PHILOS 2CT3 Study Guide - Midterm Guide: Modus Ponens, If And Only If, Modus Tollens
8 May 2018
School
Department
Course
Professor
1
!"#$%&'()*+','*-&*'(','.-/#-0''
1)#This%review%is%intended%to%direct%your%study%of%the%text%and%lectures%and%not%replace%
such%study.%2)#Only%material%on%this%exam%guide%may%appear%on%the%test.#3)#The%exam%
itself%will%consist%of%15%multiple<choice%questions%and%2%short<answer%questions%and%will%
take%place%in#class,%Wednesday#November#151'
234564'
)$7#8'9'3'4:3:;<;=:'344;>:5=?'3'@A45:5A='A='4A<;'<3::;>#
•E.g.#It’s%cold%out;%Politicians%are%incapable%of%uttering%the%truth,%etc.%#
!$-')$7#8&'9'A=;'4BCD;6:E@>;F563:;'4:3:;<;=:':G3:'63=H:'C;'IB>:G;>'
F5J5F;F#
•&BCD;6:#=#what#a#statement#is#about##
•!>;F563:;#=#something#being#af8irmed#or#denied#about#a#subject#
)%8!$-K')$7#8&'9'6A<@A4;F'AI':LA'A>'<A>;'4:3:;<;=:4'MA?563MMN'6A==;6:;F#
•E.g.#Because%it%is%winter,%it%is%likely%cold%outside;%since%political%speech%is%
intentionally%ambiguous,%politicians%are%incapable%of%uttering%the%truth,%
etc.#
O>AB=F'.BM;4P''
1) 25J3M;=6;P'a#statement#can#only#have#one#truth#value%>#either#humans#are#
mortal#or#they#are#not#mortal#
2) -Q6MBF;F'85FFM;P#either#a#proposition#is#true#or#its#negation#is#true,#but#not#
both#>#either#humans#are#mortal#is%true,#or#humans#are#not#mortal#is%true,#but#
not#both#
•*.R*"')%ST#*#%S&'9':G;'content'AI'6M35<4'3=F':G;'connections'
C;:L;;=':G;<':G3:'6A=4:>B6:':G;'C3454'A='LG56G'L;'DBF?;'4:3:;<;=:4':A'
C;':>B;'A>'I3M4;#
$A?563M'%@;>3:A>4'!'6A==;6:5A=4'C;:L;;='@>;<54;4':G3:'F;:;><5=;':G;':>B:G'
J3MB;'AI'3'6M35<'
1. )A=DB=6:5A='U'and#(both#this#and#that)#
2. T54DB=6:5A='U'or#(either#this#or#that)#
3. )A=F5:5A=3M'>'if#(this#if#that)#
4. 256A=F5:5A=3M'>'if#and#only#if#(this#if%that%and%only#that)#
5. S;?3:5A='>'not#(not%this)#
7>?B<;=:'V'-Q@M3=3:5A=''
2
•7=';Q@M3=3:5A='@>AJ5F;4'>;34A=4'F;<A=4:>3:5=?'LGN'4A<;:G5=?'54':G;'
634;W'CB:'FA;4'=A:';4:3CM54G':G;'truth'AI':G;'634;'34'3='3>?B<;=:'FA;4#
7>?B<;=:4'
•7'!.-8#&-#54'3'6M35<'A>'@>A@A45:5A=':G3:';4:3CM54G':G;'>;34A=X4Y'IA>'
366;@:5=?'3'6A=6MB45A='!'Premise%Indicators:#Since,#given#that,#because,#
insofar#as,#in#that,#due#to#the#fact,#etc.#
•7')%S)$R&#%S'54':G;'<35='6M35<':G3:'54';4:3CM54G;F'CN'3='3>?B<;=:'!'
Conclusion%Indicators:#therefore,#hence,#thus,#consequently,#it#follows#that,#etc.#
T;FB6:5A='9'3'IA><'AI'>;34A=5=?'LG;>;':G;'6A=6MB45A='=;6;443>5MN'IAMMAL4'
I>A<':G;'IA><3:5A='AI':G;'@>;<54;4'
•/7$#T'9'iff#5:'54'5<@A445CM;'IA>':G;'6A=6MB45A='=A:':A'IAMMAL'I>A<':G;'
>;M3:5A='AI':G;'@>;<54;4'>'deductive#validity#
•&%RST'9'iff#:G;'4:>B6:B>;'AI':G;'3>?B<;=:'54'J3M5F'and':G;'@>;<54;4'AB:'
AI'LG56G'5:'54'6A=4:>B6:;F'are#true'>'deductively#sound'#
#=FB6:5A='9'3'IA><'AI'>;34A=5=?'LG;>;':G;'6A=6MB45A='IAMMAL4'L5:G'?>;3:;>'A>'
M;44;>'probability#A>'likelihood#!#Inductive%arguments%are%judged%on%the%relative%
ability%of%the%premises%to%support%the%conclusion:#WEAK#or#STRONG#
Conditional#claims:#the#truth#of#one#claim#depends#on#the#truth#of#another#
•Antecedent:#the%claim%that%is%depended%upon#
•Consequent:#the%claim%depending%on%another#
S;6;443>N')A=F5:5A='U#that#in#the#absence#of#which#something#cannot#be#the#
case#
•Antecedent#‘if%this’#–#Consequent#‘then%that’;#the#consequent#is#the#
“necessary%condition%for%the%antecedent”#(23).##Why?#
•Because#the#consequent#determines#what#is#minimally#needed#for#the#
antecedent#to#be#true#>#!'63='C;':>B;'5I'Z'54'=A:'I3M4;#
&BI[565;=:')A=F5:5A='U'that#in#the#presence#of#which#something#must#be#the#case#
•Antecedent#‘if%this’#–#Consequent#‘then%that’;#the#antecedent#is#the#
suf8icient#condition#for#the#consequent.##Why?#
•Because#the#antecedent#determines#what#is#enough%for#the#consequent#
to#be#true#>##I'!'54':>B;':G;='Z'54':>B;#
Arguments#from#analogy#draw#comparisons#about#relevant#similarities#between#
different#cases#
