Class Notes (835,107)
Canada (508,933)
Sociology (3,252)
SOC101Y1 (985)
Lecture 8

Lecture 8 March 7.docx

6 Pages
Unlock Document

Matthias Koenig

SOC377H1S March 7, 2011 Recap Methodological relationalism – Goffman, Collins Last week- to understand social reality we should start with interaction patterns: social phenomenon defined by physical presence of co-actors. This perspective argues we have no grasp of macro structures apart from their foundations in micro processes which are interactions Collins and interactional chains- comes close to social relations notions Today: - Further theoretical background - Elementary introduction to network analysis - Focus on one problem of network analysis given by Granovetter and weak ties - Are claims of methodological relationalists true? Theoretical considerations concerning perspective of sociology - Heritage on which authors build are Simmel, Mead, and Norbert Elias (instead of focusing on structures, we should look at figurations in which persons are embedded- figurational sociology) - Contemporary proponents – Granovetter- tries to develop underlying arguments - Granovetter says much of sociological theory has an atomized perspective of the individual which we should go beyond. He makes this argument against 2 different traditions (functionalist: Parsons) and with tradition of (rational choice or utilitarianism) – Why do these 2 theories have an atomized perspective of the individual? o Functionalism: there is the argument that the individual is acting on the premise of internalized norms. So in the process of action, the individual acts as an atomized individual while bringing with him internalized norms embedded in cultural society o Rational choice theorists assume individual acts out of self-interest (utilitarianism) – individual conceived in atomized way o Functionalism and rational choice have in one case over-socialized and under-socialized resolution of order (so in one tradition individual is too impregnated by social norms of society and in the other it is not embedded in any social norms) - Granovetter says we should see the individual as embedded in ongoing situations. So instead of being an actor acting out of self-interest, we should see the individual as part of ongoing social transactions or relations. This concept of embeddedness has a number of consequences for various fields of research. He is interested in analysis of economic phenomena where he argues we should focus on social embeddedness in which market participant’s act. - The market participants are always embedded in social relations which require trust and provide information (always part of the calculation of actors). This distinguishes embeddedness from functionalism. Embedded participants may result in conflict too, so social embeddedness (Relational perspective too) says individual not as part of social system of norms as guiding for Parsons theory but it is part of ongoing process of transactions that generate trust, provide information, produce conflict etc. - Anti-categorical imperative – means social theorists and empirical researchers should not focus on category of actors or attributes but rather relations between actors. For instance instead of dividing population according to categories (man and woman) we should not assume these categories to be existent but rather the outcome of relational phenomena we should observe instead. This imperative goes hand in hand with the idea to not focus on variables that explain social outcomes but to focus on relations and processes of transaction. Another author related to this school of relational theorizing is Andrew Abbott who has published many critical articles against variable theory. - Collins said causality need to reside in an acting individual, in actions or interactions of various individuals who produce through their action various outcomes. In other words variables cannot cause anything but interactions have causal power! - This is to some extent a similar point made by mechanistic proponents (Hedstrom critical of variable sociology) the difference in the relational perspective is that causality is not so much in individual but rather in the relations! - So what kind of information do we need to make arguments that not follow line of variable sociology and respect anti-categorical imperative. Relational data is most often used. Background information on Network Analysis - Closely related to theoretical line of relational thinking - Brings problem forward of ambiguity in relational perspective in making more radical statements that relations focus instead of individual and less radical where relations part of model referring to individuals too - Developments that took place in 40s and 50 in sociology, anthropology, biology etc. when scholars interested in developing information via social matrices - Since 1970s we have more formal theories of network analysis + new mathematical models, new computer programs etc. - Today network analysis is an alternative methodology used in sociology- alternative to classical variable approach - Important to grasp the character of network data- different from variable data. Variable data- individuals sharing attributes - Network data – two forms of information and analysis: Graphs (analyzed using mathematical graph theory) and Matrix - Relations represented via lines connected with nodes – triadic relation Properties of Relations Form - Focus on form of relations: meaning relations can be symmetric or asymmetric – undirected or directed o Undirected: ex. Time spent together by 2 actors o Asymmetric: one way arrow or symmetric C A B Content - Multi-plexity or uniplexity- how much time do you spend together as friends and at work (friendship networks and work networks) – both present between 2 participants Intensity - Weak or strong relations- how much time do y
More Less

Related notes for SOC101Y1

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.