Class Notes (836,321)
Canada (509,732)
Geography (717)
GGRA03H3 (139)
Lecture 5

GGRA03H3 - Lecture 5.docx

7 Pages
96 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Geography
Course
GGRA03H3
Professor
Andre Sorensen
Semester
Spring

Description
GGRA03U3 – Week 5 What are Megacities? - Current UN Definition: o Population>10m (million) - In the past various definitions, including 4m (Dogan and Kasarda 1988), 8m (Richardson 1993, Gilbert 1996), 10m (Ward 1990, UNDESA 2008) - There is no reason to think that there is a qualitative difference between cities of 8 or 10m. - There clearly is a difference between cities of 1m and 8-10m. - What urban issues are likely to be impacted by very large size? o Congestion  As cities get larger, growth happens in the edges. o Travel issues o Pollution o Poverty and Social Inequalities  Exists in larger cities, or simply more? o Larger housing problems for the poor o Water Why are Megacities important? - Megacities now contain about 9% of world urban population - Rapid growth of number of megacities, 2 in 1950, by 1975 Mexico City was third, by 2007, there was 19 including 15 in developing countries - In 2025, it is projected that there will be 28, with 22 in developing countries - This is clearly an increasingly important share of total urban population - Understanding the problems and solutions characteristic of megacities is essential. Big Questions - In what ways are megacities a new form of urban development? - Is this a qualitative change, or merely a quantitative change? - What are the distinctive characteristics of megacity urbanization compared to smaller settlements? - What are the advantages and disadvantages of megacities? - What major policy challenges can be expected? - What responses are we already seeing? Key Concept 1 - Megacities represent a new urban scale. o Megacities are city-regions with more than 10m population o Most megacities are in developing countries o The number of megacities is growing rapidly o Population and urban projections for the next 40 years are known with relative certainty o Megacities are a qualitatively different urban form, not just bigger – for 5 main reasons:  Pollution  Congestion  Economy  Land values and housing  Governance Scale - Scale is a major geographical concept - A city of 100,000 will function utterly differently than a city of 5 million, even with similar GDP/capita, population density, housing types, and jobs - Methodological scale refers to the scale at which phenomena are studied (boundaries, political units) - Geographical scale refers to scales that may be inherent in the object of study – the body, neighbourhood, city, region, nation, globe – these produce relationships and power dynamics - Geographic scale differentiates between spatial phenomena, and spatial processes. Special Issues of Very Large-Scale Cities - There has been a very long history of thinking about city size - Plato and many others identified 50k as an ideal size - At that size, it is possible to know everyone, participatory democratic governance is possible - In 20 century many predicted that over a certain size a range of Diseconomies of Scale would become dominant, and would increase costs, and reduce efficiency, therefore leading to slower growth. - Economy of Scale: o The more products are made, the cheaper they are.  Hand-made vs. Factory made - Diseconomy of Scale: o The larger the product, the more costly  Large name brands - What is a diseconomy of scale, and what are some examples? o Housing o Travel o Pollution  Pollution increases as cities grow. Special Issues of Very Large Cities – 2 - Expected diseconomies of scale are congestion, pollution, long travel times, high land costs - All of these can be expected to continue to increase with population growth. - Such factors will increase the costs of business, and of living in large cities, but can be reduced by increased infrastructure investment, roads, subways, etc. - Counterbalancing these increased costs are economies of scale, where there are economic advantages to larger city size - Examples? Special Issues of Very Large Cities – 3 - Expected economies of scale: o Larger markets & larger labour pools - Higher land costs result in more efficient use of land, some goods are available that are not available in smaller cities - Subways, opera houses, specialist services, stock markets, etc. - If a large city continues to grow, we might conclude that economies of scale are larger than diseconomies of scale - BUT, it is important to realize that diseconomies of scale mostly cost individuals, while economies of scale mostly benefit firms. Costs to people Benefits to Firms - That sounds pretty unfair, why would that make sense? - Why would extra costs affect people more than firms? - They all affect livability – pollution, high housing costs, higher housing costs, long travel times all are major costs to individuals - For many firms, the benefits of large labour pools, larger nearby market, and access to specialist services and suppliers very often outweigh higher land and travel costs Key Concept 2 - Megacities demonstrate a number of special characteristics o There have been debates about ‘optimal city size’ for centuries. We cannot determine a ‘best size’ for cities. o Idea of diseconomies of scale is that for some issues very large size will mean higher costs: c
More Less

Related notes for GGRA03H3

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit