Get 2 days of unlimited access
Class Notes (1,000,000)
US (420,000)
UC-Irvine (10,000)
PHILOS (100)
Lecture 14

PHILOS 2 Lecture Notes - Lecture 14: Performative Contradiction, Presupposition, Principle Of Bivalence


Department
Philosophy
Course Code
PHILOS 2
Professor
Sven Bernecker
Lecture
14

This preview shows pages 1-3. to view the full 10 pages of the document.
Moore’s Paradox
 !"#$
%&'()*)&+(*)))),&-(&./&
0&)&(1*&(/+1/*)(&(
&+-(/'-.&'
%logical&'&()2'(/*&(&+3*
%&)+3&'/+(()*&&*+&-+$1
(/&(&+)
o%(&*'-(/&(&)+(1&)
+(&)(
4/*+(
o5&(&&&&(&&
%&)(&(*41&&&(-/
5/))&'
o5))&
.++&'!5+&/(/)&)(/'/
+&/))&1&+&)&(-+&/1
o%++++&/()-4*'(
6)&(&(++&/5&(&'&(+
%performave&'())4(/&(&)
)(('&)*(**(&'((('&6)&'&(
)((')((
4/*+(
o5/)
o5(*+&()
o7)&4&((
o5/)&&)&
%*/'-&'&(+&+&'(&(-&+)
+3&'6)-8(/
9/-(&()liar paradox*/'-&'(
o%.)&((*)))&+(&%++.(+&(
//&(*/'-&'5)&((/&(1)&&(+(
(.)(+))$:-(+1&)&((/&(+(1)&
&((.&(+&$
o6)+&*4&()*/'-+&+&'
.+&;('<
0)&))((/(4*(((*/'-&'=
% //)**&/
 5(&()&14*/*'
. 5>+&-)*

Only pages 1-3 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

D. You receive a wrien leer in the mail that reads “leers are never wrien and
never delivered.
a. 5&-()+81)>(&')+&-
)+8))+8((6?%.6+&-&&(6?
.@7676)&(+&-
 &&(+++14*)
>(4
+&-(()4/*+()&(*4
A//))(8(
 5&(&&5>+&-&&("B# $
 C&(+()(D))()(1))&(&(+&
B 5)*&(+(6(5>+&-)5&"B# $
 6+&-&)*(1(++)(/()E(
5+&-)))(1))("BF$
 C&(+())+&-(1))(
+&/()&&(((((/(+&$! $
(/()-&)/(
 Omissive form*G5+&-)*
 @/&((&-(&(+3*(++&
& $B$
 *((+(/
B Commissive form I:5+&-)*1&&()()*
 5+&-)*G3*$ 3*G5+&-)*$
 3*G5+&-)*$ *G5+&-)3*$
Commissive form II*G5+&-)3*
 ./&((&-(&(+3*(/&(&+&$
(/())*((++((/()/&((&-/&((&-
/$not+&+&'(
5)(/$+&+&'1&+((
+()))'$+)-(()
7'3&)&&(&&5+&-&&(&&
&((()6)&((/++(9(/(
&H/+&3*(/(
o6)&((/++(5++&-)&&(&&(5>/
(&(5>()&)-
(/(/+*/'-&'(1+&+&'(
-))(/(+&+&'(1((')/(/(
((+3'&/))(/((('&'
p & I do not believe that p
5)*'+'/))*)5+&-)*

Only pages 1-3 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

o5((+&-)*'+'/
o5&)(&((+&-))/)(/'/
Moore’s paradox is the problem of explaining why Moorean statements cannot be
sincerely asserted without absurdity.
C9/(
6)(&$&(*(&&(*((*(
o5&(&&5did not believe(&)*(
o5&(&&I will believe otherwise&)
6)(&$&(*(&))&($*(*
o5&(&&he+&-)&&(&&
6)>()&()!)+(/)+&-(
()&&&&)
5>(+(&)E(*((&+D*++
6)(&$&(*(&&(/+*
o5&(&&&&(possible)5>+&-&
6)E(*(*++*($(*(-)(&
o5&(&&we +&-)&&(&&
6)(&(/(&(+(*(-&)+thought
8
&9/(
4/*+(9/(&-)&/(+$
5)-+&(
o.+()(&)&()&((&!)-)-(/+&(1()
())()/(+-(/1&//&+
(/
%+)))&)++/*&&(/&(1+(&)
o6)&(&(*&&%+())&((&)(&&5
&)1)++/*&&(/&(6)/*&&)+(
&)&(/&(
())&((
6))&(///)>(&+(()>(+*)(
o6)*()8()&((&(+&)&/(+
o9/)(>+&-&&(+&)(1((/&
)4&((
5>+&-))&((4*((()
o5+4*(()(+()+&-)(1))&(
()+))&(+()
5&(&&5>+&-)5+&-)&&(&&
o6)4
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version