media text notes 1-6.docx

11 Pages
Unlock Document

University of Toronto Scarborough
Media Studies
Ted Petit

CHAPTER 4 PRAGMATIC ANALYSIS Pragmatic approach to government regulation of the media - Consequences and contingencies o Consequences  Clear effects of a given regulation on society  Must be beneficialhum  Reflects the pragmatic focus on the tangible results of a belief that measures the truth o Contingencies  Factors that should address the result of a specific situation  Contingent factors that influence possible types of regulation o Social norms o Predominant mediums o All types of technology present o American media must respond to particular set of regular or contingencies unique to the American context  Government regulation must always respond to these particular factors.  Best regulations balance them o Set of regular contingencies  TENSION  Free speech vs. public interest  GOVERNMENT REGULATION AND MEDIA SELF REGUALTION Issues in the regulation of the American media (regulating media ownership) - Six themes in how to critically respond to the regulation of media from a pragmatic stance 1. Combating monopoly  Anti-monopoly regulation  Financial interest and syndication rules o Fear that three companies NBC ABC CBS (moving towards vertical integration) were gaining too much power so passed this fin-syn rules to correct this trend o Purpose was to break up perceived monopoly of the major networks by limiting the networks financial control over their programming o Syndication: process of producing and selling programming o They relaxed the fin-syn rules to allow cable companies to lease more channels to the viewers. This shows the deregulation, and increased self-media regulation. 2. Protecting intellectual property  Copyright  Granting exclusive control of a creative work to that work’s creator o Limited however  Small portions of work can be copied under the notion of fair use  Fair dealing vs. fair use o  Can only cover material expression of the idea not the idea itself  Digital rights management  Any number of diff software programs that media industries employ to control the distribution and use of intellectual property o These actually protect private corporate interests 3. Maintaining natural interests  Encryption  Scrambling important digital messages by software so only those who possess a complementary decoding program can read them  BALANCE: between a persons right to privacy and the governments ability to monitor hostile foreign governments, terrorists and criminals o However had to backlash it because of invasion of privacy  This pragmatic encryption thing was a failure because it failed to review the contingencies of the Americans right to privacy. 4. Promoting diversity  These regulations implement diversity because most of the people who own the media are wealthy privileged social groups and they have the most access to it  By integrating minority viewpoints and perspectives find a place on TV and radio this is regulating it  Example the fairness doctrine  Decreased amount of cultural controversial material on the air  This also dictated what material they had to cover and some felt it was a violation of the first amendment  Clear negative consequences o Reduced the amount of controversial issues on air and trampled over the contingency of free speech by stipulating content  Example equal time rule  Clearly outlines how stations must handle the broadcast of political advertisements for primary or general elections  Stations must charge all advertisers equally  Negative o No negative o Represents a flexible system of encouraging equality without specifying or restricting content 5. Managing mortality  Regulations concentrated on the management of mortality in the media  One cannot legislate morality without endangering free speech o Therefore they offer guidelines rather than definite understandings of issues related to mortality o Restrict access and consumption of questionable tests rather than their production o Three main types of regulated media content are  Obscenity  Obscene media content sexually explicit in nature  Content is considered obscene when it meets the following standards o The avg person applying contemporary community standards would find that the work taken as a whole appeals to prurient interest o The work depicts or describes in an offensive way, sexual conduct specifically defined by applicable state of law o The work as a whole lacks serious literary artistic political or scientifically value  Regulation of this is straight forward its illegal  The are not obscene until someone challenges it in the court of law  This way its informal  Indecency  Any material that is morally unfit for general distribution.  Often depicts sexual or excremental activities  Not illegal  Profanity  7 filthy words; shit piss fuck cunt cocksucker motherfucker ad tits  Foul language  Instead of censoring everything they created the rating system pg g pg- 13 r nc-17 o Maintains freedom of speech  Pragmatic perspective the regulation of mortality is more contigeient on socio-historical factors than any other form of regulation  in a pragmatic perspective the rating system is ill-conceived forms of regulation 6. Ensuring accuracy  Regulations concentrated on ensuring that journalists and new reporters use media forms of government to responsibly report the truth to the American public  Two forms  Slander: publicly spoken untrue defamatory statements  Libel: written statements which are defamatory o Both not protected under freedom of speech o If statement is true and is still damaging to a person reputation it is neither slander nor libel.  Media is allowed to comment on public figures under doctrine of fair comment  You can be defamatory under this without being charged libel  Code of ethics: self-imposed set of rules that outlines ethical strivings of a media outlet.  Explains how a media should handle conflict of interests, ethical dilemmas and other problems Violence in the media - Types of violence in media o Historical violence  The portrayal of actual historical events seen in films  Allows audience to think critically about the ay violence is connected to hatred and social injustice  This heightens social consciousness  Philosophical meanings about humanity and struggles o Ritualistic violence  Generates emotional excitement  Pure spectacle in form of superficial content  This serves the sole purpose of entertainment no educational purpose o Hyper-real violence  Blurs the boundaries between ritualistic violence and historical violence  Marked by technological over-simulation gritty dialogue dramatic story telling parody etc.  Extremely realistic and believable  Combines the look of historical violence with the feeling of ritualistic violence - Consequence of media violence o Aggressor effect: exposure to violence triggers arousal and promotes aggressive behavior  Three theories  Dis-inhibition o Consumption of media violence undermines social norms and sanctions against violence that individuals would otherwise abide by  Enculturation o Speculates that long term exposure constructs violence as norm and thereby encourages aggressive behaviors o Violence is an acceptable response in certain life situations  Imitation o Audience will mimic aggressive media o But there are different forms of media violence which does not take into account of, their contingencies o Victim effect  People develop a fear of violence  Individuals who consume heavy amount of violence undergo mainstreaming and they begin to actually think that things they see in the media will really happen  Exaggerated sense of danger o Bystander effect  Media violence fosters increased callousness and insensitivity towards violence directed at others  Desensitization is a cause. Reduction of emotional responses to violence which increases acceptance of violence o Catharsis effect  Reduce alleviate feelings of aggression  Pro social outcome  Reduction of real world violence CHAPTER 5 RHETORIC ANALYSIS - Media entertains and persuades us - Rhetoric: ancient art of oratory o Ability to see the available means of persuasion - All messages and symbolic creations are biased - Theories of the sign o Sign: something that invites someone to think of something other than itself o Shared meanings what makes human communication possible o No sign is interpreted the same way by a person - Ferdidnad de sassure o Founder of modern linguistics o His approach  Linguistics semiology: a science, which studies the roles of signs as a part of social life. Investigate nature of signs and laws that govern them o All linguistic signs are combo of signified and signifier  Signifier: sound or image refers to material form of a sign as perceived by the senses such as the word dog  Signified: a mental concept, is the idea evoked by the signifier  Together they construct a sign o Linguistic signs have two defining traits  Arbitrar
More Less

Related notes for MDSA01H3

Log In


Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.