Class Notes (906,006)
CA (538,586)
UTSG (45,722)
PHL (1,576)
PHL100Y1 (466)
Peter King (114)
Lecture

PHL lecture, nov. 10.doc

5 Pages
83 Views

Department
Philosophy
Course Code
PHL100Y1
Professor
Peter King

This preview shows pages 1-2. Sign up to view the full 5 pages of the document.
Consolation of Philosophy 1-3
Greece taken over by Italians
Barbarian who set himself up of king was replaced by another
oPoisoned
oTheodoric came to power
Boethius was born into wealthy family
oParents died very young
oAdopted by even richer family
oOld line of nobility
oImportant figure in society
oCentral person in Rome
oPolitics
oUnder Theodoric: master of offices
oAll went to pieces
oSomeone in senate made comments that it was sad that the proper catholic
Italians were ruled by a Barbarian catholic
oSenator put in jail
oBoethius enraged and stood up for senator
o“No more treasonous than I say”
oSo he was thrown in prison for treason, plotting to overthrow the king and
sex with demons
oUnder house arrest for a time, then jail cell, within a year executed
oWrote Consolation of Philosophy while imprisoned waiting to be executed
oResponds to the Crito
Looking for some sort of consolation while imprisoned
oLooks to philosophy
oWhat’s the problem Boethius is facing
The Prisoner’s Lament
CP 1.4. Not the traditional ‘Problem of Evil,’ but the (related) Problem of Desert:
oWhy don’t people get what they deserve?
oThat is, why are goods and evils distributed in the world with apparently
no regard to individual desert?
oAnswering this question is the philosophical aim of the Consolation of
Philosophy
Lady Philosophy diagnoses the Prisoner’s problem as a (temporary) cognitive
failure: he ahs “forgotten himself for a while.”
oHence he must be cured, first with gentle with remedies (book 2) and then
with stronger medicines, i.e. fewer assumptions (book 3).
oThis explains the “double vision” effect
oWe will concentrate on the stronger medicines
Popular consolations
Lady Philosophy begins with the “sweet persuasiveness of rhetoric” which has to
be guided by philosophy to stay on the right road (2.18)
oBoethius should count his blessings (2.4.5-9)
oHe ought to recognize that good fortune only comes with (the possibility
of) adverse fortune (2.4.4)
Good fortune may pass, but by the same token so does adverse
fortune (2.4.11)
The Fleeting Goods of Fortune
(2.4.25-29).
The ‘second wave’ of therapy offers three arguments ephemeral goods cannot
provide happiness
oFirst argument
Happiness is the highest good
A good that cannot be taken away is better than one that can be
taken away
The goods of Fortune can all be taken away
Therefore: the goods of Fortune cannot provide happiness
An obvious objection might be that (2) is flawed, since there might not be any
good that cannot be taken away. But the point here is that transitory goods don’t
measure up to the conceptual requirements for the highest good
Second argument (2.4.26-27)
oJones either knows (1a) that fortune is fickle, or (1b) doesn’t know that
Fortune is fickle
oIf (1b), then Jones can’t actually be happy (though he may think he is
happy)
Deluded
oIf (1a), then Jones either (3a) cares about losing goods of Fortune or (3b)
doesn’t care about losing them
oIf (3b), then they must not be essential to Jone’s happiness, and hence not
make him happy
oIf (3a), then Jones will be anxious about losing them, and hence not be
happy
oTherefore: the goods of Fortune do not make Jones happy

Loved by over 2.2 million students

Over 90% improved by at least one letter grade.

Leah — University of Toronto

OneClass has been such a huge help in my studies at UofT especially since I am a transfer student. OneClass is the study buddy I never had before and definitely gives me the extra push to get from a B to an A!

Leah — University of Toronto
Saarim — University of Michigan

Balancing social life With academics can be difficult, that is why I'm so glad that OneClass is out there where I can find the top notes for all of my classes. Now I can be the all-star student I want to be.

Saarim — University of Michigan
Jenna — University of Wisconsin

As a college student living on a college budget, I love how easy it is to earn gift cards just by submitting my notes.

Jenna — University of Wisconsin
Anne — University of California

OneClass has allowed me to catch up with my most difficult course! #lifesaver

Anne — University of California
Description
Consolation of Philosophy 1-3 • Greece taken over by Italians • Barbarian who set himself up of king was replaced by another o Poisoned o Theodoric came to power • Boethius was born into wealthy family o Parents died very young o Adopted by even richer family o Old line of nobility o Important figure in society o Central person in Rome o Politics o Under Theodoric: master of offices o All went to pieces o Someone in senate made comments that it was sad that the proper catholic Italians were ruled by a Barbarian catholic o Senator put in jail o Boethius enraged and stood up for senator o “No more treasonous than I say” o So he was thrown in prison for treason, plotting to overthrow the king and sex with demons o Under house arrest for a time, then jail cell, within a year executed o Wrote Consolation of Philosophy while imprisoned waiting to be executed o Responds to the Crito • Looking for some sort of consolation while imprisoned o Looks to philosophy o What’s the problem Boethius is facing The Prisoner’s Lament • CP 1.4. Not the traditional ‘Problem of Evil,’ but the (related) Problem of Desert: o Why don’t people get what they deserve? o That is, why are goods and evils distributed in the world with apparently no regard to individual desert? o Answering this question is the philosophical aim of the Consolation of Philosophy • Lady Philosophy diagnoses the Prisoner’s problem as a (temporary) cognitive failure: he ahs “forgotten himself for a while.” o Hence he must be cured, first with gentle with remedies (book 2) and then with stronger medicines, i.e. fewer assumptions (book 3). o This explains the “double vision” effect o We will concentrate on the stronger medicines Popular consolations • Lady Philosophy begins with the “sweet persuasiveness of rhetoric” which has to be guided by philosophy to stay on the right road (2.18) o Boethius should count his blessings (2.4.5-9) o He ought to recognize that good fortune only comes with (the possibility of) adverse fortune (2.4.4)  Good fortune may pass, but by the same token so does adverse fortune (2.4.11) The Fleeting Goods of Fortune • (2.4.25-29). • The ‘second wave’ of therapy offers three arguments ephemeral goods cannot provide happiness o First argument  Happiness is the highest good  A good that cannot be taken away is better than one that can be taken away  The goods of Fortune can all be taken away  Therefore: the goods of Fortune cannot provide happiness • An obvious objection might be that (2) is flawed, since there might not be any good that cannot be taken away. But the point here is that transitory goods don’t measure up to the conceptual requirements for the highest good • Second argument (2.4.26-27) o Jones either knows (1a) that fortune is fickle, or (1b) doesn’t know that Fortune is fickle o If (1b), then Jones can’t actually be happy (though he may think he is happy)  Deluded o If (1a), then Jones either (3a) cares about losing goods of Fortune or (3b) doesn’t care about losing them o If (3b), then they must not be essential to Jone’s happiness, and hence not make him happy o If (3a), then Jones will be anxious about losing them, and hence not be happy o Therefore: the goods of Fortune do not make Jones happy • The central claim here is that you can’t be happy unless you know that Fortune is fickle, in which case you should not care about transitory goods • The third argument is as follows o 2.4.28-29 o Since the goods of Fortune are all external, they are lo
More Less
Unlock Document


Only pages 1-2 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

Unlock Document
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version

Unlock Document

Log In


OR

Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit