Class Notes (837,298)
Canada (510,219)
POL2107 (114)
Lecture 4

Lecture 4 - The Republic III, IV & V
Premium

5 Pages
125 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Political Science
Course
POL2107
Professor
Sophie Bourgault
Semester
Fall

Description
Oct. 10, 2013 MIDTERM (Antigone – Apology - Book I-V Republic) Part A: Antigone – Apology essays -Creon’s approach to politics -the accusations made to Socrates (summary and info) Part B: Republic *STRONG THESIS STATEMENT AND PRESENTATION OF ARGUMENTS THE REPUBLIC (BOOK 3-5)  Is about education (not so much about politics)  The soul of the city 1. Music/Poetry (BK III)  Functions to be played by music  The education of the child should begin with the soul  Their care givers are those responsible for this education  First few years are the most important because that phase will determine who they become; good attitude towards law, their elders, the city, the gods, etc.  Music is this powerful tool – state should censor wet-nurses and poetry  No stories about death and fearing the gods, no images of violence or cruelty  The beginning of any process is most important; especially for something young and tender; most malleable (377b)  Education should begin at a young age when minds and young and impressionable  Ideas that are imprinted; patterns of self control, courage, beauty, anything that will encourage virtue, intellectual curiosity, attachment and dedication to the city  The rest should be purged  Stories about greedy citizens, gods that lie and cheat. Those promoting falsehood are to be kicked out of the city  Emotional and educational development  Children raised by the state  378b – why we should purge – because the young cannot distinguish what is allegorical from what isn’t.  What should be allowed – stories about the gods (379-382); 1) a god can only be the cause of good things; 2) a god is always consistent 3) a god does not deceive or speak falsely  The gods have no needs for lie and deception, they are perfect beings  No stories that create fear of death should be permitted – they will grow up afraid to be soldiers  Create people that can control their desires in the face of temptation; money, sex, food, power.  Self control in citizens and soldiers – always fragile – even the philosophers kings are capable of giving in to temptations  Socrates is the only one Plato mentions, who is capable of resisting all temptations  What style should good music have?  Bad music = bad politics  FUNCTIONS OF MUSIC st  1 - Early childhood matters most for moral character  Best tool to shape the minds of future soldiers and citizens  Music goes straight to the soul  401d – Socrates tells Glaucon why education, music and poetry are important – permeates the soul more than anything else; bringing it grace…  Music is a way to tune the soul, put it in harmony  Prerequisite for all future learning; mathematics, history, etc. nd  2 – music possesses a healing function – has the ability to cure the soul and the mind  Children are restless, use music and dance as methods of teaching  Music provides the tools for developing proper judgment  Aesthetic judgment used to judge music and politics  Apply what is learned through the arts in politics (402)  Transfer the good taught to children into the realm of politics  Good music may not necessarily make you a good person, but it is necessary to becoming a good person.  Music can be used as a tool to foster unity, loyalty, and great care for the city  Self-improvement  Who should be in charge? On what basis are we to judge the best -aux (soldiers) -guardians (ruling class) 2. The noble lie: 2 purposes *Plato on truth/lies…tension here?  The myth of the metals  414c – in the best case the story would persuade even the rulers and those in the city  Phoenicians tale in which all members of the city are raised by mother earth – experiences and knowledge are a dream  1 - Earth a
More Less

Related notes for POL2107

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit