Class Notes (921,234)
CA (542,480)
UTSG (45,900)
POL208Y1 (509)
La Haine (38)
Lecture

lec note

12 Pages
44 Views

Department
Political Science
Course Code
POL208Y1
Professor
La Haine

This preview shows pages 1-3. Sign up to view the full 12 pages of the document.
POL208Y1 Sept 29th 2010
Ism Paradigm
Zombie-land : Through Experiment
The different isms
What actors want? How do we deal
with treat?
What kind of data do we need to
gather?
Is cooperation possible? Is there
possibility for change?
Realism : The Realist A Team’
Theoretical foundation of the paradigm
Bismarck-Real Politick; German
19thcentury
Politics onpractical base > moral &
ideological
What should be < what is avoided
thinking about moral questions…
what should be
Conservative & Minimalists/
expansionist / militaristic
Minimalist? Goals are achievable, risks are
counted on
It doesnt matter if a cat is black of
white so long as it catches mice-
unethical or ethical doesnt matter
Deng Xiaopeng unholy alliances ex)
we dont care about conditions of other
conditions
Power politics; actors following their
self-interest
20th century E.H. Carr
Twenty Yearscrisis- 1919-1939 WW1
WW2
Coined the term realism
Realism: places its emphasis on the
acceptance of facts and on the analysis
of their (causes and consequences)”
Carr 1939
Many rulers of that era were
idealists…
Idealism vs Realism
See what they want / see what they see
Thomas Hobbes 1588-1679
First translation of Thusydides from
Peloponesian to English
Teach new scientific ideas
Geologybuilds rules and laws ;
teaches in Italy (formulate laws and
show how politics work)
Goes back to England civil war
People, Politics
Leviathan (Hobbes) 1651
The State of Nature
Society with complete anarchy; Nature
The state of nature before society
was formed ( no institution )
How are peoples behaviours in the
absence of institution?
www.notesolution.com
Awar of every man against every
man Everythings all about
surviving (nature)
Life issolitary/ poor/ nasty/ brutish
and short
The solution is the creation of “The
Sate
The Logic of Hobbes argument :
1.Human Nature: Man is a selfish
hedonistof the voluntary acts of
every man, the object is some good to
himself
Hedonist? Pursuit of or devotion to pleasure,
especially to the pleasures of the senses.
All people are equal, rational and
possessing a passionate love of
survival ( Right of Nature )
Love for survival is the only right of
human being in the state of nature;
The only right that really exists
A persons right of nature justifies
violence against everyone else
In the interests of personal survival,
people will come around to
agreeing that they should renounce
their right to use violence
Is his a good solution? No
UNSTABLE equilibrium, the moment
one party deviates from their
promise, all will deviate and war
restarts
The Logic of Hobbes argument
2. The creation of Leviathan
enforces stability
Citizens give up their
independence to buy stability
The Leviathan (The State) gets
ultimate authority and a monopoly
over the use of violence
Morality, Justice, Property are
social constructs imposed by the
state and exists only so long as the
state is strong enough to impose
them- they are tools for
maintaining stability rather than
inherent rights
Law is dependent on power.
Legal Positivism
-Formal criteria of laws origin, law
enforcement and legal effectiveness are all
sufficient for social norms to be considered
law. Legal positivism does not base law on
divine commandments, reason, or human
rights. As an historical matter, positivism
arose in opposition to classical natural law
theory, according to which there are
necessary moral constraints on the content
of law.
Justice is whatever the law says it is
Anunjust law is an oxymoron
Bull: the Domestic Analogy- the state
exists in the state ofnature
** Anarchy doesnt mean chaos !!
Anarchy refers to the absence of
government.
If one says international system is there
is anarchy, there is no legitimate use of
power no superpower exists in
international context
www.notesolution.com
The natural right of the state
(anarchy) = right to survive
Hobbes and International
Relations
The international system is in a
Hobbesian state of nature:
individual = state / unitary actor
Anarchy without a leader;
doesnt mean chaos or lack of
order
Survival: self-help, self-interest,
constant potential for violence
Therefore, very limited potential for
cooperation (only temporary) unstable
equilibrium, fear of defection
No Leviathan = No room for moral
considerations
Survival and self-interest are moral
under anarchy since those are the
only right in the state of nature
- power and interest are the moral
considerations
- moral obligation to ones people
- different type of morality for IR
The Security Dilemma
T1: constant fear and insecurity;
because any state may at any time use
force, all states must constantly be ready
either to counter force with force or to pay the
cost of weakness Waltz
T2: A seeks to increase her security by buying
weapons / building a defensive wall/ gaining
allies rational reaction in insecurity…
Ones security increase the insecurity of
ones neighbors (others) New balance of
security and insecurity
Actor B: fears As improved position
enhance sense of insecurity
T3: Actor B: forced to invest in weapons /
defensive mean/ allies
Even with such improvements, they are just as
insecure as they used to be in T1
Outcome- A and B are as insecure in T3
as they were in T1 only POORER;
ARMS RACE
The Dilemma: how can we raise our
security?
Thucydides (5th century B.C.)
Classic writer of International
Relations
All the writers here have experienced
war in their life time
Sparta-Athens . At the end of the
war, he writes books
Peace Treatise- he thought there
are certain rules and laws to
prevent wars
Human nature- innate nature of
International Relations
Peloponnesian war (431-405 B.C.)
Athens-Sparta Bi-polar system
Was popular during the Cold War
US-Russia - Melos
Athens-Melos (Melian Dialogue)
Athens vs the people of Melos
The standard of justice depends
on the equality of power to compel
and what in fact the strong do what
they have the power to do and the
www.notesolution.com

Loved by over 2.2 million students

Over 90% improved by at least one letter grade.

Leah — University of Toronto

OneClass has been such a huge help in my studies at UofT especially since I am a transfer student. OneClass is the study buddy I never had before and definitely gives me the extra push to get from a B to an A!

Leah — University of Toronto
Saarim — University of Michigan

Balancing social life With academics can be difficult, that is why I'm so glad that OneClass is out there where I can find the top notes for all of my classes. Now I can be the all-star student I want to be.

Saarim — University of Michigan
Jenna — University of Wisconsin

As a college student living on a college budget, I love how easy it is to earn gift cards just by submitting my notes.

Jenna — University of Wisconsin
Anne — University of California

OneClass has allowed me to catch up with my most difficult course! #lifesaver

Anne — University of California
Description
POL208Y1 Sept 29 2010 20 century E.H. Carr Ism Paradigm Twenty Years crisis- 1919-1939 WW1 Zombie-land : Through Experiment WW2 The different isms Coined the term realism What actors want? How do we deal Realism: places its emphasis on the with treat? acceptance of facts and on the analysis of their (causes and consequences) What kind of data do we need to Carr 1939 gather? Many rulers of that era were Is cooperation possible? Is there idealists possibility for change? Idealism vs Realism Realism : The Realist A Team See what they want see what they see Theoretical foundation of the paradigm Thomas Hobbes 1588-1679 Bismarck-Real Politick; German 19 century First translation of Thusydides from Peloponesian to English Politics on practical base > moral & ideological Teach new scientific ideas What should be < what is avoided Geology builds rules and laws ; thinking about moral questions teaches in Italy (formulate laws and what should be show how politics work) Conservative & Minimalists Goes back to England civil war expansionist militaristic People, Politics Minimalist? Goals are achievable, risks are counted on Leviathan (Hobbes) 1651 It doesnt matter if a cat is black of The State of Nature white so long as it catches mice- unethical or ethical doesnt matter Society with complete anarchy; Nature Deng Xiaopeng unholy alliances ex) The state of nature before society was formed ( no institution ) we dont care about conditions of other conditions How are peoples behaviours in the absence of institution? Power politics; actors following their self-interest www.notesolution.com A war of every man against every Citizens give up their man Everythings all about independence to buy stability surviving (nature) The Leviathan (The State) gets Life is solitary poor nasty brutish ultimate authority and a monopoly over the use of violence and short The solution is the creation of The Morality, Justice, Property are social constructs imposed by the Sate state and exists only so long as the The Logic of Hobbes argument : state is strong enough to impose them- they are tools for 1. Human Nature: Man is a selfish maintaining stability rather than hedonist of the voluntary acts of inherent rights every man, the object is some good to Law is dependent on power. himself Legal Positivism Hedonist? Pursuit of or devotion to pleasure, -Formal criteria of laws origin, law especially to the pleasures of the senses. enforcement and legal effectiveness are all All people are equal, rational and sufficient for social norms to be considered possessing a passionate love of law. Legal positivism does not base law on survival ( Right of Nature ) divine commandments, reason, or human rights. As an historical matter, positivism Love for survival is the only right of arose in opposition to classicalnatural law human being in the state of nature; The only right that really exists theor, according to which there are necessary moral constraints on the content A persons right of nature justifies of law. violence against everyone else Justice is whatever the law says it is In the interests of personal survival, people will come around to An unjust law is an oxymoron agreeing that they should renounce their right to use violence Bull: the Domestic Analogy- the state exists in the state ofnature Is his a good solution? No ** Anarchy doesnt mean chaos !! UNSTABLE equilibrium, the moment one party deviates from their Anarchy refers to the absence of promise, all will deviate and war government. restarts The Logic of Hobbes argument If one says international system is there is anarchy, there is no legitimate use of 2. The creation of Leviathan power no superpower exists in enforces stability international context www.notesolution.com
More Less
Unlock Document


Only pages 1-3 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

Unlock Document
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version

Unlock Document

Log In


OR

Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit