PSY100H1 Lecture Notes - Lecture 15: Judith Rich Harris, Gender Dysphoria, Almost Surely

6 views14 pages
Published on 20 Nov 2012
School
Department
Course
Page:
of 14
Lecture 15 (November 1st, 2012)
!"#$%&%'()*('(+",-($&.)
!
"#$!%#!$&!'(#$!$)*+!,(-*(+.!*(%!+#%%/&0.!'(#$!*1#2+!+)&!$#0/%3!
!
4&.&*05)!+&5)(,62&.!-#0!/&*0(,(7!$)*+!,(-*(+.!'(#$8!
/0(1(0($&%2+)+""3%$#)&(45$%67(.),-!-#0!$)*+&9&0!0&*.#(!*(!,(-*(+!:0&-&0.!#(&!
.+,;2/2.!+#!*(#+)&0<!+)&(!,+!:0&-&0.!,+=!
80%($&%$#)0(1+(9.)&5(!,%&*!,.!+)*+!,(-*(+.!$*(+!+)&,0!*++&(+,#(!%0*$(!+#!#1>&5+.!+)*+!
*0&!(&$!*(%!(#9&/!+#!+)&;=!?)&@!+&(%!+#!7&+!1#0&%!*+!+)&!.*;&!#1>&5+<!12+!+)&@!
#0,&(+!+#$*0%.!#1>&5+.!+)*+!*0&!(&$!+#!+)&;=!
o A*1,&.!*0&!1#0(!$,+)!*//!+)&.&!.@(*:+,5!5#((&5+,#(.!+)*+!+)&@!%#(B+!/#.&!#0!
+)&@!%#(B+!(&&%!*(%!+)&!10*,(!7#&.!+)0#27)!+),.!;#9&!,+!#0!/#.&!,+!:#/,5@!$,+)!
+)#.&!.@(*:.&.<!12+!$&!+&(%!+#!.:&5,*/,C&!,(!+),(7.!/,'&!)2;*(!-*5&.=!
:(-"0;)0(&($&%"$)&(<&8!D&;#0@!0&+&(+,#(!+&.+!,.!+)&!,%&*!+)*+!EF)*+!%#!1*1,&.!
0&;&;1&03!G#!1*1,&.!0&;&;1&0!-0#;!%*@!+#!%*@3H!?)&!;&;#0@!0&+&(+,#(!+&.+!,.!
/*@,(7!*!1*1@!,(!*!50,1!*(%!@#2!*++*5)!*!.+0,(7!+#!,+!*(%!+#!*!;#1,/&!*(%!.#!$)&(!+)&!
1*1@!',5'.<!+)&!;#1,/&!;#9&.!+##<!12+!%#!+)&@!0&;&;1&0!+)*+!+)&!(&I+!%*@!,-!@#2!
*++*5)!*!.+0,(7!+#!+)&;!*7*,(3!?)&!#/%&0!+)&!1*1@!,.<!+)&!1&++&0!)&!,.!*+!+)*+<!+)&!
/#(7&0!),.!;&;#0@!5*(!/*.+=!
!
?)&0&!,.!%$12$&%+()2-$(<%2=!J#(&!#-!2.!5*(!0&;&;1&0!+)&!&*0/@!@&*0.!#-!#20!/,9&.=!K20!&*0/,&.+!
;&;#0,&.!*0&!L!#0!M!@&*0.!#/%=!
!
N#2(7!5),/%0&(!*/.#!+&(%!+#!%#!*!/#+!#-!5#(-*12/*+,#(=!?)&@!;*'&!2:!;&;#0,&.=!
!
O(%&0.+*(%,(7!+)&!/*$.!#-!(*+20&8!
P)@.,5.<!
D*+)&;*+,5.!
!
Q(-*(+.!*0&!:0&++@!.;*0+=!?)&@!)*9&!.#;&!,(+2,+,9&!(*+20&!0&7*0%,(7!+)&!/*$.!#-!(*+20&!*(%!
70*9,+@=!
!
R(!,(-*(+!Q.!.)#$(!*!:#..,1/&!&9&(+8!R!1#I!,.!0&/&*.&%!#(!+#:!#-!*(#+)&0!1#I=!R(!,(-*(+!,.!.)#$(!
*(!,;:#..,1/&!&9&(+8!R!1#I!,.!0&/&*.&%!,(!;,%S*,0!12+!%#&.!(#+!-*//=!Q(-*(+!.:&(%.!;25)!;#0&!
+,;&!/##',(7!*+!+)&!,;:#..,1/&!&9&(+=!
!
P,*7&+!%,%!.#;&+),(7!$,+)!;*01/&.=!"&!:/*@&%!+)&;!#2+!*(%!)*%!+)&;!5/2.+&0&%!*(%!.:0&*%!
#2+<!*(%!+)&!',%.!/##'&%!*+!+)&!/&(7+)8!,-!.:0&*%!#2+!-20+)&0<!+)&@!.*,%!+)*+!+)&!/#(7&0!#(&!$*.!
;#0&!+)*(!+)&!#+)&0!#(&=!4&.&*05)&0.!+)&(!0&:/*5&%!+)&!;*01/&.!$,+)!DTD.<!;#+,9*+,(7!+)&!
1*1,&.!+#!+*'&!+)&!#(&.!$,+)!;#.+!DTD.!,(!,+<!*(%!+)&@!.&&!+)*+!+)&!',%.!%#!,+!.255&..-2//@=!
!
>"4%2+)?)@A($&%&;)*('(+",-($&.)
!
/20($&<)'<=)/((0<.)
!
F)#!,.!0&*//@!,;:#0+*(+!,(!+&0;.!#-!.#5,*/,C*+,#(!*(%!,(!+&0;.!#-!',%.!&.+*1/,.),(7!+)&,0!
,%&(+,+,&.3!Q.!,+!:*0&(+.!#0!,.!,+!:&&0.3!
!
U#!V2%,+)!4,5)!"*00,.!1*.,5*//@!.*,%!+)*+!:*0&(+.!*0&!(#+),(7=!Q+B.!*//!*1#2+!+)&!:&&0.=!U)&!)*.!+),.!
70#2:!.#5,*/,C*+,#(!+)&#0@!+)*+!.*,%!$&!/&*0(!#(&!.&+!#-!1&)*9,#0.!,(.,%&!+)&!)#;&<!+)&(!$&!
/&*0(!#+)&0!.&+.!#-!1&)*9,#0.!1@!/,9,(7!#2+.,%&!#-!+)&!)#;&=!A&)*9,#0.!,(.,%&!+)&!)#;&!*0&!#(/@!
0&/&9*(+!,(.,%&!+)&!)#;&<!*(%!,+B.!#2+.,%&!+)&!)#;&!+)*+!$&!/&*0(!)#$!+#!1&)*9&!#2+.,%&!#-!,+=!
!
"&0!+)&#0@!$*.!;&+!$,+)!*!/#+!#-!50,+,5,.;<!*(%!,+!.&&;.!5/&*0!+)*+!1#+)!:*0&(+.!*(%!:&&0.!:/*@!
*(!,;:#0+*(+!0#/&!,(!.#5,*/!%&9&/#:;&(+=!
!
N#20!:*0&(+.!5*(!)&/:!.+&&0!@#2!+#$*0%.!*!.&+!#-!-0,&(%.<!#0!1*(!@#2!-0#;!1*%!,(-/2&(5&.<!.#!
1#+)!:*0&(+.!*(%!:&&0.!*0&!,(-/2&(+,*/!,(!%&9&/#:,(7!#20!,%&(+,+@=!
!
@-,24&)"1)*%'"04(.)
!
Q+!,.!*..#5,*+&%!$,+)!/#+.!#-!(&7*+,9&!#2+5#;&.!W!*5*%&;,5!:0#1/&;.<!.#5,*/!:0#1/&;.=!J#+!*//!
5),/%0&(!5#:&!:##0/@8!#/%&0!5),/%0&(!)*(%/&!,+!1&++&0<!.#5,*//@!;*+20&!5),/%0&(=!F#0.+!+)*(!
%,9#05&!,.!/,9,(7!,(!*!)#;&!+)*+!,.!*!),7)S5#(-/,5+!)#;&!$,+)!:*0&(+.!-,7)+,(7!*//!+)&!+,;&=!?)*+!,.!
*..#5,*+&%!$,+)!;#0&!(&7*+,9&!#2+5#;&.=!?)&!%#$(.,%&.!#-!%,9#05&!:#,(+!+#!+)&!,;:*5+!#(!
-,(*(5&.=!D#.+!#-!+)&!5),/%0&(!*0&!0*,.&%!1@!;#;<!;#;!)*.!/#.+!;#.+!#-!%*%B.!,(5#;&<!&+5=!
!
B($A(0)@A($&%&;.)
!
4&-&0.!+#!:&0.#(*/!1&/,&-.!*1#2+!$)&+)&0!#(&!,.!;*/&!#0!-&;*/&=!
!
!B($A(0)0"+(<.!*0&!52/+20*//@!%&-,(&%!(#0;.!+)*+!%,.+,(72,.)!1&+$&&(!;*/&!*(%!-&;*/&!
5)*0*5+&0,.+,5.=!"#$!:&#:/&!#-!*!5&0+*,(!7&(%&0!*0&!.2::#.&%!+#!1&)*9&=!?)&.&!*0&!/&*0(&%!9&0@!
&*0/@!#(=!
!
B($A(0)<45(-2<8!*0&!5#7(,+,9&!.+025+20&.!+)*+!,(-/2&(5&!)#$!:&#:/&!:&05&,9&!+)&!1&)*9,#0.!#-!
-&;*/&.!*(%!;*/&.=!
!
A#+)!1,#/#7@!*(%!+)&!&(9,0#(;&(+!5/&*0/@!:/*@!*!0#/&!,(!+)&!%&9&/#:;&(+!#-!7&(%&0!,%&(+,+@=!
!
R!',%<!%20,(7!*!5,052;5,.,#(<!/#.&.!),.!:&(,.<!*(%!,(!+)&!XYZ.!+)&@!%&5,%&!+#!;*'&!),;!,(+#!*!
1,#/#7,5*/!7,0/<!*(%!+)&@!5)*(7&%!),.!(*;&!+#!A0&(%*!*(%!0*,.&%!),;!*.!*!7,0/<!*(%!+)*+!%,%!(#+!
7#!9&0@!$&//=!A0&(%*!>2.+!)*%!+#(.!#-!+0#21/&!7#,(7!2:!*(%!.)&!*/$*@.!-&/+!/,'&!.)&!$*.!*!1#@!*(%!
$*(+&%!+#!%#!1#@!+),(7.<!.#!-,(*//@!$)&(!A0&(%*!$*.![\<!+)&!:*0&(+.!+#/%!),;])&0!$)*+!)*%!
)*::&(&%<!*(%!.)&!-&/+!0&/,&9&%<!.#!.)&!%&5,%&%!+)*+!.)&!$*(+&%!+#!1&!*!1#@=!U#!)&!1&5*;&!*!
;*(!*(%!7#+!;*00,&%<!*(%!)&!%,%!&(%!2:!5#;;,++,(7!.2,5,%&!*-+&0!7#,(7!+)0#27)!*!50,.,.!*.!*(!
*%2/+=!
!
A2+!1,#/#7,5*/!5#;:#(&(+!%#&.!&I,.+!,(!7&(%&0!*(%!+#!$)#!$&!*0&=!
!
B($A(0)%A($&%&;)A%<"0A(08!$)&(!*!5#(-/,5+!#5520.!1&+$&&(!*!:&0.#(B.!1,#/#7,5*/!.&I!*(%!+)&,0!
7&(%&0!,%&(+,+@=!
!
?)&0&!*0&!,..2&.!%&*/,(7!$,+)!$)&+)&0!+),.!,.!*5+2*//@!*!E%,.#0%&0H!#0!(#+=!
!
C24%2+)@A($&%&;.)
!
R(#+)&0!'&@!5#;:#(&(+!#-!;#.+!:&#:/&B.!.&/-!,%&(+,+@=!U#;&+),(7!+)*+!;*(@!*%#/&.5&(+.!.+*0+!
+#!%&*/!$,+)<!*(%!@#2!0&*/,C&!+)*+!(#+!&9&0@#(&!/##'.!+)&!.*;&!$*@=!
!
R(#+)&0!(&$!,..2&!,.!+)*+!:&#:/&!)*9&!;,I&%!0*5,*/!*(%!&+)(,5!,%&(+,+,&.<!.#!?,7&0!F##%.!5*;&!
2:!$,+)!+),.!,%&*!-#0!),;.&/-!E^*1/,(*.,*(H!+)*+!)&B.!^*25*.,*(<!1/*5'<!R;&0,5*(<!*(%!R.,*(=!
K1*;*!+*/'.!*!/#+!*1#2+!+)&!.+0277/&.!)&!)*%!70#$,(7!2:!+0@,(7!+#!-,(%!),.!0*5,*/!,%&(+,+@!
1&5*2.&!)&!,.!-0#;!*!;,I&%!0*5&!$,+)!*!$),+&!;#+)&0<!1/*5'!-*+)&0<!&+5=!
!