• If you have only one life, what are you going to do with it?
• Employee want—success in life (happiness)
• Employee right—right to quit (freedom)
• Don’t underestimate the value of a good work environment
• Employer wants money
o You make more money by having enthusiastic workers. Studies back this up
• What Makes a good work environment?
o Doing something you like
o Working with people you like
• When you have that, perhaps shouldn’t just look at the money
• Family vs work
o Employer want—fair pay for fair pay
o But what exactly is pay?
• Working for free
o Unpaid Internship o Should there be a difference between “unpaid interning” and working? Should
workers be entitled to minimum wage?
o Business supports unpaid internships
*Marx spoke of how worker competition would drive wages down to
subsitence. Has it began sinking below subsistence?
o Should government regulate internships?
• Should government get involved in business?
o Milton Friedman—leave business alone. Let the market decide
• Minimum wage laws? Why not allow businesses to decide how much they want to pay
o Employer Rights (or at least wants)—leave me alone, when it comes to business
Put up all risk, money for business. Why should gov come in and tell
them what to pay their employees
• Job Market
o If you are not willing to compete, job goes to somebody else
• Milton Friedman against min. Wage—well meaning, but ensures that those without skills
to justify earning w/e minimum wage is will be unemployed.
o Min wage laws are a direct contributor, then, to youth unemployment
• Equal pay for equal work o So, business shouldn’t negotiate based on experience or anything else save
what actual work is being done
• Employee wants
o Right to quit
• Mike Handerson—business not forced to do these. But should anyways, because its
o 1) Right to your employee information. What is your status in the company?
Job secure? What’s your standing. Without this, insecurity.
o 2) Right to fair pay
What’s fair? Generally , equal pay for equal work. Even if not a right,
makes for a better working environment, reduces employee resentment
o 3) Right not to be fired for invalid reason
As the boss, can fire and hire whoever want. But if fire people on a whim,
will make for bad work environment. A smart boss will only fire for valid
reasons, to set examples
o 4) Right to be free from unjust discrimination
Is racism (or the like) smart business? Almost definitely not.
• Unjust discrimination
o Making decisions based on gender, race, religion, etc. o Should government do something about it?
If yes, then you believe in gov interference in business. And if you believe
in that here, why not other places as well?
o Is discrimination on basis okay? Less unjust than racism?
o Hiring quotas
o In certain business, say perhaps where clientele are racists, is racism in business
• Dimock and Tucker—
o Hiring quotas—if white and male, at bottom of list. Anything else, higher.
Aren’t hiring quotas just another form of unjust discrimination?
Or is it correcting an imbalance? Is that a valid response?
o If believe in hiring quotas, then believe that end justifies the means
Canadian Constitution—must not discriminate on the basis of race,
gender, etc.. But, discrimination okay if it helps such identifiable groups
for the sake of having more equal society with full participation
o Non-descrimination Kantian (deontological)
o But, employment equity
o Both are together in Canadian constitution
o Hiring quotas
Those who are for them argue on both utilitarian and deontological
Justice – deontological
1) compensatory – somebody wronged me, now they owe me. Righted
• Because certain people were unjustly discriminated in the past
o Group membership alone is not proof of discrimination
o Majority of people formerly discriminated against in past
are not now the ones benefitting from hiring quotas
2) distributive – equal access, not to be discriminated against
• How do we define that person’s special access? If we want to
have a hiring quota, how do we categorize people? The blond, lesbian, black woman deserves to be hir