Study Guides (247,998)
Canada (121,216)
LAW 122 (330)
Midterm

MIDTERM Sheet #6.docx

4 Pages
125 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Law and Business
Course
LAW 122
Professor
Sari Graben
Semester
Winter

Description
Chapter 6: Negligence • Negligence: the most common tort. • Negligence in business context. • Flexible balancing of social values:  Compensation for carelessly caused harm  Encouragement of socially useful activities o Flexibility arises at each stage of analysis. Elements • For a plaintiff to bring a successful negligence action, the plaintiff must prove that: o the defendant owed a duty of care to the plaintiff o the defendant breached the standard of care o the breach caused the plaintiff’s damage. • The defendant may prove: o defences 4 elements a plaintiff has to prove: • owe a duty of care • Plaintiff suffered a loss. • Causation • Damage Duty of Care (pg 130) • An obligation to use reasonable care to avoid harm to plaintiff. • You must take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions which you can reasonably foresee would be likely to injure your neighbor (Donoghue v. Stevenson). • Criteria for duty of care: o Reasonable foreseeability: Was it reasonably foreseeable that the plaintiff could be injured by the defendant’s carelessness? o Proximity: Did the parties have a relationship of sufficient proximity? o Policy: Are there any social policy reasons to deny liability? (E.g. pg 131) • Mother has no duty of care to her unborn child. • Father has duty of care to protect unborn child. Reasonable Foreseeability (pg 132) • This is an objective test o Would reasonable person have foreseen risk of loss? • Not whether the defendant personally foresaw the risk, but whether a reasonable person in defendant’s position would foresee. Proximity (pg 133) • Is there a close and direct connection between the parties? • Proximity may arise in various ways: o Physical o Social o Commercial o Causal o Reliance Professional Liability (pg 133) • Importance increases as information and advice become our economic driver more than more historic goods production. • Rules for careless statements as opposed to careless actions may be more complicated. • Hercules case is very important in establishing guidance for finding a duty of care where there is economic loss. Hercules case (Supreme Court of Canada, 1997) pg. 134 • Court stated that duty of care is more likely if: o Defendant possesses special knowledge, i.e. expertise; o Statement made in a business (not social) setting; o Statement made in response to inquiry; o Defendant received financial benefit in exchange for the statement; o Statement of fact (or opinion based on fact) rather than purely personal opinion. • Liability is less likely if: o Statement accompanied by disclaimer. • Although the facts of the case satisfied these criteria, the Court was concerned about indeterminate liability which would cause the price of services to rise unduly. • The Court found no liability because the plaintiff, as a shareholder used the statement as investment advice, rather than to assess the management of the company. • The Court stated that a duty of care for careless statements causing economic loss would be recognized only if: o The defendant knew that the plaintiff might rely on the statement, o And the plaintiff relied on the statement for its intended purpose. Policy Considerations (pg 135) • Hercules case is a good example of the court’s use of public policy to limit liability. • Policy = overriding considerations (legal, social, political concerns). • Effect of policy: even if reasonable foreseeability, even if close proximity, duty of care rejected for external reasons. • Many professions are regulated by regulatory bodies, e.g. Law Society. • Is a case against a regulatory body l
More Less

Related notes for LAW 122

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit