Study Guides (256,350)
CA (124,628)
UTM (5,120)
SOC (753)
SOC100H5 (138)
Final

Final Test Notes (chs. 14, 12, 11)

19 Pages
141 Views

Department
Sociology
Course Code
SOC100H5
Professor
Barry Green

This preview shows pages 1-3. Sign up to view the full 19 pages of the document.
Chapter 14 - Max Weber
Max Weber - a historian, sociologist, and philosopher who left an indelible mark on the
philosophy of history and on social science methodology. He lived in Germany.
Observed the outbreak of WWI. He experienced long periods of severe
depression.
-He argued strongly against the any simplified analyses or unitary theories of
social change, emphasizing instead the complex multi causality and inherently
probabilistic character of all theories of human action.
human action - the outcome of free will, and such freedom can never be
described through fixed relations of cause and effect
Weber’s Scholarship
-struggled to synthesize the very different intellectual traditions that were prevalent in
Europe at the time
idealism - emphasis on ideas and values as the distinctive moving force of
human history
historical materialism - contended that class conflict was the driving force of
history and the primary determinant of human fate
positivists - sought to apply the methods of the natural sciences to the study of
human behaviour, seeking predictive or deterministic laws of action
-Weber tried to reconcile the commitment to notions of individual freedom and religious
values with the apparently contradictory commitment to scientific study of human
behaviour and to an emphasis on economic materialism in history
-He tried also to reconcile the obvious commitment of all researchers to political goals
and values with the demand of objectivity in social science research
-He tried to reconcile the objective of democracy, with its commitment to representative
government based upon participation of an informed population and the mechanism of
bureaucracy
bureaucracy - seemed essential to democracy and yet at the same time was its
greatest threat. It is the mark of Weber’s brilliance that he was largely able to achieve
these syntheses in his work
Weber’s Methodological Contribution
-he sought out to synthesize the objective, empirical methods of the natural sciences
with the intuitive aspects of the humanities
nomothetic - law-like
-our actions determined not only by objective conditions and forces but by the
subjective meanings that we attach to our actions
-he also wanted to avoid the trap of idealism
-actions are not determined by outside forces and so are not predictable
-he argues meaningful behaviour is not unique and unpredictable or without any pattern
or order.
-he argues there is no real contradiction between free will and determinism
www.notesolution.com
-he defines sociology as “the sciences which attempts the interpretive understanding of
social action in order thereby to arrive at a causal explanation of its cause and effects”
-sociological analysis must do two things: explore the meaning of actions for the people
involved and show how this meaning provides a causal explanation for the behaviour
social action - any human conduct that is meaningfully oriented to the past,
present, or future expected behaviour of others
-people do what they do because it is meaningful to them
-Verstehen involves putting ourselves in the position of the people we are studying and
trying to reconstruct the interpretations that they might give to their own action
-Weber is well aware that human motives may require much deeper searching and that
human motives are complex
-he argues that explanations in sociology must take the form of probabilities rather than
the absolute predictions characteristic of the natural sciences
-his model of typical characteristics of Calvinist values in contrast with typical Catholic
values, makes possible broad generalizations about the relationship between religious
ethnics and business practices in Europe of that period
-he argues that functionalism is useful and indispensable in providing a place from
which to begin analysis, but sociologists need to go beyond functional uniformities
-society is converted into a thing and then is used in explanations as if it were an acting
unit with its own consciousness: society does such and such, or society has certain
needs etc
-he rejects the opposite extreme of psychological reductionism (the attempt the explain
collective social processes by reference only to the psychological processes within the
individuals involved
-he draws a careful distinction between the related disciplines of sociology and history
history - concerned with the causal analysis of particular culturally significant
events and personalities
sociology - deals with the observation and explanation of general patterns of
behaviour
causal pluralism - on searching for multiple causes for social phenomena
-it is through subjective understanding and analysis that these objective conditions
come to influence human actions as they do
-he advocated ideal-type constructs as a method of inquiry that would be adequate at
the level of meaning or interpretive understanding of actions and would at the same
time make possible objective and replicable analysis
ideal-type model - theoretical model that is designed to highlight the typical
characteristics of the kind of social organization being studied
Objectivity in Social Science
-Weber analyzed the struggle for revolutionary socialism in these terms:
-the goals of freedom that are part of the ideal and socialism are threatened by
the use of force as a means of achieve socialism and by the political repression
ineveitably associated with the use of force
www.notesolution.com
-predicted that the consequences of trying to establish a socialist economy
within a largely hostile capitalist world would result in multiple difficulties that
would undermine the practice of socialism
-the most important - he predicted that whatever means were used to bring
about socialism, the ideals of socialism would be compromised by the
organizational means needed to co-ordinate such a society, namely the
bureaucratic state
- Weber distinguishes between 2 fundamental ethics to address these ethical dilemmas:
ethic of ultimate ends - a term used by Weber to refer to morality based on
obedience to religious doctrine or to what is perceived as the will of God, or some
absolute value, regardless of the consquences
ethic of responsibility - For Weber, moral principles that take account of the
probable consequences of actions
-neither ethic is in and of itself morally superior to the other. The ethic of ultimate ends
is essentially religious.
-those who accept the ethic of responsibility must take account of the consequences of
their actions or means chosen to further their goals
Weber’s Substantive Contribution - Types of Action Orientation
-his model of types of action orientation outlines 4 basic kinds of meaningful action or
typical orientations that individuals may adopt in relations with each other
(1)traditional-rational behaviour - the simplest, comprises action based on habit, least
amount of conscious, traditional-rational actions are always done that way
(2)affective-rationality - based on emotions, actions expressions of emotions, passions,
and immediacy that involves neither calculated weighing of means or consequences nor
commitment to values
(3) value-rational - focus upon an overriding ideal, deeply committed people do not ask
the consequences of their actions. Do what they believe is right, underlies the ethic of
ultimate ends
(4)purposive-rational action - most important, rational selection among alternative
means of action, rational consideration of consequences in relation to other goals,
easiest to understand and analyze, basic assumption of theory in economics
-this serves to guide research into the meaning of action from the perspective of the
participants’ own view of that action
Model of Authority
-he uses this typology as a basis for his subsequent model of legitimacy of political
authority
-distinction between power that is based on authority and power based on brute force
-authority is legitimate in that the subordinates themselves accept that those in
authority in practice as the probability that a given order will be obeyed by a specific
group of people. Three bases of authority:
-traditional - simplest and historically most prevalent basis for authority is
tradition, inherited status, stable and unchanging societies
www.notesolution.com

Loved by over 2.2 million students

Over 90% improved by at least one letter grade.

Leah — University of Toronto

OneClass has been such a huge help in my studies at UofT especially since I am a transfer student. OneClass is the study buddy I never had before and definitely gives me the extra push to get from a B to an A!

Leah — University of Toronto
Saarim — University of Michigan

Balancing social life With academics can be difficult, that is why I'm so glad that OneClass is out there where I can find the top notes for all of my classes. Now I can be the all-star student I want to be.

Saarim — University of Michigan
Jenna — University of Wisconsin

As a college student living on a college budget, I love how easy it is to earn gift cards just by submitting my notes.

Jenna — University of Wisconsin
Anne — University of California

OneClass has allowed me to catch up with my most difficult course! #lifesaver

Anne — University of California
Description
Chapter 14 - Max Weber Max Weber - a historian, sociologist, and philosopher who left an indelible mark on the philosophy of history and on social science methodology. He lived in Germany. Observed the outbreak of WWI. He experienced long periods of severe depression. - He argued strongly against the any simplified analyses or unitary theories of social change, emphasizing instead the complex multi causality and inherently probabilistic character of all theories of human action. human action - the outcome of free will, and such freedom can never be described through fixed relations of cause and effect Webers Scholarship - struggled to synthesize the very different intellectual traditions that were prevalent in Europe at the time idealism - emphasis on ideas and values as the distinctive moving force of human history historical materialism - contended that class conflict was the driving force of history and the primary determinant of human fate positivists - sought to apply the methods of the natural sciences to the study of human behaviour, seeking predictive or deterministic laws of action - Weber tried to reconcile the commitment to notions of individual freedom and religious values with the apparently contradictory commitment to scientific study of human behaviour and to an emphasis on economic materialism in history - He tried also to reconcile the obvious commitment of all researchers to political goals and values with the demand of objectivity in social science research - He tried to reconcile the objective of democracy, with its commitment to representative government based upon participation of an informed population and the mechanism of bureaucracy bureaucracy - seemed essential to democracy and yet at the same time was its greatest threat. It is the mark of Webers brilliance that he was largely able to achieve these syntheses in his work Webers Methodological Contribution - he sought out to synthesize the objective, empirical methods of the natural sciences with the intuitive aspects of the humanities nomothetic - law-like - our actions determined not only by objective conditions and forces but by the subjective meanings that we attach to our actions - he also wanted to avoid the trap of idealism - actions are not determined by outside forces and so are not predictable - he argues meaningful behaviour is not unique and unpredictable or without any pattern or order. - he argues there is no real contradiction between free will and determinism www.notesolution.com- he defines sociology as the sciences which attempts the interpretive understanding of social action in order thereby to arrive at a causal explanation of its cause and effects - sociological analysis must do two things: explore the meaning of actions for the people involved and show how this meaning provides a causal explanation for the behaviour social action - any human conduct that is meaningfully oriented to the past, present, or future expected behaviour of others - people do what they do because it is meaningful to them - Verstehen involves putting ourselves in the position of the people we are studying and trying to reconstruct the interpretations that they might give to their own action - Weber is well aware that human motives may require much deeper searching and that human motives are complex - he argues that explanations in sociology must take the form of probabilities rather than the absolute predictions characteristic of the natural sciences - his model of typical characteristics of Calvinist values in contrast with typical Catholic values, makes possible broad generalizations about the relationship between religious ethnics and business practices in Europe of that period - he argues that functionalism is useful and indispensable in providing a place from which to begin analysis, but sociologists need to go beyond functional uniformities - society is converted into a thing and then is used in explanations as if it were an acting unit with its own consciousness: society does such and such, or society has certain needs etc - he rejects the opposite extreme of psychological reductionism (the attempt the explain collective social processes by reference only to the psychological processes within the individuals involved - he draws a careful distinction between the related disciplines of sociology and history history - concerned with the causal analysis of particular culturally significant events and personalities sociology - deals with the observation and explanation of general patterns of behaviour causal pluralism - on searching for multiple causes for social phenomena - it is through subjective understanding and analysis that these objective conditions come to influence human actions as they do - he advocated ideal-type constructs as a method of inquiry that would be adequate at the level of meaning or interpretive understanding of actions and would at the same time make possible objective and replicable analysis ideal-type model - theoretical model that is designed to highlight the typical characteristics of the kind of social organization being studied Objectivity in Social Science - Weber analyzed the struggle for revolutionary socialism in these terms: - the goals of freedom that are part of the ideal and socialism are threatened by the use of force as a means of achieve socialism and by the political repression ineveitably associated with the use of force www.notesolution.com
More Less
Unlock Document


Only pages 1-3 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

Unlock Document
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version

Unlock Document

Log In


OR

Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit