Class Notes (806,449)
Canada (492,253)
York University (33,488)
Philosophy (679)
PHIL 2500 (10)

Feminist Epistemology and Reason (Lloyd) March 4th 2013.docx

4 Pages
Unlock Document

York University
PHIL 2500
Linda Carozza

Monday March 4 th Feminist Epistemologies TA teaching class -What is “feminist epistemology”? -What makes an epistemology feminist? Today: “The Man of Reason”-Genevieve Lloyd -What is epistemology? -A body of knowledge -Study of knowledge -Epistemologists want to know what is knowledge? How is it created, disseminated? How is it dispersed and acquired. How do we know what we know? To what extent is it possible for a subject to be know? How much knowledge can you have a subject? Necessary and sufficient conditions of knowledge -Feminist epistemology -Study of knowledge from a feminist perspective -male paradigms vs. female qualities, divide between maleness and femaleness -dominant epistemological systems Terms- necessary and sufficient conditions of knowledge What are necessary conditions?-needed meeting a requirement- must be satisfied for a statement to be true. if x is needed for y then if we don’t have x we don’t have y. Oxygen is a necessary condition for human life. If we don’t have oxygen we don’t have human life. Sufficient condition- enough. If satisfied, assures the statements truth. X guarantees y. if you get 89% you get a A. You could get 85 or whatever, but 89 would be an A. Various types of knowledge -know how to do things (play softball) -know about places -we can know other people- We know the lecturer, he brother also knows her. There are degrees of knowledge Propositional Knowledge “S” knows that “P” S- subject who knows p-proposition that is known -example Sally knows that the cup is white -Substitution assumptions (A key aspect of propositional knowledge) -S can be substituted by S (S can be substituted for any other subject who knows) And P can be substituted for any other subject who knows -When epistemologists talk about propositional knowledge they’re talking about empirical items that you can observe in the world- not like how well you know someone or somewhere, they’re talking about chairs, balls, tables. -Pieces of information that you can verify through your senses. -The idea is that the subject can be anyone. -Sally knows that the class ends at 2:30 Feminist epistemologist- critique the issues with classical western epistemology The take issue with the following- -positivism and objectivity -universality (not located- doesn’t have a place in space and time) -authority-who do we say can know? who do we look to to provide knowledge? -rationality, certainty, universalizability -individualism and autonomy (depends on who’s work your reading, different feminist episimologists have different viewpoints) 1. reliance on science and positivism- to get to the truth of something- western context but also other culture -Every rationally justifiable assertion can be scientifically verified. We use science to get truth. Well “science has proven that ____”. Trying to get us to believe that’s true. 1.Value-neutrality- we look at Facts as disconnected or dissociated from value system- no objective, no ideology. Facts and values are separate. It’s just science. 2.Objectivity- remove subjective bias from inquiry and claims about truth. Be able to reproduce same results. Need the same results anywhere- ideological leaning is removed. -contrasted with relativism /subjective relativism)-truth about reality is relative to the individual perceiving it (ie. Protagoras-“man is the measure of all things”) -If a br
More Less

Related notes for PHIL 2500

Log In


Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.