Civil and military relations

24 views1 pages
user avatar
Published on 7 Dec 2010
School
UTSG
Department
Political Science
Course
POL101Y1
December 6th 2010
Civil Military Relations and Democracy
x Civil military relations are at the core of political problems
x Conflicts between the military and the government make up the prime division of societies
institutional problems
x dZu]o]Ç[compliance with civil demands factor into the power equation of a state
x Violence is a necessary tool in statecraft
x ^]uÁZ}ZZ]PP]lUµ]uu}ÁZ}]Á]vP]vP]X_
x oo(]ovuÇUZ}ÁZ}}v[Àµovo}he armies of others (vulnerable to
other states interests)
x Modern states are the result of the transition from feudal to mass armies
x Feudal army: an army made up of the nobility and their supporters
x Mass Army: citizen army; fuelled by patriotism and popular support
x Professional army: volunteer army of trained professional soldiers.
x Draft army: force composed of individuals who under a state obligation to serve for a given
period.
x Armies are necessary for the preservation of state interests
x Problem: Guarding the guards?
x To properly control the military, you have to properly define the soldiers commitment;
governance of a soldiers thought
x The latter model implies a close relationship between soldier and civilian life
x The second (objective) model consists of a separation of soldiers and civilians; this army obeys
the will of the citizenry
x Professional model knows its problems when you try to get the army to perform civilian tasks
x Other problems occur when you get the military to formulate and execute policies
x Dov[lU}v[oo}o]Ç]]u}v(}ZÀ]}v}(u]o]Ç}]}vvµ]vP
their secrecy
x In poor states the military is subject to state corruption, overbearing demands, and social
confrontation
x On the whole it is necessary for the military to be separate from the citizenry to assure effective
proceeding in state policy
x The various levels of political and military hierarchy assure that there is no coup d[état
x A problem with poor countries is that they are stuck in a ^rebellion cycle_ (democracy, chaos,
military action)
x Armies have no interest in state control, they have interest based on their respective states
www.notesolution.com
Unlock document

This preview shows half of the first page of the document.
Unlock all 1 pages and 3 million more documents.

Already have an account? Log in