Class Notes (921,960)
CA (542,709)
Western (51,671)
Sociology (3,358)
2259 (202)
Prof (12)
Lecture

6 - Critcal Theories of Deviance.odt

6 Pages
107 Views

Department
Sociology
Course Code
Sociology 2259
Professor
Prof

This preview shows pages 1-2. Sign up to view the full 6 pages of the document.
Critical Theories of Deviance
1. Conflict Theories
2. Power-Reflexive Theories
3. Feminist Theories
Conflict Theory of Deviance
Macro-level approach
Focus on FORMAL social control of deviant behaviour
Social order is maintained through management of conflict between different groups in society
Focus on WHO has the power to create rules that deviantize those with less power
Conflict theory of deviance includes 3 basic elements:
Social rules emerge from conflict and serve the interests of society's powerful groups
Members of powerful groups are less likely to break the rules because...
Members of powerful groups are more likely to break the rules because...
Society is divided into groups with competing interests
Social rules emerge from this conflict
However, the dominant group organizes society in order to preserve and reproduce power
Therefore the rules serve powerful interests and deviantize those that are powerless
The goal of a conflict approach to deviance is to explain crime within economic and social
contexts including:
The connections among social class, crime, and social control
The role of government/criminal justice system (CJS) in creating criminogenic
environments
Bias in the justice system
The relationship between capitalism and crime rates
Karl Marx (1818-1883)
Bourgeoisie (“ruling” class) and proletariat (“powerless” class) have an unequal relationship
due to power differentials
Marx: capitalism would result in proliferation of criminal laws to foster the interests of the
bourgeoisie:
Laws would prohibit behaviour that wasn't conductive to ruling class
Laws would legitimize formal social control by the ruling
Friedrich Engels (1820-1895)
Portrayed crime as a function of social demoralization
A collapse of people's humanity reflecting a decline in society
The brutality of the capitalist system turns workers into animal-like creatures
Without a will of their own
Willem Bonger (1876-1940)
Society is composed of ruling class and inferior class based on the system of production
Laws reflect the interests of the dominant class
Capitalism encourages egoism and criminality by equating status with property
Capitalism creates greed --> crime!
Modern Conflict Theory
Prominent during the 1960s
Influenced by:
Labelling theories
Research on social inequality (racism, sexism) and social injustice
Social and political upheavals of the 60s and 70s
Sees crime/deviance as RATIONAL behaviour due to the nature of society
Group Conflict Theory (George Vold)
Vold: “Criminality is the normal, natural response of normal, natural human beings struggling
in understandably normal and natural situations for the maintenance of the way of life to which
they stand committed.”
Behaviour that conflicts with the ideology of the dominant group will be defined as
deviant/criminal
Deviant behaviour often associated with an ideological clash between dominant and less
powerful groups
“Core Struggle” (Austin Turk)
Dominant group must convince “powerless” group that norms/rules are legitimate
Coercing doesn't work
In order to convince the “powerless” of the current rules, dominant class uses:
Ideology
Hegemony
Power
Authority
Results in the “powerless” having a “False Consciousness
Instrumental Marxism (Richard Quinney)
Laws and definitions of deviance are a “tool” of the ruling class
About serving interests of those in power and criminalizing the behaviour of those with minimal
power
Laws and definitions of deviance are instrumental to those making them
A “deviant” label is a means through which to control the powerless
Social Reality of Crime (Richard Quinney)
Definitions of behaviour (conformity and deviance) made by authorized political agents
Deviant/criminal definitions reflect interests of powerful
Degree of threat determines mode of enforcement
Less powerful = more deviant
Media disseminates “images” of crime = consensus
Crime is “constructed”
Nuts, Sluts, and Perverts (Alexander Liazos)
Fascination with individual deviants deflects our attention from social structure and “power”
Ignores “top dogs”—power holders
Sociologists should be focusing on “Covert Institutional Violence”
Structural Marxism (Stephen Spitzer - 1975)

Loved by over 2.2 million students

Over 90% improved by at least one letter grade.

Leah — University of Toronto

OneClass has been such a huge help in my studies at UofT especially since I am a transfer student. OneClass is the study buddy I never had before and definitely gives me the extra push to get from a B to an A!

Leah — University of Toronto
Saarim — University of Michigan

Balancing social life With academics can be difficult, that is why I'm so glad that OneClass is out there where I can find the top notes for all of my classes. Now I can be the all-star student I want to be.

Saarim — University of Michigan
Jenna — University of Wisconsin

As a college student living on a college budget, I love how easy it is to earn gift cards just by submitting my notes.

Jenna — University of Wisconsin
Anne — University of California

OneClass has allowed me to catch up with my most difficult course! #lifesaver

Anne — University of California
Description
Critical Theories of Deviance 1. Conflict Theories 2. Power-Reflexive Theories 3. Feminist Theories Conflict Theory of Deviance • Macro-level approach • Focus on FORMAL social control of deviant behaviour • Social order is maintained through management of conflict between different groups in society • Focus on WHO has the power to create rules that deviantize those with less power • Conflict theory of deviance includes 3 basic elements: ◦ Social rules emerge from conflict and serve the interests of society's powerful groups ◦ Members of powerful groups are less likely to break the rules because... ◦ Members of powerful groups are more likely to break the rules because... • Society is divided into groups with competing interests • Social rules emerge from this conflict • However, the dominant group organizes society in order to preserve and reproduce power • Therefore the rules serve powerful interests and deviantize those that are powerless • The goal of a conflict approach to deviance is to explain crime within economic and social contexts including: ◦ The connections among social class, crime, and social control ◦ The role of government/criminal justice system (CJS) in creating criminogenic environments ◦ Bias in the justice system ◦ The relationship between capitalism and crime rates • Karl Marx (1818-1883) ◦ Bourgeoisie (“ruling” class) and proletariat (“powerless” class) have an unequal relationship due to power differentials ◦ Marx: capitalism would result in proliferation of criminal laws to foster the interests of the bourgeoisie: ▪ Laws would prohibit behaviour that wasn't conductive to ruling class ▪ Laws would legitimize formal social control by the ruling • Friedrich Engels (1820-1895) ◦ Portrayed crime as a function of social demoralization ▪ Acollapse of people's humanity reflecting a decline in society ◦ The brutality of the capitalist system turns workers into animal-like creatures ▪ Without a will of their own • Willem Bonger (1876-1940) ◦ Society is composed of ruling class and inferior class based on the system of production ◦ Laws reflect the interests of the dominant class ◦ Capitalism encourages egoism and criminality by equating status with property ◦ Capitalism creates greed --> crime! Modern Conflict Theory • Prominent during the 1960s • Influenced by: ◦ Labelling theories ◦ Research on social inequality (racism, sexism) and social injustice ◦ Social and political upheavals of the 60s and 70s • Sees crime/deviance as RATIONAL behaviour due to the nature of society Group Conflict Theory (George Vold) • Vold: “Criminality is the normal, natural response of normal, natural human beings struggling in understandably normal and natural situations for the maintenance of the way of life to which they stand committed.” • Behaviour that conflicts with the ideology of the dominant group will be defined as deviant/criminal • Deviant behaviour often associated with an ideological clash between dominant and less powerful groups “Core Struggle” (Austin Turk) • Dominant group must convince “powerless” group that norms/rules are legitimate ◦ Coercing doesn't work • In order to convince the “powerless” of the current rules, dominant class uses: ◦ Ideology ◦ Hegemony ◦ Power ◦ Authority • Results in the “powerless” having a “False Consciousness” Instrumental Marxism (Richard Quinney) • Laws and definitions of deviance are a “tool” of the ruling class • About serving interests of those in power and criminalizing the behaviour of those with minimal power • Laws and definitions of deviance are instrumental to those making them • A“deviant” label is a means through which to control the powerless Social Reality of Crime (Richard Quinney) • Definitions of behaviour (conformity and deviance) made by authorized political agents • Deviant/criminal definitions reflect interests of powerful • Degree of threat determines mode of enforcement • Less powerful = more deviant • Media disseminates “images” of crime = consensus • Crime is “constructed” Nuts, Sluts, and Perverts (Alexander Liazos) • Fascination with individual deviants deflects our attention from social structure and “power” • Ignores “top dogs”—power holders • Sociologists should be focusing on “Covert Institutional Violence” Structural Marxism (Stephen Spitzer - 1975) • Rules protect capitalist system • Not just about protecting the “ruling class” • Interests usually coincide, but ruling class is not monolithic • Deviant labels attached to anyone who threatens the capitalist system Contradictions of Capitalism • Education • Factory system • Problem populations: ◦ Social junk ◦ Social dynamite Control Overproduction of Deviance 1. Normalization 2. Conversion 3. Containment 4. Organized Crime Pluralist Conflict Theory • Emphasizes multiple axes of inequality and power in society—needs to focus on more than just the economic • Intersectional approach to deviance/crime • People can be deviantized/powerless on the basis of other social categories, ex: ◦ Gender ◦ Race/Ethnicity ◦ Sexual orientation ◦ Religion Cultural Conflict Theory (Thorstein Sellin – 1938) • Criminal law vs. Conduct norms • Results in culture conflict • ex. recent Shafia honour killings in Canada Power-Reflexive Theories (Pfohl – 1994) • Aka “Critical Poststructuralism” • Emphasize intertwining of knowledge and power • Existence of multiple “discourses” (bodies of knowledge) • BUT...power relations determine which discourses are legitimized • 3 tasks of power-reflexive analysis • Foucault – power through discipline • Benthan – Panoptic Prison Panoptic Power and Discipline (Foucault) • Society modelled like a panopticon • Pervasiveness of regulatory mechanisms to ensure “conformity” • Disciplinary power allows for supervision, control, and correction of deviance • Always potentially under surveillance Limitations • Ignores individual differences ◦ Variation in response to powerlessness ◦ Why people commit particular crimes/acts of deviance ◦ Opportunity, intelligence, skills ◦ Individuals/groups not totally dominated, dominating • Focus on making the powerless amendable to “correction” • Tends to be hi
More Less
Unlock Document


Only pages 1-2 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

Unlock Document
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version

Unlock Document

Log In


OR

Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit