PHL240H1 Lecture : Notes Lecture 3
Document Summary
Second half of the lecture: introduction and situation, duplication case, identity, survival and psychological continuity. Locke was right about psychological cont. but he thinks we can answer these questions in other ways. These cases present a problem if you hold either of the beliefs which (at that time ) people did believe. He"s going to try and give reasons for denying these beliefs. Its not clear what we should say about identity and that will be a problem depending on what we believe about identity. Determinate answers: there are determinate answers for all questions regarding identity. Identity is what matters : if we cannot ans questions of identity, we can"t ans imp. Questions about responsibility, memory and survival. (nd) : there are some questions about personal identity for which there are no answers. (ni): identity is not what matters to us. Parfit maintains his target is the same as for e. g. ; law.