LLB102 Study Guide - Final Guide: Cerebos, Vicarious Liability, Tort
Approach(to(full(advice(in(negligence(
(
- !"#$%&'()*+,%&#-)+$")+..#/#")$#/.&/#$0#)
- 12,3)%425/4)#+04)#.#6#$%)+-)+$)&--5#7)
o 8&")%4#)"#'#$"+$%)29#)+)"5%()2')0+,#:)Donoghue(v(Stevenson)
§ ;-%+<.&-4#":)"5%()Donoghue(v(Stevenson)=>+$5'+0%5,#,à?2$-56#,7)Donoghue(v(
Stevenson@)A005*&#,à)#$%,+$%7)Strong(v(Woolworths@);6*.2(#,-à);6*.2(##-7)
Kondis=B88C@)D2+")5-#,-à)D2+")5-#,-7)Imbree(v(McNeilly@)E0422.)+5%42,&%&#-F)
G#+04#,-à)-%5"#$%-7)NSW(v(Lepore@)H,2'#--&2$+.-à)?.&#$%-7)Roger(v(Whitaker)I)
Wallace(v(KamCJ))
§ B2$K"#.#/+<.#)"5%()=&'),#.#L+$%C:)*NSW(v(Lepore;(Kondis(v(State(Transort(
Authority)
)
=E0422.à)-%+'')à)-%5"#$%-7)NSW(v(Lepore@)M2-*&%+.)à)H+%&#$%-7)Kondis(v(State(
Transport(Authority@)A005*&#,-à);$%,+$%-@);6*.2(#,à);6*.2(##)=,#+-2$+<.#)
0+,#)%+3#$)<()&%-#.'N)#6*.2(##-)+$")&$"#*#$"#$%)02$%,+0%2,-CC))
§ O&0+,&25-)P&+<&.&%()=;6*.2(#,);6*.2(##)D#.+%&2$-4&*C:)Hollis(v(Vabu(Pty(Ltd)
• G2,%'#+-2,)&-)#6*.2(##)=G2%+.&%()2')D#.+%&2$-4&*7)Hollis(v(VabuC)
• ;6*.2(##)0266&%%#")+)%2,%&25-)+0%)
• G2,%)0266&%%#")9&%4&$)-02*#)=;6*.2(#,)+5%42,&-#-)+0%7)NSW(v(Lepore@)
1,2$/'5.)>2"#)2,);Q*,#--)H,24&<&%&2$7)Bugge(v(BrownCJ)
§ B2L#.)"5%(:))
• H5,#)H-(04&+%,&0)!$R5,()
)
>5.%&)S+0%2,)T**,2+04)=Sullivan(v(Moody))
o M+,6),#02/$&-#"7)>#"&0+..()$2%)R5-%)/,&#'N)+$Q&#%()2,)-2,,29)=Tame(
v(NSW;(Annetts(v(Stations(Pty(LtdC)
o M+,6),#+-2$+<.#)'2,#-##+<.#),#-5.%)',26)"#')02$"50%)=Gifford(v(
Strang(Pty(Ltd(='2,#-##+<.#C@)Koehler(v(Cerebos(=%22)6504)92,3F)
$2%)'2,#-##+<.#C)
o B2,6+.)'2,%&%5"#)=Tame(v(NSW))
o )S+0%2,-),#.#L+$%)
§ B+%5,#)2')D#.+%&2$-4&*)<#%9##$)*+,%&#-7)0.2-#),#.+%&2$-4&*F)
+--56#"),#-*2$-&<&.&%()=Gifford(v(Strang,(Annetts(v(StationsC)
§ ?2$%,2.)O5.$#,+<&.&%()=Gifford;(AnnettsC)
§ ?24#,#$0()2')P+9)=?2$-&-%#$%C)
§ !$"#%#,6&$+0()
)
• H5,#);02$26&0)P2--)=Caltex(Oil(v(The(Dredge))
>5.%&KS+0%2,)=Sullivan(v(MoodyC)
o T-0#,%+&$#")?.+--)G#-%)=CaltexC7)U$29.#"/#)2')H.J)+-)&$"&L&"5+.)
§ U$29.#"/#)2')+-0#,%+&$+<.#)0.+--)2')L5.$#,+<.#)*#,-2$-)
=Christopher(v(FijiC)
o S&L#)E+.&#$%)S#+%5,#-)=Caltex)7)U$29.#"/#)2').2--)+-),#-5.%)2')
"+6+/#N)3$29.#"/#)2')#Q&-%#$0#)2')*&*#)+$")&%-)5-#-N)B#/.&/#$%)
&$'.&0%&2$)2')"+6+/#N)B+%5,#)2')"#%,&6#$%)-5''#,#"N)B+%5,#)2')
8+6+/#-)0.+&6#")
o H4(-&0+.)*,2*&$V5&%()%#-%)=H4(-&0+.)*,2*&$V5&%(W)*4(-&0+..()0.2-#C)
=CaltexC)
o A%4#,)Fortuna(Food(S+0%2,-7)8#'X-)3$29.#"/#N)8#'X-)?2$%,2.N)
!$"#%#,6&$+%#).&+<&.&%()
) )
§ E%+%#)%4#)-02*#)2')%4#)"5%()+$")&"#$%&'()&')%4#)+..#/#")<,#+04)&-)9&%4&$)%4+%)-02*#)
2')"5%()
Document Summary
Established? duty donoghue v stevenson (manufacturer consumer: donoghue v. Stevenson; occupier entrant: strong v woolworths; employers employees: Kondis(ndd); road users road users: imbree v mcneilly; school authorities/ Teachers students: nsw v lepore; professionals clients: roger v whitaker & Authority (school staff students: nsw v lepore; hospital patients: kondis v state. Transport authority; occupiers entrants; employer employee (reasonable care taken by itself, employees and independent contractors)) Hollis v vabu pty ltd: tortfeasor is employee (totality of relationship: hollis v vabu, employee committed a tortious act, tort committed within scope (employer authorises act: nsw v lepore; Wrongful mode or express prohibition: bugge v brown). Multi factor approach (sullivan v moody: harm recognised: medically not just grief, anxiety or sorrow (tame v nsw; annetts v stations pty ltd, harm reasonable foreseeable result from def conduct (gifford v. Strang pty ltd (foreseeable); koehler v cerebos (too much work/ not foreseeable: normal fortitude (tame v nsw)
