Study Guides (248,471)
Canada (121,570)
Psychology (579)
PSYC 341 (26)

Reading 8

4 Pages
Unlock Document

PSYC 341
Richard Koestner

The Critical Period Hypothesis: Where Are We Now? Harley and Wang The Critical Period Concept • Period of time during the life cycle when there is greater sensitivity to certain stimuli than at other times • Ex: filial imprinting in birds. Limited period after hatching, goslings become irreversibly attached to the first moving object they see • ‘Sensitive period’ now used instead of ‘critical period’, pointing to the more gradual nature of development • Colombo says a critical period must have: o An onset o A terminus o An intrinsic (maturational) component o An extrinsic component in the shape of a stimulus to which the organism is sensitive o A system that is affected by stimulation during the critical period • Ultimate and proximate causes of critical period phenomena: o Ultimate causes have to do with the functions and benefits of the critical period o Proximate causes are concerned with the mechanisms that regulate the growth and decline of sensitivity. Lenneberg’s Critical Period Hypothesis • The onset: marked by a peculiar, language-specific maturational schedule nd rd consisting of gradual unfolding of capacities between the 2 and 3 years of life. Lack of language before 2 due to cerebral immaturity, rather than immaturity of vocal tract. • The terminus: age 13, or puberty. See a rapid decline in language acquisition capabilities, coinciding with the completion of lateralization of language function nd to the dominant left cerebral hemisphere. 2 language learning becomes different, less natural than learning a language during the critical period. Adults are able to learn a 2 language because languages resemble one another, and a cerebral matrix for language skills exists. • The intrinsic component: the child is endowed from the outset with an innate mechanism dedicated to language. Argued for understanding neurological correlates of language in terms of the way many parts of the brain interact, not specific brain structures. • The extrinsic component: recognized that environmental influences on language acquisition were undeniable, but wasn’t interested in elaborating on this aspect. • The affected system: referred mostly to ‘language’ without specifying what particular aspects (e.g. phonology, syntax). Emphasized capability in contrast to behaviour (similar to Chomsky’s competence compared to actual performance • Ultimate causes: human language is a social adaptation contributing to the survival of the species. Variation at the surface structure level of language is permissible, but very little tolerance for abnormality in the deep structure. The Empirical Evidence • One argument is that there is no particular maturational stage where language acquisition emerges, but the process begins at birth and continues on throughout life. • There is tentative support from speech perception research for some kind of innate mechanism for language acquisition. Whether operational from birth or emerges during infancy is unclear. • When exposure to language is substantially delayed, ultimate attainment is irregular and incomplete. Cannot compensate for initial deprivation. • Congenitally deaf adults exposed to ASL at different ages: clear age-related effect for morphology, native-learners outscoring early learners, early learners outscoring late learners. • Later second language learning of ASL was enhanced by having previously had full access to a first language, but also native language experience in infancy/early childhood was still better than second language learning later on • Rate-of-acquisition studies have shown adults and adolescents generally making faster initial progress than children, older children progressing faster than younger children. These advantages can be short-lived, and little to no difference seen between adjacent age groups. nd • Studies of long-term attainment ind2 language pronunciation indicate the younger the age of arrival in a 2 language environment, the better the pronunciation will be. Age of arrival in the environment is key predictor, rather than length of residence (which is important only for the first few months after
More Less

Related notes for PSYC 341

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.