PHI 2396 Lecture Notes - Deontological Ethics, Sperm Donation, Gene Therapy
Document Summary
Resnick"s thesis: we should make a distinction between genetic therapy and genetic enhancement (the distinction doesn"t mark a firm moral boundary between moral and immoral genetic intervention). Genetic therapy and genetic enhancement and health: two approaches to health and disease: descriptive and value- laden. Descriptive: normal is typical and anything that does not fall under the species-typical traits is considered abnormal. Genetic therapy should not be considered a threat to normality" but genetic enhancement performed on healthy people, should be. But the descriptive approach can"t tell us whether one or the other is moral or immoral. The value-laden approach: our understanding of health and disease is based on moral, cultural and social norms. Under this approach, genetic therapy is morally good because it helps us fight disease which is considered bad. Resnick: the answer depends on the scope of our definitions of health and disease.