Sacred Healing and Biomedicine Compared notes.docx

3 Pages
Unlock Document


Sacred Healing and Biomedicine Compared  Analysis of the similarities and differences between sacred healing and biomedicine along several important dimensions that bear on the differential effects of patients’ experiences of their treatment.  Looking into these differences shows the medical regimes that are embedded in different systems of knowledge. This reveals strengths and weaknesses of each. The analysis  This analysis demonstrates the dramaturgical nature of biomedicine-patient encounter with its inherent underlying contradictions whereas in the sacred healer-patient, the drama is lacking Introduction  In this article, two systems of healing are compared—Spirtualist and biomedical (practices in Mexico)  Comparison addresses several dimensions such as: physical setting, etiological concepts, diagnoses, the practioner-patient relationship, recruitment into the healing role, and the treatment repertoires, as well as issues relevant to the patients’ perceptions of their bodies and their existences.  Spiritualism is both a dissident religious movement and a health care delivery system.  Spiritualisim provides its followers with a clearly defined cosmology, ethics, and liturgical order, transmitted orally to its adherents through a medium in trance during weekly rituals consisting chiefly of sermons.  The majority of those coming to Spiritualist temples for the first time seek treatment from the healers for self-assessed, non-grave ailments.  Spirtualist healing reveals that Spiritualism and biomedicine diverge along many dimensions. Spiritualism is embedded in a sacred world while biomedicine is sanctioned by secular science.  Spiritualist healers are folk practioners (lacking academic training and state legitimation)  The two systems of healing may have developed in Mexico during the same historical period the, they are rooted in disparate realties and distinct epistemologies. Nevertheless, they become unified in day to day life by the people who resort to them, a phenomenon that has been recognized cross-culturally  People don’t judge on which regime is better. What they search for is the alleviation of pain, pragmatism prevails. People judge treatments they are given by their effects,  During her research, she found that patients seeking treatment from Spiritualist healers usually did so after unsuccessful treatment by several physicians.  Healers are usually women. Healers minister to the sick through spirit protectors who possess their bodies when they enter a trance.  Spiritualist healers do not provide the patient with a definitive diagnosis, and when they do, it usually consists of informing the person either that he or she possesses a gift that requires cultivation or that the person is possessed by an obscure spirit that requires extrication.  Similarties: Both biomedicine and spiritualism focus on the body (bodily discomforts). Both adhere to a dualistic view of the body and its attendant disturbances (Spiritualism clearly distinguish between the “material” and “spiritual” like how biomedicine distinguished between body and mind). Both are structural in their encounters with patients (in both, the patient takes the role of a passive recipient of the practioner’s ministrations and in both regimes the practioner requires the patients compliance). Both try to peer inside the body (physician use technoligcal apparatuses and spiritualist gazes into spirits)  Differences: Physical settingsThe healing experience is communal. Healers sit in one room, receiving patients separately. This is a collective experience. Physicians heal people in a cubicle(isolated). The relatively private surroundings of biomedical consultations reflect the individualist cast of biomedicine. Mimics western industrialized societys emphasis on privacy and individualism (Since Mexico adopted biomedicine from the western civilization)  Differences: Etiological Beliefs and Diagnoses Common pool of etiological beliefs in Mexic
More Less

Related notes for ANTC61H3

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.