Class Notes (836,580)
Canada (509,856)
Sociology (3,253)
SOC314H1 (8)
Lecture

MARCH27LECSOC314.doc

7 Pages
84 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Sociology
Course
SOC314H1
Professor
Bonnie Fox
Semester
Winter

Description
SOC314 - March 27th ViolenceAgainst Children and Women - kids experience a sense of absence (a sense of loss & missing) - most researchers would stop at that - if you talk to children & look at what they are doing; learn- ing smart ways to handle that problem - kids are quite perceptive* - they argue that looking @ what these kids say - not only do kids care about their parents, but they also care for them (diplomatic in solving problems, interfaced, etc) - go on to make bigger claims - divorce forces kids to think differently about families - the kids are very involved in the relationships w/ their parents & their families - interesting argument 1. ViolenceAgainst Children - violence against children was a concern in the late 19th century - in the middle of 1980s; the issue was raised - when she raised the issue; there was laughter (1986) - disgusting! - before that; seen as something that was irrelevant - Duffy - argument they make; the causes are not just about individuals - if the causes are individual (sick people, or individual pathology) you would see violence ran- domly scattered across different types of household - NOT randomly scattered; clear patterns* - types of people who are more likely to be violence (social class, gender, etc) - good discussions about patriarchal cultures; violence against women is not seen as problematic and is in fact apart of the culture A. A Canadian estimate: over 1 in 100 (Trocme) (1) 40% involved neglect (failure to protect, failure to supervise, failure to feed properly, failure to enroll in school, putting them at risk of danger) (2) 31% involved physical abuse (clear evidence usually by looking @ the body of child, mandato- ry to report evidence of abuse {the law}) (3) 19% involved emotional abuse (hardest to find evidence of - involves maltreatment, exposure to drugs) (4) 11% involved sexual abuse (ranges exhibitionism, unwanted touch) - estimating the incidence is difficult - a fraction of what actually happens - for every 1 case that came to their attention, there were 10 more (sense of what actually come clear) - estimates come from people who self-report (“i was a victim”) - self-reporting; we don’t know how good the data is - Duffy talks about national study done in 2001 - random sample of child welfare service agencies - this data is based on formal investigations of cases reported to them that they’ve investigated - this is the best data we have* - in 45 percent of those investigations; the suspicions were correct - conclude that in about 1 in every 100 children is experiencing some kind of abuse or violence Who are the perpetrators? - neglect = mothers more likely to be seen as the perpetrator - not surprising - mothers are the ones who take care of children - in the case of physical abuse - biological mothers and father equally - finding is interesting b/c men spend much less time with their children - stepfathers are more likely than stepmothers to physically abuse their kids - emotional abuse - mothers and fathers equally (stepfathers more than stepmothers) - the case of sexual abuse - much more likely to be someone who is not a parent (if it’s a parent, its almost never the mother) - sexual abuse = a neighbor or someone the child knows/trusts B. Children in lone-parent families more likely to suffer some kind of violence (causes: alcohol, lack of social supports, mental-health problems) C. Men as perpetrators (1) no history of caregiving, lack of empathy - men don’t do daily care of their children - what is most interesting about this (in caring for a child) you develop everything - literally learn empathy by taking care of a small child - with father - if they don’t care of their children, they may not create that empathy (2) the discourse of rights - started to think of kids as rights (3) the stresses of occupation failure - the role of a father: to support your family financially - a guy’s children might represent his failure - also the role of occupational failure; economy that is producing lots of unemployment D. Women as perpetrators (1) The weight of private responsibility for children, and lack of social supports - her children was her life - difficult to stay home full-time with children - we put women in a situation that is very stressful - do not provide them with much support - single mothers have added pressures - the private responsibility for kids is something we need to think about - contextual things that affect people - in the end; a lot of people have stress and don’t hurt their kids - what is the added factor to the situation that does it???? E. The effects of childhood abuse (for women & men, Alice Miller) - people who are violent are much more likely than anybody else to have been abused themselves or grown up in families where violence was present - another piece to the puzzle - arguing that in all their childhoods; found authoritarian, psychological parents - if children are absolutely suppressed - that leaves psychic damage - argues that without therapy; that child will grow up to be violent - people have said without a loving parent (horribly abusive father + a loving mother) that child may be OK as an adult F. A violent culture - can argue that we live in a violent culture - Canadians are much different thanAmerican - 47% of us condone spanking as a form of discipline - 70% of us were opposed to a law refraining parents from spanking kids - spanking is dangerous* G. Sexual Abuse (Judith Herman, Father-Daughter Incest) - premeditated abuse - sexual abuse is premeditated - as I said, almost never women - one study by Herman - study called Father-Daughter Incest - study a large group of cases that she can get details on* - finds a pattern across the different cases (40 cases) - the patterns were the same across all the families she was looking at - the man is clearly the authority in the family - often he was a good provider - fulfilled his role very well - BUT very controlling; kind of man who felt entitled to have his needs met - when she looked at the details of the family situation - found a mother, wife who somehow was not able to fulfill her duties as a wife* - not available for sex, chronically sick, busy w/ children - common pattern: not available! - a daughter stepped in to help out (cooking, laundry) fill in for mom now that she is in capacity - the daughter - do the things that her mother did - INCLUDES SEX! - distorted sense of entitlement - clear a lack of empathy & understanding - forgets this is a child, someone he is supposed to protect 2. Adults A. A “gendered” crime - about men hurting women - more frequently occurring in the home, & often due to factors common to heterosexual relationships - violence against adults - different kinds of summaries about what is going on - when you separate only serious violence - it is men who do it, very rarely women - look @ serious violence - true that women are as likely to start a fight than the man - the serious violence - almost exclusively done by men - gendered social phenomenon (1) Homicide: Rosemary Gartner et al., on “femicide” 1974-1994: between 63% and 76% were by intimate partners or ex-partners - she has done a very careful and long study but she looks @ homicides - 1974 - 1994 in Ontario - started out with the easy stuff - the records from the court case - for permission to look at the police records - not accessible to most people + coroner’s records as well - 1st statistic = 87% of homicides in that period of time were done by men - who is committing the homicides? - with that additional evidence; able to estimate who likely did it - what she finds is that the official stats - 46 & 50% of those
More Less

Related notes for SOC314H1

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit