Class Notes (838,537)
Canada (510,933)
Sociology (3,264)
SOC313H1 (110)
Lecture

SOC313- Gender & Self Control .docx

6 Pages
171 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Sociology
Course
SOC313H1
Professor
Candace K.
Semester
Winter

Description
Gender and Self Control – January 30 I. Labeling Women Deviant: Edwin Schur A. Presentation of Self 1. Emotions  mousy, bitchy, aggressive, etc. 2. Appearance  being overweight/too thin, dressing flashy etc. are all appearance norms 3. Speech & Interactions B. Marriage and Maternity  marital; still single, etc.  maternity; still single? Too many children? Unfit mother C. Sexuality 1. Behavior  cock-tease, frigid, nymphomaniac, etc. 2. Orientation  butch, queer, etc. -there is a fine line walking between what is acceptable and what is not for women based on these categories -Occupational Norms where do women go once they finish places like law school ? Ghettoized; family practice, divorce law, etc. Female Doctors go into Ob/Gyn and pediatrics -there are some changes but not enough II. Gender and Crime: Women Don’t Commit Crimes A. Biology: Lombroso & Ferrero  Criminal appearance; they look different than us  credited with inaugurated in the biological explanation of female crime  THE FEMALE OFFENDER By: LOMBROSO & FERRERO o biological deterministic view o they were interested in three factors: 1. How the female offender can be identified 2. Rate of female offending 3. Types of female crimes (Theft, Prostitution. Fraud, etc.) -female criminals had “masculine” characteristics; SAVAGE woman -women display fewer physical anomalies than men which in turn is indicative of their closeness to lower, less differentiated forms of life -limited range of cognitive facilities could also explain women’s fixation in particular areas of crime -DISCREDITED (obviously) -only analyzed people who were convicted & sent to prison -he drew connections between women’s physiology and the nature & extent of crime; this has become a recurring theme over time B. Hormones and Crime -the idea that you can connect premenstrual syndrome with female offending -this has been used as a successful defense in Britain, but not in the Americas -there are serious problems in establishing a cause and effect relationship  she has PMS, commits a crime, but we also know that the menstrual cycle is a very delicate thing and stress can bring on a menstrual cycle; so to argue that PMS causes crime is silly when the causal direction could be the reverse -hormones invoked when a woman kills her children  POST PARTUM DEPRESSION C . Psychology and Crime: Freud -wasn’t interested in criminal behavior but rather how we become social beings -he argued that we start out with an ID (instinct, with no socialization)  then the EGO is developed, and eventually a SUPEREGO (conscious; don’t do evil don’t commit crimes, etc.) -1925 article on psychological consequence of the anatomical distinctions b/w the sexes -1931 essay on female sexuality  at some point women experience penis envy  the way to deal with this was to become a mother -the influence of this kind of perspective has been relevant in prostitution studies- they have personality traits to want to dominant men, homosexual inclinations as a sign of role confusion -virtually all scholarship that assumes that female criminality represents a departure from prescribed sexual behavior is based on Freudian notions -this approach to female criminality didn’t die out with Freud D. DMS-IV and Women -defines all kinds of disorders surrounding criminal behavior -when the DMS IV was being reviewed, two new categories were called:  self-defeating personality disorder o women who put others needs ahead of their own  late luteul phased diysphoric disorder (PMS) o women who experienced extreme stress as an aspect of menstruation -MARGARET EKLER & someone responded by suggesting another disorder to add to DMS-IV  inability to derive pleasure from doing things for others, and to feel threatened by women who fail to disguise their intelligence -self defeating personality disorder was never added to the DMS –IV -there is a clear tendency to pathologize female offending; it is “not normal” for women to commit crimes -homicides have the best statistics  males account for 90% of homicides in the US ; constant over time  men commit more homicides than women but do they differ in who they kill? o acquaintances 55%, strangers at 25% -when you look at women, 37% kill an intimate partner, and the next category is their children at 10%  unusual for a woman to kill a stranger -Canada, Australia, Europe, etc, show similar statistics E. Sex Differences in Lethal and Non-lethal Violence -gap in gender isn’t as large as it is in homicides ; men still dominate though at 80% in the US -non lethal violence dominated by males OUTSIDE the US as well  even more so in European countries -why are women less involved in violence? -expectations of behavior will affect the developmental outcome -women’s lesser involvement in violent crime has been interpreted as a natural/normal fact ; more passive individuals; conversely some people say being violent is indicative of being violent as well  if you assume this is true, then anytime a woman commits a violent crime it is abnormal and cannot be attributed to the same factors for a man Her Article -interviewed women in jail; if they had initiated any acts of violence with a stranger or intimate partner -recorded the details up to 10 incidents of violence -that article only focuses on the women who said “I was involved in a violence incident -the focus of the article: could it be that women do violence/for the same reasons as men do -5 broad categories of motivation -jealousy, self-defense being dis-respected, self-help -lots of overlap III. Gender and Victimization: The Failure to “Deviantize Offensive Male Behaviors A. War Crimes  war prizes (?)  Vietnamese women & Japanese soldiers – “comfort women”  rape was ethnic cleansing  rape cannot be seen as incidental; str
More Less

Related notes for SOC313H1

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit