Class Notes (837,175)
Canada (510,151)
Philosophy (1,521)
PHL275H1 (146)
Tom Hurka (59)
Lecture

PHL275-sept16.doc

3 Pages
114 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Philosophy
Course
PHL275H1
Professor
Tom Hurka
Semester
Fall

Description
Wednesday September 16 Cultural Relativism Relativism is not just the claim that peoples beliefs about morality differ. Values that people accept or believe in are different. There are clear disagreements about what is right or wrong. Ex. Permitting/condemning abortion. -there are no universal moral principles, instead values or moral truths are all only “relative” to an individual or culture -claim is not that people disagree, morality itself differs as well, what is right or wrong can be different between cultures and people. Ex. What is right in Canada, is different from what is right in Afghanistan Rachel’s pages 18-19, Cultural Differences Argument 1.Different societies have different moral codes, fact of moral disagreement, observation that people disagree 2-5-goes beyond the mere claim that there are differences, right and wrong are relative to a culture 6-conclusion about what we ought to do, we ought to be tolerant 2 types of relativism: Cultural Relativism-what is right and wrong in a culture depends on what that culture thinks is right and wrong Personal Relativism-applies the same idea to individual people, often applied to beliefs about abortion, homosexuality etc. Ex. If you think gay sex is right, then its right for you, if you think it’s wrong, then it’s wrong for you. -both make right and wrong depending on what some person thinks Difference between the two: cultural relativism doesn’t give individuals the freedom to determine what is wrong and right in their lives, whereas personal relativism does. Relativism is a challenge to morality for two reasons: 1)we usually think we can judge other cultures morally We can say that they are doing something wrong even though they believe they are doing something right. With cultural relativism, if it’s true, it would never be possible for us to say truly that another culture acting by its own values was doing something wrong, but we often do think that. Ex. Nazi genocide 2)we usually believe it’s important to think about moral problems and possibly change our minds about them. Personal relativism says there is no point, whatever you think is right will be right for you if you do it. Cultural relativism thinks the same, can’t think that there has been progress ex. Treatment of women Personal Relativism says that there is no point in changing your moral beliefs. If at one time doing x is right, if 5 years later doing not x is right, then won’t do x. As long as moral beliefs that I have are acted on, I am not acting wrongly. Cultural Relativism-if our cultural belief 100 years ago, was that homosexuality was immoral, then at that time it is immoral. Now we don’t prohibit it, and in this time, it is moral as well. No progress has been made Rachels' page 22- point 3) women, if cultural relativism is correct, giving women more rights cannot be viewed as making progress from previous times. Can’t judge the morals of today within the framework of another time. Relativism-sometimes embraced on the political left Ex. Wouldn’t be able to say that the Nazi policy on concentration camps etc. was wrong The claim that because relativism is true we much be tolerant is contradictory. Tolerance of other cultures would be valid only within a culture that has this view ex. In Canada. In cultures where they believe that non-tolerance is what they should aim for, they would not be tolerant of others. Couldn’t say that there are no moral principles, other than the principle to be tolerant of others
More Less

Related notes for PHL275H1

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit