Class Notes (835,295)
Canada (509,074)
Philosophy (388)
PP111 (69)

Religious Experience and the Problem of Evil

5 Pages
Unlock Document

Gary Foster

PP111: Religious Experience and the Problem of Evil March 31 , ‘14 - Nature, universe exhibits a certain kind of order/patterns with structures … can only be attributed to an intelligent designer. Religious Experience: - Traditional arguments for the existence of God (cosmological, ontological, teleological, etc.) aim to give ‘indirect’proof of God’s existence. - Religious experience is meant to be ‘direct’evidence of God’s existence. Two kinds of Experiences 1. Mystical Experience (do not rely on the concept of god): - Of the unity of all things; - Of the unity of the self with non-self; etc… 2. Religious Experience: - Of God Justification for Religious Belief: Experience & Testimony Can God be known by experience? 1. Do religious experiences reported by others give us reason to believe God exists? When is their testimony reliable? a) Are their reports sincere? b) Are their experiences veridical? 2. Do our own religious experiences give us reason to believe God exists?  Are our own experiences veridical? The Visions of Teresa (1515 – 1582) “Of all impossibilities, the most impossible is that these true visions should be the work of the imagination … they far transcend what we can comprehend on earth.” (161) “Religious ideas … are illusions” - “What is characteristic illusions is that they are derived from human wishes.” - “An illusion is not the same thing as an error.” (162) - Religious experiences, if derived from wishes for security and comfort, may explain belief; but they do not justify it. The Problem - We all rely on the testimony for many of our beliefs. - But we know that: 1. Not all reports can be trusted – some are insincere 2. Not all experiences can be trusted – some are not veridical How can it be rational to rely on testimony? - Because we have the ability to verify their reports for ourselves - But in the case of religious experiences we usually cannot check the reports of others: We typically have nothing but their word. What does reliable testimony require? 1. The testifier must be a reliable perceiver. - Functioning perceptual organs in good perceptual conditions 2. The testifier must be a competent judge of what she perceives. - Has conception of the object that is adequate for identifying it Interrogating Testimony about religious experience 1. Do we know what conditions are good for optimal for experiencing God? 2. Do we have any conception of what God looks (or sounds) like? Would we recognize God? ADefense of Atheism: The Problem of Evil 1. If there were a God, then there would be no evil. 2. But, there is evil. 3. So, there is no God. Theodicy: An attempt to rationally reconcile the existence (or apparent existence) of evil with the existence of God. Constructing a Theodicy requires denying 1, 2 or both. Three Clarifications 1. Natural Evils vs. Moral Evils 2. Definition of ‘God’: all-powerful, all-knowing, all-good, creator of everything. (God is never weak, ignorant, or malicious) 3. It is no limitation on God’s power to be unable to do what is logically impossible (e.g., draw a 4 sided triangle). Theod
More Less

Related notes for PP111

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.