Class Notes (835,107)
Canada (508,933)
POL316Y1 (31)

Section 5.docx

3 Pages
Unlock Document

Political Science
Michael Stein

incomplete 3. Later historical trends and issues in the judicial review of federalism: the Supreme Court of Canada (JCC) as the final court of appeal in distribution of power cases, 1949 to the present - The “balancing” role of the Supreme Court in quantitative terms: percentage of federal and provincial “victory ratios” o Prior to 1949, Supreme Court was under the shadow of JCPC and never defined a distinct position for itself o In contrast to JCPC after 1882, JCPC wanted to help rebalance o Supreme Court was bypassed on appeals by JCPC, with respect to POGG clause and trade and commerce clause o Supreme Courts role was to interpret what the JCPC said (stare decisis) not what the constitution said, it was therefore perceived during those years, late 1870’s to 1949, a captive court (Russell, 1989) o When it became a court if final appeal, at first for the first 20 years it interpreted both POGG clause and trade and commerce in a centralist manner o The federal government victory ratio for the first 20 years from 1949-1969 was 54.7%, it was slightly better – halted pro- provincialist judgments o Supreme Court broadened federal government provisions in the POGG clause o 1970 – uncanny balance (Russell, 1985)  Sometimes the Supreme Court favored the federal government and sometimes it favored the provinces  Patrick Monahan argued that in all but two federal statutes were upheld during this period  1970-1983: victory ration went down to 53.9% o unconscious desire to even things up, and one can detect this in the most important cases involving the POGG clause and the trade and commerce clause - The “balancing role of the Supreme Court qualitatively: o The Anti-Inflation Case, 1975  Trudeau government…  Challenged by provinces for acting beyond its controls  Objectives for wage and price control was to curb inflation  Supreme Court ruled that the federal government had the right to impose controls under the POGG clause but not on the grounds it could generally…, but rather to be a perceived action to combat a national economic emergency  o The Senate Reference Case, 1978
More Less

Related notes for POL316Y1

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.