SOME HIGHLIGHTS OF LECTURE 1 ON CHAPTERS 1AND 2
The Canadian Legal System
In addition to the Constitution, and written and unwritten law, the Canadian
Legal system is comprised of three Branches of Government:
1. Legislative Branch: creates law in the form of statutes. Synonyms for statutes
are legislation, and Acts if Parliament or Acts.
As between the federal government and the provincial governments, in order to
determine which government has the right to enact a statute or legislation, you must
refer to the Canadian Constitution which is comprised of both the British North
America Act, 1867 (now called theConstitution Act, 1867); and the Canadian
Charter of Rights and Freedoms. In the ConstitutionAct 1867, sections 91 and 92
of this Act set out the division of powers between the Federal Government (section
91) and the Provinces (Section 92) or, in other words, the jurisdiction of the Federal
Government and the provinces. For example, the federal government has exclusive
jurisdiction over criminal law, navigation and shipping, bankruptcy and insolvency,
national defence and currency etc…, while the provincial governments have
jurisdiction over property and civil rights, matters of a local or private nature in a
province, the solemnization of marriage, administration of justice (the court system)
etc…. Exclusive jurisdiction means that the jurisdiction held by that particular level
of government is not shared with another. In other words, if the federal government
has exclusive jurisdiction in a specific area such as criminal law, the provinces cannot
enact or make or pass any laws in that area.
Sometimes, however, a given area does not fall into section 91 or 92 so that both the
provinces and the federal government can pass laws relating to that area. For
example, “public health”. This is called concurrent jurisdiction. However, where both the federal government and a province or provinces pass laws that conflict with
one another, something called the doctrine of paramountcy applies. This doctrine
states that where there is a conflict or inconsistency between federal and provincial
legislation, the federal legislation prevails.
2. Executive Branch: The branch of government that formulates or makes and
executes or puts into force government policy, as well as administering all
departments of government. It is comprised of the prime minister (federal) or premier
(provincial) and their Cabinets (made up of ministers of various governmental
departments). Generally speaking, the Executive branch is responsible for
making regulations for particular statutes. These regulations often provide
procedures and rules under a given statute and/or fill in blanks left in the
statutes. Regulations and the making of rules form the basis of Administrative
Law which is an area of law that relates to the various boards, agencies, tribunals and
commissions who exercise some form of governmental function provided for by
legislation and the regulations that apply to them.
3. Judicial Branch: This branch is composed of judges who are appointed by
both federal or provincial governments. These judges preside over civil disputes and
criminal proceedings and administer justice in the courts of the provinces.
Generally, in Ontario and most provinces, the system of courts, is divided as follows:
1. Small Claims Court: In Ontario (Ontario
More
Less