10. April 1 14 ENV222 lecture outline.pdf

4 Pages
49 Views
Unlock Document

Department
School of Environment
Course
ENV100H1
Professor
Stephen Scharper
Semester
Fall

Description
23)April 1 New forms of global governance Khagram, Sanjeev (2006). "Possible FutureArchitectures of Global Governance:ATransnational Perspective/Prospective." Global Governance, Vol. 12, pp. 97-117. ▯ Lecture outline ▯ Review - The problem with current environmental governance (March 13 lecture): . global environmental problems cannot be addressed by any one state acting alone; co- operation is needed; . the norm of state sovereignty (states need not recognize any authority as having powers to influence their actions) makes co-operation difficult; . the North-South divide means very different objectives exist; . the current system of global environmental governance suffers two major weaknesses in terms of its ability to facilitate co-operation: 1) multilateral environment agreements (MEAs) have low standards (due to veto power/lowest common denominator process) and cannot be actively enforced; 2) international governmental organizations (IGOs) like UNEP have limited powers and inadequate funding. ▯ 1. The solution ▯ Bear in mind that Khagram is offering both normative and analytical arguments (p. 501 “normative-analytic images”) – telling us which futures he personally prefers (normative) and which he thinks most likely (analytical), based on analysis of current trends. ▯ Khagram suggests six possibilities and then at the end gives his own preference. ▯ 1.1 Multilateralism Continued strengthening of current multilateral global governance system – IGOs (reading uses term interstate organization, IO) embedded in regimes, eg MEAs . states still dominant, but increased voice for civil society . establish international taxation (eg Tobin tax) . greater equality amongst states ▯ 1.2 Grassroots globalism . the radical activist vision, similar to anarchism . decentralization of political authority – states no longer dominant . move from globalized, private production by transnational corporations to localized, community-owned production . social movements much more powerful 1.3 Multiple, co-operative regionalisms . replication of the EU model in other parts of the world, except states are not central actors ▯1 . possible interregional body to provide governance above the levels of regional bodies ▯ 1.4 One world state . would hold military and taxing power – exercise coercive force, like current states . all global citizens vote . would almost certainly be federated; perhaps a federation of regional subnational governments 1.5 Networked governance . multi-level, state and non-state governance . both state and non-state actors co-ordinating their global activities, both outside and within the umbrella of state-led multilateral governance 1.6 Institutional heterarchy . many overlapping forms of state and non-state multi-level governance and government . shared norms such as democracy ▯ Khagram’s argument: . global governance has changed enormously since 1900, no reason to expect will not continue to change; so, any of these six are possible . states may hold a monopoly on coercive force, but they are far from being the only actors exerting influence at the global level . p. 507 civic transnational advocacy, eg Greenpeace; but also conservative forces, eg Christian fundamentalism . p. 508 professional scientific and technical organizations . p. 509 transnational corporations, plus globally organized criminal activity . p. 510 globalization/Americanization of culture . p. 510 movements of peoples across borders ▯ . presents history of emergence of the state as the dominant publicly-funded organizational form: 1900 – 55 states; plus many colonies (empire as form of global governance) 1954 – 154 states; result of decolonization 2000 – 192 states; plus many regions within states which want to become states, e
More Less

Related notes for ENV100H1

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit