Class Notes (838,058)
Canada (510,633)
POL354Y5 (11)
Schwartz (11)
Lecture

NATIONAL INSTITUTIONS

23 Pages
68 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Political Science
Course
POL354Y5
Professor
Schwartz
Semester
Fall

Description
FEATURES OF A DEMOCRATIC CONSTITUTION FUNDAMENTAL / BASIC / HIGHEST LAW SUBSTANTIVE FUNCTION: IDENTIFY COLLECTIVE & INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS & RESPONSIBILITIES PROCEDURAL FUNCTION: PROVIDE CONTEXT FOR RULE OF LAW IDENTIFY BASIC STATE INSTITUTIONS: • POWERS • JURISDICTIONS • LIMITS • RELATIONS IDENTIFY TERRITORIAL LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT & THEIR JURISDICTIONS CHALLENGES TO CONSTITUTIONALISM IN RUSSIA LACK OF HISTORY OF CONSTITUTIONALISM NEED TO BUILD ENTIRE NEW SYSTEM: COMPLEX SET OF TASKS NEED TO BE ACHIEVED SIMULTANEOUSLY ABSENCE OF A “LEGAL CULTURE” ABSENCE OF COMPARATIVE EXPERIENCE GAP BETWEEN AUTHORITY AND POWER SPECIFIC FEATURES OF ELTSIN’S CONSTITUTION UNILATERALLY INTRODUCED AMBIGUOUS APPROVAL AMBIGUITIES & OMISSIONS  “WAR OF LAWS” PRESIDENTIAL POWERS FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO INABILITY TO REACH CONSENSUS ON CONSTITUTION POLITICAL CULTURE: • PAST RESORT TO AUTHORITARIAN RULE IN CRISIS • NEGATIVE ATTITUDES TO "COMPROMISE" • NEGATIVE ATTITUDES TO "OPPOSITION" • LACK OF TOLERANCE OF DIVERSITY • CYNICISM OF POLITICS & POLITICIANS • L ACK OF RESPECT OF "LAW" (RULES, PROCEDURES) • FLUIDITY OF NATIONAL IDENTITY POLITICAL CIRCUMSTANCES: • ABSENCE OF POLITICAL PARTIES • POLARIZATION OF SOCIETY • FRAGMENTATION OF CENTRIST COALITION • PERSONALIZED POLITICAL LEADERSHIP • MUTUAL THREATS AT HIGH LEVEL • ABSENCE OF SECURITY FOR THOSE EXCLUDED FROM POWER • "WAR OF LAWS" & "MULTIPLE SOVEREIGNTIES" • ETHNIC TENSIONS (DOMESTIC & REGIONAL) COMPONENTS OF RUSSIAN CONSTITUTION PREAMBLE FOUNDATIONS OF THE CONSTITUTIONAL SYSTEM HUMAN AND CIVIL RIGHTS AND LIBERTIES FEDERAL STRUCTURE *PRESIDENT *FEDERAL ASSEMBLY *GOVERNMENT JUDICIARY LOCAL GOVERNMENT CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS NATIONAL STATE INSTITUTIONS OF RUSSIAN FEDERATION LEGISLATIVE POWER: FEDERAL ASSEMBLY Criteria for Democratization  Free and Fair Elections  Representation of population in a predetermined and fair manner  Parties forming Government and Opposition  Constitutionally defined, clear legislative powers  Responsibility for drafting, debating, approving laws  Two models: o Presidential: Division and balance of powers between executive and legislature; o Parliamentary: government sits in parliament and is held responsible by legislature. Soviet Heritage • Soviets (Councils) (no power, no elections, no representation, no legislative power); • Congress of Peoples’ Deputies (Gorbachev 1989); • President a figure-head (Chairman of Supreme Soviet). 1993 Eltsin Constitution Federal Assembly of two Houses: • Upper House: Federation Council (178 seats = 2 x 89 regions); • Lower House: State Duma (450 deputies = 225 single member constituencies / 225 party lists) (elected for 4-year term) (2007: all deputies elected by party lists / 7% threshold). • Federation Council Powers: (limited) o Confirm Presidential decrees, border changes, martial law, state of emergency; o Schedule presidential elections; o Appoint high court justices, procurator-general; o Adopt resolutions on matters under its jurisdiction; o Approve / veto State Duma legislation. • State Duma Powers: o Consent on presidential nominee for Chairman of Government; o Decide questions of confidence in Government; o Bring accusations against President to remove him from office (impeachment); o Adopt resolutions on matters under its jurisdiction. o Legislative Powers:  Draft laws and consider draft laws submitted by other state bodies and individual office holders;  Approve tax and expenditure bills from Government;  Pass laws (simple majority)  Override vetoes of laws by Federation Council & President o May be dissolved by President under certain conditions (e.g., 3x rejection of Presidential nominee for Chair of Government) Weaknesses of Federal Assembly: Structural Weaknesses: • Limited jurisdiction; • Strong presidency; • Lack of control over Government / President; • Complex procedures. Political Weaknesses: o Weak fragmented parties (Eltsin) / One-Party dominance (Putin); o Strongest parties anti-regime (LDPR, KPRF) (Eltsin) / liberal & centrist parties marginalized (Eltsin) and eliminated (Putin); o Roles: opposition (Eltsin) / puppet (Putin). • GOVERNMENT OF RUSSIAN FEDERATION Soviet Heritage  Council of Ministers (Supreme Soviet) (USSR Inc.): wide-ranging powers to plan, legislate, implement and monitor all public activities;  Consisted of Chair (Prime Minister), Deputy Chairs, Ministers, Chairs of State Committees;  Effectively subordinated to CPSU Politburo and Secretariat 1993 Constitution and the Russian “Government”  Exercises executive power. Chmn, Vice-Chmn, Ministers (110)  Chmn appointed by Pres w/ consent of Duma. If nomination rejected 3x by Duma, then Pres appoints Chmn, dissolves Duma & schedules new elections.(111-4)  Chmn presents proposals for structure of govt & nominates candidates for positions-- approved by Pres.  Responsibilities (114) include: o fed budget preparation (to Duma for approval) & implementation; o implementation of financial, credit & monetary policy & other domestic policies; implementation of foreign, security & defense policy; o issues resolutions & directives & ensures their implementation (may be annulled by Pres if unconstitutional or at variance with fed laws or Pres decrees).  Govt is disbanded if: o it resigns; o it is dismissed by Pres; o no confidence voted by Duma (majority). May be rejected by Pres. But, if Duma dismisses govt 2x w/i 3 months Pres must dismiss govt & Duma must be dissolve & election held. o Govt may put confidence vote before Duma. If Duma votes no confidence, Pres must decide: dismiss govt or dissolve Duma. FEATURES OF RUSSIAN "GOVERNMENT" Appointed Not Elected Subordinated To Two Elected, Competing Institutions Cabinet Does Not Consist of a "Team" or "Coalition" Loyal To PM or Accountable to Parliament Cabinet Headed by Appointed PM & Ministers Who Manage Independent Bureaucratic Fiefdoms (Ministries, Departments, Officials) Ministerial ‘Feudalism’ Explained By: • Absence Of "Legal" Culture / Rational – Legal N
More Less

Related notes for POL354Y5

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit