Class Notes (923,486)
CA (543,255)
UTSG (45,890)
PHL (1,579)
PHL378H1 (23)
Tom Hurka (23)
Lecture 13

LEC13 – Proportionality and Necessity Oct 22 2009

2 Pages
75 Views

Department
Philosophy
Course Code
PHL378H1
Professor
Tom Hurka

This preview shows half of the first page. Sign up to view the full 2 pages of the document.
PHL378: War and Morality
LEC13 Proportionality & Necessity
Oct, 22nd, 2009
Economic Benefits of War
! in order to end depression, it is the the process of trying to get the JC that ends the depression,
and not the JC itself
! Suppose Iraq had invaded several oil producing countries for no apparent reason, and after this
it puts a monopoly on oil and increase the world oil price, should we go to war with Iraq, and
what are the relevant benefits, does economic benefit count as a relevant benefit?
! in the Iraq hypothetical case, it is the JC that achieves the economic benefits, hence this should
be counted in favour of the war
! in proportionality weighting, only the benefits which are causally downstream from the JC are
counted and not benefits derived from the process of achieving the JC
! in the Oslo peace agreement case, we also should not use that in proportionality b/c the
agreement came about through the process of achieving the JC and not expelling Sadam himself
! if by outsting Sadam, we have less suicide bombers b/c the government is no longer paying for
bomber's families. This should count as a relevant good, b/c the goods are causally downstream
from the achieving the JC
Proportionality
! Hurka: the in bello proportionality condition is weighted based on how important the ad bellum
condition of JC is
! this is direct contrast to Waltzer's view, and says that jus ad bellum and jus in bello are not
distinct entities, in bello depends on ad bellum
! thus a war can only be fought just if it had a just cause to begin with
! additional protocol #1: attacks are forbidden, if they harm civilians collaterally which are
excessive in proportion to the direct military advantage anticipated
this supports the Waltzer view, applies equally to both sides
Relevant Evils
! few restrictions on the relevant evils
! thumb pressed down on the scale, there is a restricted set of goods that count, but most evils
count
! the feelings of citizens on the side of the losing does not count as a relevant evil
! there may be restriction on how it comes about, how much evil our act will cause depends on
the wrongful choices of the other side
! this does not apply to the goods of war
! take the case of deterrence, if we fight a war now, it has the good effect of deterring future
aggressors, but that is dependent on whether the would be aggressors will initiate war in the
future; the fact the good depends on the other party's actions does not make us count the
good any less in proportionality measurement
! if b/w my choice and a bad outcome, there intervenes a third party and agent, then my
responsibility for the bad outcome will decrease
! there is an enemy military installation, and civilians voluntarily place them self infront of the
installation prior to our attack to impede us from attacking due to proportionality assessment
we are still permitted to attack it b..c they were voluntary
! pg. 47-48: same scenario as above but with involuntary civilians who were placed due to
government
www.notesolution.com

Loved by over 2.2 million students

Over 90% improved by at least one letter grade.

Leah — University of Toronto

OneClass has been such a huge help in my studies at UofT especially since I am a transfer student. OneClass is the study buddy I never had before and definitely gives me the extra push to get from a B to an A!

Leah — University of Toronto
Saarim — University of Michigan

Balancing social life With academics can be difficult, that is why I'm so glad that OneClass is out there where I can find the top notes for all of my classes. Now I can be the all-star student I want to be.

Saarim — University of Michigan
Jenna — University of Wisconsin

As a college student living on a college budget, I love how easy it is to earn gift cards just by submitting my notes.

Jenna — University of Wisconsin
Anne — University of California

OneClass has allowed me to catch up with my most difficult course! #lifesaver

Anne — University of California
Description
PHL378: War and Morality LEC13 Proportionality & Necessity Oct, 22nd, 2009 Economic Benefits of War in order to end depression, it is the the process of trying to get the JC that ends the depression, and not the JC itself Suppose Iraq had invaded several oil producing countries for no apparent reason, and after this it puts a monopoly on oil and increase the world oil price, should we go to war with Iraq, and what are the relevant benefits, does economic benefit count as a relevant benefit? in the Iraq hypothetical case, it is the JC that achieves the economic benefits, hence this should be counted in favour of the war in proportionality weighting, only the benefits which are causally downstream from the JC are counted and not benefits derived from the process of achieving the JC in the Oslo peace agreement case, we also should not use that in proportionality bc the agreement came about through the process of achieving the JC and not expelling Sadam himself if by outsting Sadam, we have less suicide bombers bc the government is no longer paying for bombers families. This should count as a relevant good, bc the goods are causally downstream from the achieving the JC Proportionality Hurka: the in bello proportionality condition is weighted based on how important the ad bellum condition of JC is this is direct contrast to Waltzers view, and says that jus ad bellum and jus in bello are not distinct entities, in bello depends on ad bellum thus a war can only be fought just if it had a just cause to begin with
More Less
Unlock Document


Only half of the first page are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

Unlock Document
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version

Unlock Document

Log In


OR

Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit