Class Notes (905,176)
CA (538,373)
UTSG (45,721)
POL101Y1 (1,189)
Lecture

Problems of Democracy.pdf

3 Pages
48 Views

Department
Political Science
Course Code
POL101Y1
Professor
Jeffrey Kopstein

This preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full 3 pages of the document.
Arab Spring, Occupy Wall Street - people uprising to the problems of Democracy - it is democracy in
Action
1975 -2010 -46 -114 democracies arouse
However, during that time, there were 53 democratic breakdowns
Around 1/2 of the 53 did not return
Democracy = fragile
Democracy and Equality
Key virtue = rule of law over the rule of man
Rules of the game - political institutions are political rules that govern the game
Democracies are a lot more predictable than an autocratic regime
We live in colonies / areas where people have similar interests
Democracy helps make compromise and mediates voters
Democracy implicates the norms of inclusion
Democracies - recognize that societies are diverse, therefore they are able to facilitate for these
difference better
Democracy - helps manage diverse societies
Core principle of democracy is realizing that you can lose
There is always new alternatives - you can vote the government out
It creates accountability & responsiveness to the people
Uncertainty is a good thing
Institutional uncertainty
They all adhere to the virtues of democracy, but they are flexible
They differ due to history of societies and social economic status
There is not one fixed model - not 2 models are alike
Democracy is an adaptable to many different circumstances
Variations in Democracy
It is absolutely fundamental to democracy
Equality of opportunity - thinking about the democratic process
1)
As individuals, we are all politically equal - we all have one vote
Political equality - everyone is equal under the rule of law
Equality of opportunity = procedural democracy
Public contestation - people can compete in public - the provision of pluralism
Inclusive participation - democracy includes everyone - you need universal suffrage
Polyarchy (Robert Dahl ) - 2 concepts of polyarchy
Equality of Outcome
2)
Does the democracy have substance to it
Will democracy create better economic outcomes ?
Procedural vs substantive democracy
Ex: Democratic Welfare State - what is considered fair for taxation
Unions were able to be created due to the ability to vote
Began in Europe with the rise of Capitalism and the Rise of the working class
Political - economic equity
2 ways to think about equality in democracy
Equality is core to democracy
Toronto 2012 - 50. 6 % of voters voted for the mayor
Canada's voter turnout rate is declining
Voter turn out rates for the united states hovers at around 50%
Challanges of Democracy
We all believe in the collective good, but don't believe on things at the individual level
Costs
1)
There is an enormous cost that is associated with voting
Demonstrates the Collective Action Problem
Problems of Democracy
October-22-12
12:10 PM
Sept Lectures Page 1

Loved by over 2.2 million students

Over 90% improved by at least one letter grade.

Leah — University of Toronto

OneClass has been such a huge help in my studies at UofT especially since I am a transfer student. OneClass is the study buddy I never had before and definitely gives me the extra push to get from a B to an A!

Leah — University of Toronto
Saarim — University of Michigan

Balancing social life With academics can be difficult, that is why I'm so glad that OneClass is out there where I can find the top notes for all of my classes. Now I can be the all-star student I want to be.

Saarim — University of Michigan
Jenna — University of Wisconsin

As a college student living on a college budget, I love how easy it is to earn gift cards just by submitting my notes.

Jenna — University of Wisconsin
Anne — University of California

OneClass has allowed me to catch up with my most difficult course! #lifesaver

Anne — University of California
Description
Problemsof Democracy October-22-12 12:10PM • ArabSpring,OccupyWall Street-peopleuprisingtotheproblemsofDemocracy-itisdemocracyin Action • 1975 - 2010 - 46 -114 democraciesarouse • However,duringthattime,therewere53democraticbreakdowns • Around1/2ofthe53 did notreturn • Democracy=fragile DemocracyandEquality • Rulesofthegame-politicalinstitutionsarepoliticalrulesthatgovernthegame ○ Keyvirtue=ruleoflawoverthe ruleofman • Democraciesarealotmorepredictablethananautocraticregime • Democracy-helpsmanagediversesocieties ○ Weliveincolonies/areaswherepeoplehavesimilarinterests ○ Democracyhelpsmakecompromiseandmediatesvoters ○ Democracyimplicatesthenormsofinclusion ○ Democracies-recognizethatsocietiesarediverse,thereforetheyareabletofacilitateforthese differencebetter • Institutionaluncertainty ○ Thereisalwaysnewalternatives-youcanvotethegovernmentout  Coreprincipleofdemocracyisrealizingthatyoucanlose ○ Uncertaintyisagood thing  Itcreatesaccountability&responsivenesstothepeople • VariationsinDemocracy ○ Thereisnotonefixedmodel-not2modelsarealike  Theyalladheretothevirtuesofdemocracy,buttheyareflexible  Theydifferduetohistoryofsocietiesandsocialeconomicstatus ○ Democracyisan adaptabletomanydifferentcircumstances • Equalityiscoretodemocracy ○ Itisabsolutelyfundamentaltodemocracy ○ 2waysto thinkaboutequalityindemocracy 1) Equalityofopportunity-thinkingaboutthedemocraticprocess  Politicalequality-everyoneisequalundertheruleoflaw □ Asindividuals,weareallpoliticallyequal -weallhaveonevote  Equalityofopportunity=proceduraldemocracy  Polyarchy(RobertDahl)-2conceptsof polyarchy □ Publiccontestation -peoplecancompete inpublic-theprovisionofpluralism □ Inclusiveparticipation -democracyincludeseveryone-youneeduniversalsuffrage 2) EqualityofOutcome  Political-economicequity □ Proceduralvssubstantivedemocracy  Doesthedemocracyhavesubstancetoit  Willdemocracycreatebettereconomicoutcomes? □ Ex:DemocraticWelfareState-whatisconsideredfairfortaxation □ BeganinEuropewiththeriseofCapitalismandtheRiseoftheworkingclass  Unionswereabletobecreatedduetothe abilitytovote • Toronto2012 - 50. 6 % ofvotersvotedforthemayor • Canada'svoterturnoutrateis declining • Voterturnoutratesfortheunitedstateshoversataround50% ChallangesofDemocracy • DemonstratestheCollectiveActionProblem ○ Weallbelieveinthecollectivegood,butdon'tbelieveonthingsattheindividuallevel 1) Costs Thereisanenormouscostthat isassociatedwithvoting 1) Costs ○ Thereisanenormouscostthat isassociatedwithvoting  Timecost 2) Benefits  Thebenefitstotheindividualaresominisculethattheactionofvotingbecomesirrational  Thebenefitisnotworththecost 3) Free-riding  Somebodyelsewillvote  othersirrationaleffortswillhelpyourindividualneeds ○ Itisnot rationaltovote ○ Youare abletofreerideoverthevote ○ Evenifwehavetheequalityofopportunity,,wedon'texerciseit • TheFallacy ofDemocratic Pluralism ○ Aslongas wecan expressouropinion,itisgood ○ Ex:usHealthCare - AmericansbelievethattheyshouldhaveNationalHealthinsurance,butall effortstomakehealthcarepublichasfailed  Iftherulesofthegamewerefair,theUS wouldalreadyhaveNationalhealthcare  Peopleblametheinstitutionalfragmentationtogetthingsdoneinaprocedurallyfairway □ Theinstitutionalfragmentationprivilegesminorityacts  Richareableto overrulethepoor-a tyrannybytherich minority  55peopleaccountfor75% offundsforCampaigns □ Therefore,pluralismfails  Proceduralfairnessisrunbytheeliteinsocietyforpowerfulinterests • EliteDemocra
More Less
Unlock Document


Only page 1 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

Unlock Document
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version

Unlock Document

Log In


OR

Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit