(',3(+K'*1(-/(1+&&(-/(1-%3+,-1
!
:+#+(2+(8'0+(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1
!
?8+=('#+(+,)')+3(",('(7%,3'*+,-'&&=(3"77+#+,-('$-"0"-"+1(
!
?+'$8+#1(8'0+(,/(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+(28+,(4#/0"3",)($/4"+1(-/(1-%3+,-1(
!
I,(+,-"#+($8'4-+#($/4"+3(A=(-+'$8+#("1(,/-(7'"#('1(-8+(4#/4/#-"/,(/7(-8+(2/#L(
3+'&",)(2"-8("1(,/-(7'"#(
!
?8+(-+'$8+#1('#+($/4=",)(+K$+#4-1(/7(-8+(2/#L
!
F-1(,/-(-8+(7'$-(-8'-(dee(+K$+#4-1(/7($/4=#")8-+3(2/#L(A+",)(3"1-#"A%-+3(-/(dee(
1-%3+,-19(-8'-H1('))#+)'-+J
!
?8'-H1(,/-(8/2(=/%(7")%#+(/%-(-8+('*/%,-(/7(-8+(3+'&",)
!
M8'-B1(-8+(4#/4/#-"/,(/7(-8'-($8'4-+#(-8'-(-8+(-+'$8+#(48/-/$/4"+3(
]'-8+#(=/%(8'0+(-/(&//L('-(-8+(2/#L(",(C%+1-"/,([+J)J($8'4-+#(<(/7('(A//L\((
!
9$Q/)")R#*/$+%3)%S)$-*)0.%0%.$+%3)3%$)"''.*'"$*A)
!
?8'-H1(,/-(-8+('*/%,-(/7(3+'&",)(-8'-H1(@%1-(-8+(A/%,3'#"+1(
F-1(4%#+('*/%,-9(,/(&/,)+#(4#/4/#-"/,
^%#+('*/%,-("1(,/-(,+)/-"'A&+
F7('(-+K-A//L(8'1(de($8'4-+#19(-8+,("-($',(A+$/*+('(4#/A&+*(28+#+A=('(,/J(/7(
4')+1(-8'-('$$%*%&'-+('(f(/7(4')+19(-8'-($/%&3($#/11(-8+(A/%,3'#"+1
!
M8+,(=/%B#+(3+'&",)(2"-8(4#/4/#-"/,(-8'-H1(,+)/-"'A&+(
!
?8+(4#/4/#-"/,(/7(-8+(2/#L1(A+",)(3"1-#"A%-+3(2+#+(#+'1/,'A&+(4#/4/#-"/,1(/7(
-8+(+K$+4-1(
!
?+K-A//L(4%A&"18+#1('#)%+3(-8'-(-8+('77+$-(/7(-8"1(L",3(/7(3+'&",)([-+'$8+#1(
3"1-#"A%-",)(48/-/$/4"+1(-/(1-%3+,-1\(-8'-(8'#*1(-8+*J
!
?8'-H1(/,+(/7(-8+(7'"#(7'$-/#1
?8+(+77+$-(/7(-8"1(3+'&([48/-/$/4=",)\
!
?8+('$$+11($/4=#")8-("1(1'=",)(/,(A+8'&7(/7(-8+(4%A&"18+#19(-8+=('#+(8%#-",)(
!
7".")IB
Lecture'12'*Tab'8
M+3,+13'=9( X+$+*A+#( S9(Se;d _P;>(^.

Only pages 1-3 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

!"#$%&'#('#)%*+,-(
!
!"#$%&%'()
./0+1(-/2'#31(',(+,3(4/",-(
!
!*&*%&%'+,"&
5/,64#"0'-+(7/#*(/7(3+'&",)(",(-8"1($'1+9(28"$8("1(,/-($/0+#+3(%,3+#(-8+(!!:(!','3"',(
1+-
!'-+)/#"+1(;(-/(<
!'-+)/#=(>("1(-8+#+(-+'$8(1'"3(=/%(3/(-8"1((
?8/1+(;;(@%3"$"'&(#+0"+21(2/%&3(,/-(8'0+(A++,($/4"+3(A=(-8+(&"A(4'-#/,1("7(
-8+=(2+#+,B-(#+C%+1-
!!:(D+#0"$+(2'1('-(-8+(#+C%+1-(/7(-8+(&'2=+#1(E(4'-#/,1
!
F,(-8"1($'1+(-8+1+(1-%3+,-1(2+#+(,/-(#+C%+1-",)(-8+($/4"+1(
!
G,(-8+(C%+1-"/,(/7(-8+($%1-/*(48/-/$/4=(1+#0"$+(-8'-H1(28+#+(!!:(!','3"',(3"77+#1(
7#/*(I&A+#-'($'1+J
!!:(',3(I&A+#-'($'1+(-8+=('#+('A1/&%-+&=(3"1-",)%"18'A&+(7#/*(-8+(7'$-1(',3(
$/,-+K-(/7(+3%$'-"/,(
!
?8+(0+#=(,'-%#+(/7(+3%$'-"/,("1(1%$8(-8'-(0+#=($/,-+K-(/#($/,$+4-(/7(-+'$8",)("1(
1%$8(-8'-(-+'$8+#1('1(4'#-(/7(-8+"#(@/AE+3%$'-"/,'&(+,0"#/,*+,-9(2"&&(*'L+(
$/4"+1('11"),(-8+*(-/(1-%3+,-1(+-$J
!
F,(-8'-($/,-+K-(1-%3+,-1(2"&&(#+C%+1-(-+'$8+#1(-/(*'L+($/4"+1
!
F-H1('(7'&1+(3"1-",)%"18*+,-(-8+,(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#(
!
?8+(3"$8/-/*=(AE2(-+'$8+#1(',3(1-%3+,-1(
!
M8+-8+#(/#(,/-(-8+#+("1(",(7'$-('(A/,'(7"3+(3"1-",)%"18'A&+(/7(@%3)+*+,-(",(!!:(
I(3"1-",$-($/,$+4-%'&"N'-"/,(/7(-+'$8+#1(',3(-8+"#(#/&+1(",(-8+($/,-+K-(/7(+3%$'-"/,
G,(-8+(/,+(1"3+(=/%(8'0+(-+'$8+#1(-8+,(-8+#+("1('(1+4'#'-+($/,$+4-%'&"N'-"/,(/7(-8+(
1-%3+,-
M8'-(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(3/+1(",('$$+4-",)('$$+11($/4=#")8-B1('#)%*+,-1(
?8'-H1(-8+(1+-(%4(",(-+#*1(/7(28'-('$$+11($/4=#")8-("1('#)%",)
!
D/(-+'$8+#(',3(1-%3+,-(28'-('#+(-8+"#(#/&+1(
!
?8+=('#+(*'L",)(-8+(48/-/$/4"+1
!
O"-8+#('-(-8+(#+C%+1-(/7(-8+(1-%3+,-1(/#('-(-8+"#(/2,(","-"'-"0+
!
I,3(-8+,(3"1-#"A%-",)(-8/1+($/4"+1(-/(1-%3+,-1((
!
?8+(7"#1-('44#/K"*'-"/,("1(@%1-(%,3+#1-',3(-+'$8+#E$/4"+#
!
?8+#+7/#+("7(=/%(8'0+(-8'-(3"1-",$-"/,(-8+,(1-%3+,-1(2/%&3(A+(-8+(
%1+#1
!
!*",-*.)"/),%0+*.
1$#2*3$/)"/)#/*./))
?8+"#(#/&+1(+11+,-"'&&=("1P
!
?8+(7"#1-($/,$+4-%'&(3"1-",$-"/,("1(AE2(-+'$8+#(',3(1-%3+,-(
I$$+11(1'=1(-+'$8+#1(*'L+($/4"+1(/7(A//L1(-8'-(-8+=(8'0+(#")8-1(-/(
!
F-1(,/-(8/2(-8+=('#+(*'L",)(-8+($/4"+1("1(-8+(4#/A&+*("-1(8/2(-8+=('#+(3+'&",)(
-8+($/4"+1
!
I$$+11("1(1'=",)(-+'$8+#1('#+(+,)')",)(",(%,7'"#(3+'&",)
!
4,,*//)5%0(.+'-$)
?'&L",)(4#/4/#-"/,1
!
?8+('*/%,-(/7(3+'&",)("1($/,$+#,+3(2"-8(4#/4/#-"/,'&"-=
!
Q/%(-'L+(-8+(2/#L(",(C%+1-"/,9(2/#L(-8'-("1(A+",)(3+'&-9(28'-("1(-8+(4#/4/#-"/,(
/7(2/#L(-8'-("1(A+",)(3+'&-(',3("1("-(',(%,7'"#('*/%,-(/7(-8'-(2/#LR
!
F7(=/%('#+(1-#+'*",)('(4#+0"+2(/7('(1/,)(-8'-("1(S(*",(-8'-("1(%,7'"#(4#/4/#-"/,(/7(
-8+(2/#L(",(3+'&",)
!
T++4(",(*",3(-8+(&/)"$(/7(8/2(-8+('*/%,-(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#9(8/2("-(
2'1('44&"+3(28+,(2+(1-%3"+3(4#+0"+21(
!
Q/%(-'L+(-8'-(&/)"$(-8+,(=/%(A#",)("-(-/(I&A+#-'(+3%$'-"/,9(28'-(=/%(8'0+(-8+,("1(
'($/4=#")8-+3(2/#L(-8'-("1(A+",)(3+'&-(2"-8
!
M8+,(=/%(8+'#("6%#3$ /7(-8+(2/#L(",(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#
F1(-8+(2/#L(2/#-8(3"11+*",'-",)(
!
F,(-8"1($'1+(28'-("1(-8+(,'-%#+(/7(-8+(2/#L(",(-8"1($'1+(
!
?8"1(2'1(,/-(/,+(/7(-8+(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(3+'&-(2"-8(*'@/#"-=(",(-8+(D!!
!
M8'-("1(-8+(3"$#.* /7(-8+(2/#L(-8+,R
?8"1("1(-8+(*/1-(1"),"7"$',-(/,+
?8"1("1(28+,(2+($/*+(",-/(-8+("3+'(/7(%,3+#1-',3",)(-8+(#/&+(/7(-8+(
-+'$8+#(',3(-8+(#/&+(/7(-8+(1-%3+,-
?8+(#/&+(/7(-8+(-+'$8+#("1(-8+($/4"+#9(#/&+(/7(-8+(1-%3+,-("1(%1+#
?8+(4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(=/%(8'0+(-/(&//L(',3($/,1"3+#(28'-("1(-8+(
4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(
M8+,(=/%('#+('44&=",)(-8"1(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#(/7(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(
"-H1(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+9(7#/*(28/1+(4+#14+$-"0+(3/(2+($/,1"3+#(",(-8+(3+'&",)(
',3(28+-8+#("-1(7'"#
U1+#1(#")8-1($/,$+4-
!
F,(DG!I5(0J(V+&&(2"-8(-8+(*%1"$(4#+0"+219(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+(=/%(-'L+("-H1(-8+(
4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-8+(+,3(%1+#J(
M8+,(=/%(8'0+(-8+(4#/A&+*(/7(*%1"$(4#+0"+21(-8+1+(A%1",+11+1(-8'-(
'&&/2(4+/4&+(-/(4#+0"+2(1/,)1(A+7/#+(4%#$8'1",)(-8+*9(-8'-(1-"&&(3+'&",)(
",(-8+($/4=#")8-+3(2/#L1
F,(DG!I5(0J(V+&&(!','3'(-8+(/&3(A%1",+11(*/3+&(2'1(-'L",)(7#/*(-8+(/&3(
7'18"/,(",(1-/#+(&"1-+,",)(-/(4#+0"+21(-/(/,&",+(1-#+'*",)(/7(4#+0"+21J
?8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3($/,$&%3+3(-8+(-+'$8+#('1(-8+($/4"+#(
?+'$8+#('1($/4"+#9(-8'-(A+$/*+1(-8+(3/*",',-(4+#14+$-"0+
7#.0%/*)
!
.'@/#"-=('33#+11+1(>(/7(-8+(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(",(-8"1($'1+(
?8+(-+'$8+#('1('($/4"+#(
!
5/2(2+(8'0+(-/(&//L('-(-8"1(7#/*(-8+(#/&+(/7(-8+(-+'$8+#
!
?8"1(7/$%1(/,(-8+(-+'$8+#(#+1%&-1(",(-8+(1$+,'#"/(28+#+A=(-8"1("1(,/-('(3+'&",)(7/#(
-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(.*/*".,-)%.)789:4!;)1!<=>J
!
?8+(4+#14+$-"0+(-8'-(2'1('3/4-+3(A=(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(2'1P
M8'-('$$+11($/4=#")8-('#)%+3(',3($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(')#++3
!
5/9(-8+=('#+(1%A@+$-(-/(#/='&-"+1(
M8+,(=/%(-'L+(4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#(',3(-/(3+-+#*",+(28+-8+#(/#(
,/-(-8+(48/-/$/4"+1(3"1-#"A%-+39("1(-8'-(7'"#(3+'&",)R
!
I&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(/7(7'"#(3+'&",)("1(#+1+'#$8(/#(4#"0'-+(1-%3=
!
M8+,(=/%('3/4-(4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#(=/%(,/(&/,)+#(8'0+(#+1+'#$8(
',3(1-%3=J
!
?8+(L+=(-+#*(-8+(2'=("-1($/,$+4-%'&"N+3("1(=/%(8'0+(",1-#%$-"/,
!
?8+(1-'-+(/7('77'"#(2'1('3/4-+3(',3('$$+4-+3(A=($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(',3(
1%A1+C%+,-&=(W+3+#'&($/%#-(/7('44+'&
!
M8'-(2+(8'0+(8+#+("1(',(",1-#%$-"/,9(-+'$8+#(48/-/$/4=",)(',3(8',3",)(-/(
1-%3+,-1(-/(1++(',3(#+'$8(-8+(48/-/$/4=9(-8+=('#+(1'=",)(-8'-H1(',(",1-#%$-"/,
!
D!!(3"3(,/-('#-"$%&'-+(",1-#%$-"/,('1(A+",)('&&/2'A&+(%1+39("-1(,/-('(7'"#(3+'&",)
!
F7("-1(,/-(7'"#(3+'&",)(-8+,('$$+11($/4=#")8-(2",1J(
!
M8'-("1(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(R
?8'-(3"1-",$-"/,(2'1(#+@+$-+3(A=(D!!(
!
F*4(-/(%,3+#1-',3(3"77+#+,$+(AE2(-8/1+(S($/,$+4-%'&"N'-"/,(/7(-+'$8+#('1('($/4"+#(
',3(1-%3+,-('1('(%1+#
?8"1(8'1(+0+#=-8",)(-/(3/(2"-8(%,3+#1-',3",)(-8+(+K4',1"0+(",-+#/4+#'-"/,()"0+,(-/(
+3%$'-"/,(A=(-8+(*'@/#"-=(/7(D!!(",(-8"1($'1+9(-8+=(8'0+(-'L+,(-8"1($/,$+4-(/7(1-%3=J
?8+(3+7","-"/,(/7(#+1+'#$8('1(',('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(2'1(A#/'3+,(-#+*+,3/%1&=(",(
DG!I5(0J(V+&&
F-(A+$/*+1(-8+($/#+(",-+&&+$-%'&($'1+(
!
Q/%($',-(8'0+(4#"0'-+(1-%3=("7(-8+#+B1(,/(4%A&"$(1-%3=
!
F-($',(/,&=(+K"1-(",(/44/1"-"/,(-/(1/*+-8",)(+&1+
!
5/2(2+(4"$L(%4(/,(4#"0'-+(1-%3=
X+4+,3",)(",(-8+(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-9(4#"0'-+(/#(4%A&"$(1-%3=("-1('&&(-8+(1'*+
!
F,1-#%$-"/,(7/&31(",-/(-8+($/,$+4-(/7(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(
!
?8"1("1(",(',(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-
!
?8+#+('#+(/-8+#($/,-+K-(=/%($/%&3(&//L('-(28+#+A=(-8+(#+'1/,",)(',3(4#+$+3+,-(
1+-(",(-8"1($'1+(*'=(,/-(A+('$$+4-+3
!
M8+,(2+('#+(3+'&",)(2"-8($/,$+4-(/7(+3%$'-"/,(-8+,(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(',3(
",1-#%$-"/,('#+(-8+(1'*+(-8",)
!
?8'-H1(/,+(/7(-8+(L+=('14+$-1(/7(D!!(",(-8"1($'1+(28+#+(-8+=($/##+$-+3('(0+#=(
1"),"7"$',-&=(%,#+'1/,'A&+(/%-$/*+(/7(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3B1(3+$"1"/,(
!
F-1($#%$"'&(-8'-(",1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-(1+4'#'-+3(7#/*("-1(A#/'3+#($/,$+4-(
!
X#"0",)('(2+3)+(AE2(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#(',3(1-%3+,-('1(%1+#(-8'-H1('#-"7"$"'&( ',3(
3'*')",)(',3($',,/-(1-',3J(
!
M8'-(-8+(/%-$/*+(/7(-8"1(@%3)+*+,-(3/+1(2"-8(#+14+$-(/7(*'@/#"-=(/7(D!!
D+4'#'-"/,("1(1/*+8/2(3"77+#+,-(7#/*(-+'$8",)('$$/#3",)(-/($/4=#")8-(A/'#3
!
?8+('#)%*+,-("1(A=(*'L",)(-8+1+($/4"+1(/,(-8+"#(/2,(","-"'-"0+9(8',3",)(-8+(-/(
1-%3+,-1(-8'-("1('(7/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,
!
I,3(D!!(#+@+$-1(-8"1('#)%*+,-(
!
93/$.#,$+%3)"1(1"),"7"$',-(8+#+
F-H1('(2'=(",(1%$8(-8'-($/,$+4-%'&"N",)(-8+($&'11#//*(',3(-8+(7/#*(/7(1-%3=(",(
1%$8(4&'$+
!
F,1-#%$-"/,(",(1/*+(3"1-",$-('$-"0"-=("1(4#/A&+*'-"$(
!
?8+('*%'."0-( /7(-8+($&'11#//*
M8+,(=/%(4%-("-(",(',(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-(-8+,(",1-#%$-"/,9(4#"0'-+(/#(4%A&"$(1-%3=("-1(
'&&(-8+(1'*+(-8",)(
M8'-(=/%(8'0+("1(",('(1$8//&(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-(",1-#%$-"/,(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=9(
-8+=('#+(-'%-/&/)"$'&9(-8+=(3/,H-(1+4'#'-+J
!
?8+(2+3)+(-8'-("1(1+4'#'-+3(AE2(",1-#%$-"/,(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(A=($/4=#")8-(
A/'#3("1(#+@+$-+3(A=(D!!J
!
!/4=#")8-(A/'#3(1'=1(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1('#+(+,)')+3(",('(7/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,(A=(
-8+(,'-%#+(/7(8/2(-8+=('#+(3+'&",)(2"-8(-8+($/4"+1J
!
F,1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-(',('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(7/#(7'"#(3+'&",)(%,3+#(-8+(!!:(!','3"',(
-+1-
!
W/#(7'"#(3+'&",)(-8+#+(8'1(-/(A+(/,+(/7(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+19(2+(8'0+(/,&=(
A++,($/,$+#,+3(2"-8(#+1+'#$8(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=J(
!
W/#(1-+4(;(-8+#+(2'1(,/(4#/A&+*9("-1('44&=",)(-8+(&/)"$(/7(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(-/(-8+(
7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(-8+*1+&0+1(
!
F-H1(-8+('44&"$'-"/,(7/(-8+($/,$+4-(/7(4#"0'-+(1-%3=
!
F-H1(-8+(7'"#,+11(+&+*+,-(-8'-H1('-("11%+
!
F-1(8/2(",(/-8+#(2/#31(28+-8+#(/#(,/-(3+'&",)("1(7'"#('-("11%+
!
?"+.)2*"&+3'
I$-(/7(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1
.'3+(A=(-+'$8+#1(-/(3"1-#"A%-+(-/(1-%3+,-1
I-(-8+(-+'$8+#B1(","-"'-"0+;J
Y/(A'$L(-/(!!:
!
:/2(=/%($/,$+4-%'&"N+(-8+(0+#=(,'-%#+(/7(1+#0"$+1(
!
M/#3(#+C%+1-("1($#%$"'&
!
I-(-8+(1-%3+,-B1(#+C%+1-(SJ
S('$-1
!&'11(",1-#%$-"/,
F1(-8"1('$-"0"-=('&&/2'A&+(7/#(-8+(4%#4/1+1(/7(-8+(7'"#(3+'&",)(+K$+4-"/,
Z'1-(1+,-+,$+
!
7".")@)0'A)@B)C-+'-&+'-$)&"$*.D
:/2('1(-+'$8+#('1($/4"+#('$$+4-+3('1('($'-+)/#=
!
U,3+#1-',3(3"77+#+,$+(AE2($'-+)/#"+1(;6<(',3($'-+)/#=(>
!
;6<("1(&"-+#'&&=(28+#+(-8+=(#+$/#3(48/-/$/4"+1(*'3+(A=(-+'$8+#1(A%-(*'3+('(
#+C%+1-(/7(-8+(1-%3+,-1
!
Y/(A'$L(-/(!!:(-/(%,3+#1-',3(-8+(1"*"&'#(4#'$-"$+( 28+#+A=(-8+(1",)&+($/4"+1(/7(
-8+($/4=#")8-+3(&+)'&(2/#L1(",(!!:(*'3+('-(-8+(#+C%+1-(/7(-8+(4'-#/,1(
!
?8'-('14+$-(/7(!!:(!','3"',
!
7".")E
!'-+)/#=(>(
!
!/4"+1(2+#+(*'3+('-(-+'$8+#1(","-"'-"0+1(
!
7".")F
!/,$&%1"/,(/7($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(
!
F3+'(/7('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+1
!
V/'#3($/,$&%3+3(-8'-($'-+)/#=(>($/4"+1(2+#+(*'3+('-(-+'$8+#B1(","-"'-"0+(',3("-(
2'1(7/#(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(/7(#+1+'#$8(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=([1-+4(;\
!
V%-(28+,(=/%(*/0+(-/(1-+4(S(/7(!!:(-+1-9($'-+)/#=(>($/4"+1(3"3(,/-($/,1-"-%-+(
7'"#(3+'&",)(',3(2+#+(-8+#+7/#+(1%A@+$-(-/(#/='&-=
!
7".")G
?8+(7+3+#'&($/%#-(/7('44+'&($/,$&%3+3(-8'-($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(",(-+#*1(/7(8/2(
-8+=(3+'&-(2"-8($'-+)/#=(>('-(-8+(-+'$8+#1(","-"'-"0+9(-8+=(2+#+(,/-(7'"#(3+'&",)(
',3(-8+=(1'"3(-8'-(3+-+#*",'-"/,(A=($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(2'1(-/-'&&=(#+'1/,'A&+
!
7".")@H
D!!(1'"3(-8+1+('#)%*+,-1('#+(%,#+'1/,'A&+
!
?8+(*'@/#"-=(D!!(')#++(2"-(-8+($/'&"-"/,('#)%*+,-
!
?8+=(3/(,/-('$$+4-('$$+11($/4=#")8-1('#)%*+,-1('$$+4-+3(A=($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(
',3(%48+&3(A=(-8+(7+3+#'&($/%#-(/7('44+'&(
!
7".")@@
5/2(2+('#+(*/0",)(",-/(/-8+#(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#
F-(2'1(-8+(C%+1-"/,(/7(-8+('44&"$'-"/,(/7(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(A=(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(-8'-(
'#+('-("11%+J
?8+(D!!(')#++1(2"-8(I&A+#-'(+3%$'-"/,($/'&"-"/,(-8'-(-8+(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(2+#+(
",$/##+$-&=('44&"+3(A=(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3J
?8+(A"))+1-(',3(*/1-(4#/A&+*'-"$("1(-8+(0#.0%/*)7'$-/#J(
]+0"+2(/7(!!:(!','3"',(-+1-
!
7".")@I
F-H1(-8+(*'@/#"-=(@%3)+*+,-(-8'-(3+-+#*",+1(8/2(-8",)1(2/#L(
V")($/,$+#,("1()/",)(-/(A+(*',')",)(3")"-'&(*'-+#"'&1(',3(*',')",)(-8+($#+'-/#1(',3(
%1+#1(#")8-1J
I44#+$"'-",)(-8+("*4&"$'-"/,1(/7(-8+(D!!(",(-8+($/,-+K-(/7(%1+#1(#")8-1(",(',(
+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-J
?8+("*4&"$'-"/,1(/7(-8+(@%3)+*+,-('#+(1%$8(-8'-(",(',(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-(28'-(3/+1(
-8'-(*+',(
?8+(3"1-",$-"/,(AE2(4#"0'-+(',3(4%A&"$(1-%3=("1(+77+$-"0+&=(+#'1+3(A=(D!!(
^'#'(;<6S_(*/1-("*4(7/#(3+-+#*",",)(7'"#(3+'&",)(
W"#1-(1-+4(7'"#(3+'&",)P(28+-8+#("-("1(7/#(4%#4/1+(/7(#+1+'#$8(/#(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(;J
?8+(7"#1-(1-+4(-8+(&',)%')+(#+1+'#$8(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=('#+(,/-(',("11%+(/#(
$/,$+4-%'&(4#/A&+*1
!
M8+#+(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(A+$/*+1('($/,$+4-%'&(4#/A&+*("1('-(1-+4(S(/7(-8+(!!:(
!','3"',(-+1-(28+#+A=(2+(3+-+#*",+(28'-B1(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(7'"#(3+'&",)
!
?8'-H1(28=(2+(8'0+('(!/4=#")8-(A/'#3(',3('$$+11($/4=#")8-('#)%",)(-8+(
)+/)#'48"$'&('14+$-(/7(-8+($&'11#//*
!
W/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,P(,/,64#"0'-+(1-%3=(
!
?8+($/,$+4-(/7(",1-#%$-"/,('1("-('44&"+1(8+#+(A/-8($/,,/-+1(',3(3+,/-+1('(4%A&"$(
7/#*(/7(1-%3=(-8'-(-'L+1(4&'$+(",(-8+($&'11#//*9(",(-8+($/,-+K-("-1(,/-(4#"0'-+J(
!
?8+(4/",-("1("-1(,/-(`4#"0'-+`
!
F,1-#%$-"/,(-8+#+7/#+(",('($&'11#//*(-8'-(7/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-(4#"0'-+(
!
Y+,+#'&&=("-1('$$+4-+3(-8'-(/L(-8+#+B1(,/("11%+(8+#+(/,('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(/7(
#+1+'#$8(',3(1-%3=9(-8'-H1(,/-(-8+("11%+J(M8'-($/*+1(-/("11%+("1(-8+(2/#3(
`4#"0'-+`(
!
?8+(3"1-",$-"/,(1+-(%4(A=(-8+(A/'#3(
?8"1("1('(7/#*(/7(",1-#%$-"/,9(,/-(4#"0'-+(1-%3=
!
7".")@B
M8'-B1(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)("-1+&7SJ
F,(DG!I5(0J(V+&&(!','3'(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(",(-8'-($'1+(2'1(1-#+'*",)(
,/-(3/2,&/'3",)J([-8'-H1("*4\
!
M8'-("1(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)(",(-8"1($'1+P(0-%$%,%0(+3'
!
Q+1("-("1(A+$'%1+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)("-1(48/-/$/4=",)
^8/-/$/4=",)('1(',('$-"0"-=(",(',(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,$+4-("1('$$+4-'A&+(7/#(
4#"0'-+(1-%3=(/#(#+1+'#$8J(
?8'-H1(28=(-8+#+B1(,/-('(4#/A&+*('-(1-+4(;(
Q/%(8'0+(-/(7/$%1(/,(-8+("3+'(/7(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)P(
48/-/$/4=",)(",(-8+(+3%$'-"/,'&($/,-+K-
W/#(-8+(7"#1-(4'#-(/7(!!:9(1'=1("1(-8+(3+'&",)(7/#(/,+(/7(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+1R
!
M8+#+("-(A+$/*+1(-8+(4#/A&+*(28"$8(+11+,-"'&&=($+,-#+3(/,(-8+(S,3(1-+4(/7(-8+(
-+1-
!
M8+-8+#(-8+($'-+)/#=(>($/4"+1([$/4"+1('-(-8+(","-"'-"0+(/7(-8+(-+'$8+#\(2+#+(7'"#J(
!
?8+=('#+(1'=",)(-8'-("1(,/-(7'"#(3+'&",)(A+$'%1+(28+,(=/%(&//L('-(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(
-8+(3+'&",)(28'-B1(-8+(7"#1-(-8",)(=/%(8'0+(-/($/,1"3+#9(D!!(1'"3(28/1+(
4+#14+$-"0+("1(-8"1(7#/*J(
!
^+#14+$-"0+(/7(-8+(-+'$8+#('1(-8+(48/-/$/4"+#9(',3(",1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-('(7'$-/#(/7(
7'"#,+11(",(!!:9(-8+#+7/#+("-1(,/-(',('&&/2'A&+(%1+('$$/#3",)(-/('$$+11($/4=#")8-(
'1(-8+=(1'=("-1(,/(28+#+(",(8+#+
!
F,1-#%$-"/,(",(-8"1($/,-+K-("1('(,/,64#"0'-+(1-%3=(-8+#+7/#+(-8+=(",0/L+(-8+(
$/,$+4-(/7(-8+()+/)#'48=(/7(-8+($&'11#//*(',3(-8+(,'-%#+(/7(-8+(",1-#%$-"/,(
-8'-(-'L+1(4&'$+(-8'-(&+'31(-/(-8+(%,#+'1/,'A&+($/,3%$-(A=(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(
',3(#/='&-"+1(*%1-(A+(4'"3('1(-8+=(3+-+#*",+("-1(,/-(7'"#(3+'&",)J
!
D!!(1'"3(-8+=('#+(2#/,)(
D+4'#'-"/,(AE2(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1(',3(-'L",)(",1-#%$-"/,(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(',3(
1+4'#'-",)(
!
?8+,(=/%('#+(4#/4+#&=(%,3+#1-',3",)(-8+(0+#=(7%,3'*+,-'&(,'-%#+(',3(
4%#4/1+(/7(+3%$'-"/,
Q/%($',-(1+4'#'-+(-8+*(",(-8"1($/,-+K-('-(&+'1-(
!
F-H1('(1=*A"/-"$(#+&'-"/,18"4(AE2(-+'$8+#1(',3(1-%3+,-1
93/$.#,$+%3)"32)0.+J"$*)/$#2()+/)$"#$%&%'+,"&
!
7".")@K
!'-+)/#=(;6<($/4"+1(2+#+(1-%3+,-(#+C%+1-+3($/4"+1
!
I-("11%+(8+#+('-(-8+(7'"#(3+'&",)(4#/A&+*(2+#+($'-+)/#=(>('1(-8+=(2+#+(,/-('-('(
1-%3+,-(#+C%+1-(-8+#+7/#+(A/'#3($/,$&%3+3(-8'-(-8+=('#+(,/-(7/#(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(
4#"0'-+(1-%3=
!
?8/1+('#+(S(0+#=(3"77+#+,-('$-1(-8'-(8'0+(4#/7/%,3("*4&"$'-"/,1(7/#(8/2(-8+(
$/4=#")8-(A/'#3(1+-(/%-(-/(3+-+#*",+(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(3+'&",)(',3(28+-8+#(-8'-(
3+'&",)(2'1(7'"#(
!
F,(!!:(-8+(48/-/$/4"+1(2+#+('-(-8+(`#+C%+1-`(/7(-8+(4'-#/,1(E(&'2=+#1(
!
D/(A+$'%1+(-8+#+(2'1(,/(1%$8(#+C%+1-(7/#($'-+)/#=(>($/4"+1(-8+($/4=#")8-(A/'#3(
",(-8"1($'1+($/,$&%3+(-8'-(-8+(4#+63/*",',-(4%#4/1+(2'1(*'",&=(-8'-(/7(-+'$8+#9(
*'",&=(",1-#%$-"/,(/#(`,/,64#"0'-+(1-%3=`J(
!
D!!(1'"3(-8'-H1(4#/A&+*'-"$('44#/'$8
W#/*(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-+'$8+#('1('($/4"+#
!
M8+,(=/%(7/$%1(/,(1-%3+,-1('1('(%1+#(-8+,(2+('#+(",0/L",)(%1+#B1(#")8-1
!
D!!(",(4#+0"/%1(@%3)+*+,-1(8'1(A++,(0+#=($&+'#(28+,(=/%(&//L('-(DJ(Sa(2"-8(
#+14+$-(-/(7'"#(3+'&",)1([%1+#B1(#")8-1\9(-8+(D!!(8'1(A++,(0+#=(0")/#/%1(",(1+--",)(
'(2'=(7/#2'#3(",('$L,/2&+3)",)(-8'-(%1+#1(#")8-1('#+(4'#'*/%,-(',3(-8+=(8'0+(
-/(A+(#+'3(*L0"3/+J*&(A)[3+#"0+1(7#/*(!!:9(?8+A+#)+9(DG!I5(0J(V+&&9(+-$J\J(5/-(
,'##/2(",-+#4#+-'-"/,(/7(%1+#1(#")8-19(28"$8(2/%&3(&"L+&=(4#/3%$+('(3"77+#+,-(
/%-$/*+(A+$'%1+("-(2/%&3($/,1-#'",(-8+(1$/4+(/7(28'-($/,1-"-%-+1('(4#"0'-+(
1-%3=J(
!
F7(=/%(7/$%1(/,(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1(4+#14+$-"0+("-(1+-1(%4(-8+(7'&1+(3"$8/-/*=9(
-8'-(2+3)+(AE2(-+'$8+#1(',3(1-%3+,-1J
!
D!!(1'"3(2+(8'0+(-/(7/&&/2(-8+(#+'1/,",)(1+-(",(DG!I5(0J(V+&&9(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(
-8+(3+'&",)(*%1-(A+(%,3+#1-//3(7#/*(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+(/7(-8+(+,3(%1+#
!
?8+,($&+'#&=(-8+('#-"7"$"'&(2+3)+(AE2(-8/1+(S(3"1'44+'#1(',3(=/%(8'0+(
-'%-/&/)"$'&(#+&'-"/,18"4(',3(-8+#+7/#+("-(A+$/*+1(%,-+,'A&+(-/(1+4'#'-+(
",1-#%$-"/,(',3(4#"0'-+(1-%3=J(
M8+,(=/%(7/$%1(1-%3+,-('1(%1+#9("-(3/+1,H-(*'--+#(28+-8+#(-8+(1-%3+,-('1L+3(
7/#('(48/-/$/4=(/#(-+'$8+#(/,(-8+"#(/2,(","-"'-"0+(48/-/$/4"+3(',3(3"1-#"A%-+3(
-/(1-%3+,-19(-8'-H1(28'-(-+'$8",)("1(",('(A#/'3+#($/,-+K-9(',3(-8'-H1('(0"-'&(
$/,-+K-J
!
!'-+)/#=(>(2'1(1'"3(-/(A+(%,7'"#('$$/#3",)(-/(-8+(A/'#3(2'1(A+$'%1+("-(2'1(7/#('(
,/,64#"0'-+(1-%3=J
!
F,1-#%$-"/,("1(,/-(1+4'#'-+(7#/*(4#"0'-+(1-%3=P(D!!
!
7".")@M
<(L",31(/7($'1+1(
!
<(",1-',$+1(28+#+(=/%(8'0+(
!
I--+*4-1(A=($/**+#$"'&(%,3+#-'L",)
!
V+$'%1+(-8+#+("1(',(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+(/7(-8+(4%A&"18+#19(+,-"-"+1(-8'-('#+(
3+'&",)(2"-(-8+1+(2/#L1J(?8+=('#+(1'=",)(-8+(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+("1($/**+#$"'&(
A+$'%1+(=/%($',-(4#/7"-(",(-8"1($/,-+K-J(
?8'-(4#/7"-(*/-"0+("1(4#/A&+*'-"$
?8"1($/,$+4-(/7(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+("1('44&"+3(-/(-8"1($'1+(
?8+($/%#-1(",(+'$8(/7(-8/1+($'1+1('&&($/,$&%3+3(-8'-('&-8/%)8(-8+(3+'&",)(*'=(
/1-+,1"0+&=(A+(7/#(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(/7(#+1+'#$8(/#(4#"0'-+(1-%3=9(28+,(=/%(
*/0+(-/(-8+(7'"#,+11($/*4/,+,-(/7(-8+(-+1-([28+-8+#(-8'-(3+'&",)("1(7'"#\(-8+=(
'#+(,/-J(
!
7".")@E)$%)@N
The$court$held…rejecting$argument
!
It$could$not$be$contended…nor$if$an$author$produced…
!
7".")@F
!/%#-(#+@+$-1('&&(-8/1+(<($'1+1('1(-8/1+('%-8/#"-"+1(8'0+(,/(2+")8-(",(-8"1(
",1-',$+
!
This$expressly$contradicts$CCH…
!
Research$is$not$limited$to$non=commercial$or$private$context
!
?8"1("3+'(-8'-(4#"0'-+($/,-+K-(28+,(=/%(&//L('-(!::9(-8+('&&/2'A&+(4%#4/1+(
%,3+#(-8+(7'"#(3+'&",)(4#/0"1"/,19(!!:("1(28+,(2+(",-+#4#+-(#+1+'#$8("-1(,/-(
&"*"-+3(,/,6$/**+#$"'&(/#(4#"0'-+($/,-+K-J
!
?8"1("1(@%1-"7"$'-"/,(7/#(,++3(-/(1-+4(A'$L
!
W'"#(3+'&",)(',3(%1+#1(#")8-1(*%1-(A+()"0+,(*L0"3/+J*)",-+#4#+-'-"/,J
!
7".")@G
<&$*.+%.)6%$+J*
!
F,(-8"1($'1+(4%#4/1+(/7(48/-/$/4=",)([-8'-H1(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(3+'&",)\9(
C%+1-"/,("1(28+-8+#(/7(,/-(-8"1(48/-/$/4=",)(7'"#
!
?8+1+('#+(,/-(1-+419(-8+=('#+('44&"+3
?8+=('#+(,/-(1-'-%-/#=(#+C%"#+*+,-1(
?8+=('#+(1%A@+$-(/7(7'$-/#1(-8'-('#+(-8+#+(-/(A+('44&"+3(#+&'-"0+&=(
1%A@+$-"0+&=
M8"$8("1(28=(/,&=(>(/7(-8+*(-8'-('#+('-("11%+(-#+'-+3(A=(*'@/#"-=('-(D!!(
F,(!::9(D!!('3/4-+3(-8+(%1+(/7(b(7'"#,+11(7'$-/#1(
!
F,(-8"1($'1+(-8+(-+'$8+#1(3/(,/-(3"14&'=(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+19(-8+($8'#'$-+#(/7(-8+(
3+'&",)9(48/-/$/4=",)c-8+#+B1(,/(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+
!
F-H1('($'1+(28+#+A=(=/%(8'0+(-+'$8+#1(+,)')",)(",(",1-#%$-"/,
!
D!!(28+-8+#(",1-#%$-"/,(/#(,/-9(4#"0'-+(1-%3=(',3(",1-#%$-"/,('#+(1'*+(+11+,-"'&(
'$-"0"-=(-8'-(*'L+(%4(A'1"$(+K+#$"1+1( ",('(1-',3'#3(+3%$'-"/,(
!
7".")IH
W'"#(3+'&",)("1(',(+K$+4-"/,9("-('&&/21(=/%(-/(+1$'4+(&"'A"&"-=(7/#($/4=#")8-(",7#",)+*+,-
./1-("*4(/,+(",(-8+(+,-"#+(#+'3",)(
!
7".")IIO)IBO)IKO)IM
F*4($/*4',"/,($'1+(
!
5++3(-/(#+'3(-8"1(/,+(",($/,@%,$-"/,(2"-8(DG!I5(0J(V+&&(!','3'
!
?8+(L+=(-+#*(8+#+("1(P.*&*J"3$)0*./0*,$+J*P
!
M8'-("1(-8+(4%#4/1+(/7(-8+(3+'&",)P("-($/*+1(3/2,(-/(#+&+0',-(4+#14+$-"0+
!
?8'-H1(28+#+(D!!(1+-1(/%-(
!
W'"#(3+'&",)("1('(%1+#1(#")8-(
!
D-%3+,-1(
?8+(1-%3+,-1('#+(%1",)(-8+(*'-+#"'&1(-8+#+7/#+(-8+(%&-"*'-+(+,3(%1+#(
2/%&3(A+(-8+(1-%3+,-(
?8+#+7/#+(-8+(4+#14+$-"0+(=/%(-'L+(28+,($/,1"3+#",)(1-%3+,-19(-8+"#(%1+1(
/7(-8+(3+'&",)1(-8'-(3+-+#*",+1(/,(8/2(=/%($/*+(3/2,(-/(-8+(C%+1-"/,(
/7(8/2(=/%(%1+(-8+(3+'&",)(
M8/('#+(-8+(%1+#1(",(-8"1($'1+R
!
7".")II
I&A+#-'(O3%$'-"/,(A+",)(3"1-",)%"18+3(7#/*(-8/1+(<($'1+1(-8'-(I$$+11(2'1(
#+&=",)(/,
!
?8+(4%A&"18+#1('1($/4"+#1([",(-8/1+(<($'1+1\("1(3"1-",)%"18'A&+(7#/*(-+'$8+#1('1(
$/4"+#1
!
^%A&"18+#('1($/4"+#1
F,(-8/1+(<($/*4',"/,($'1+1("-H1(-8+(4%A&"18+#1(-8'-('#+($/*4"&",)(-8+1+(1-%3=(
)%"3+1(',3(+K'*1(-/(1+&&(-/(1-%3+,-1
!
:+#+(2+(8'0+(-+'$8+#1('1($/4"+#1
!
?8+=('#+(+,)')+3(",('(7%,3'*+,-'&&=(3"77+#+,-('$-"0"-"+1(
!
?+'$8+#1(8'0+(,/(%&-+#"/#(*/-"0+(28+,(4#/0"3",)($/4"+1(-/(1-%3+,-1(
!
I,(+,-"#+($8'4-+#($/4"+3(A=(-+'$8+#("1(,/-(7'"#('1(-8+(4#/4/#-"/,(/7(-8+(2/#L(
3+'&",)(2"-8("1(,/-(7'"#(
!
?8+(-+'$8+#1('#+($/4=",)(+K$+#4-1(/7(-8+(2/#L
!
F-1(,/-(-8+(7'$-(-8'-(dee(+K$+#4-1(/7($/4=#")8-+3(2/#L(A+",)(3"1-#"A%-+3(-/(dee(
1-%3+,-19(-8'-H1('))#+)'-+J
!
?8'-H1(,/-(8/2(=/%(7")%#+(/%-(-8+('*/%,