Study Guides (256,486)
CA (124,666)
UTSC (8,077)
POLB80H3 (38)

study guide

4 Pages
118 Views

Department
Political Science
Course Code
POLB80H3
Professor
Yvonne Ramcharan

This preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full 4 pages of the document.
Capitalism vs Socialism: History and Predictions.
In Western Democracies there has always been a stigma about Socialism. Far too often it is
associated with Communism and the ideals behind it often disregarded before they are even
considered. In contrast, Capitalism has always been the blessed child of Democracy and Liberalism
and due to its promise of individual success it has always been accepted with wide open embraces.
Both Capitalism and Socialism are not just economic systems but they reflect ideologies of the people
they represent. Throughout history we have been plagued by various economic and natural disasters
and each of these two systems has been affected. Both systems have dealt with different crises in
their own way, and it would make in interesting comparison how each situation was dealt with. This of
course refers to the fall of the Stock Market in 1929 and the Ukrainian famine. In order to successfully
compare and analyze these two systems one has to do it from a perspective of someone who has
lived in both systems. It is fairly easy to theorize and analyze, but one has to be affected by both
systems, both physically and intellectually, to judge and predict on the topic at hand. Both systems
have their advantages, while Socialism has many advocates among scholars, intellectuals and
academics, Capitalism also has many supporters. Some of these supporters are entrepreneurs,
leaders and intellectuals as well. What separate us from animals are our values and our morals. We
are a society driven by excess, individual success and ultimately greed, we have swapped our values
for personal gain and this is a result of, mostly, Capitalist ideals. Socialism on the other hand is a
system driven by equality and although morally sound it is very unstable once put into practice. In
order to support this more needs to be said on each and one must come to a conclusion from the
information provided.
Socialism as a movement arose somewhere between 1825 and 1850. It was a response to
remarkable changes brought on by the Industrial Revolution. The Industrial Revolution was an
extreme change in the life of a common worker in Britain. Britain as a Society was mostly agricultural
and somewhere between mid 18th and 19th century this changed. The number of factories suddenly
rose in urban Britain and as the demand for jobs was raised, more people moved away from the rural
areas. Technological advances directly influenced the Industrial rise; an example could be the
invention of steam power. Steam power paved the way for the rail and that in turn sped up the
transportation of goods, which in turn expanded the industry. This sudden change brought on a new
class of people. These people who had been up till then agricultural workers were now living in an
urban area and had nothing to live off except their labor. This sudden exodus of people from the rural
areas forced some families, which were living in same villages, to now crowd themselves in shacks,
which were built in slums. Very quickly the situation in the cities became dire. The cities became crime
havens, diseases reached epidemic levels and poverty among the working class was a fact. Socialism
was a response to these effects of Industrialization. Three main influences contributed to socialism:
the ideas of Robert Owen, the development of trade unions, and Chartism. These three movements
contributed to the rise of Socialism as a response to Capitalism, but the writings of Karl Marx and
Friedrich Engels were fundamental in establishing Socialism as a movement. Although their ideas
have been changed and argued for over a century, they represent the basis of Socialist thought. One
should keep in mind that not all Socialists are Marxists, Karl Marx presented a more extreme view of
what Socialism should be. Marx believed Socialism would eventually bring about the fall of
governments. He wrote that governments represent the means by which a dominant class exploits
another class. Marx also believed that competition for profit would mean that fewer and fewer people
would control the means of production and that an increasing number of people would be exploited.
The system (Capitalist) would in addition withhold resources, which would in turn bring on poverty.
This would eventually lead to revolution of the "proletariat" (Karl Marx). The working class would take
over the production until all needs have been satisfied and this would bring on the fall of the
government. Although the theory Marx predicted has not been fulfilled, some of his ideas influenced
non-Marxist Socialism. Compared to non-Marxist Socialism this may be viewed as revolutionary,
because the change would be sudden and extreme. Most Socialists believe that change is necessary
but should be done legally. This change should, for example, be done through proper channels, like
the parliament, and should not be forced upon the people if they do not wish so. History cannot
provide us with successful Socialist states, but learning how the biggest Socialist economies failed
can teach us what needs to be done to do it successfully the next time. Russia was the first state to be
www.notesolution.com

Loved by over 2.2 million students

Over 90% improved by at least one letter grade.

Leah — University of Toronto

OneClass has been such a huge help in my studies at UofT especially since I am a transfer student. OneClass is the study buddy I never had before and definitely gives me the extra push to get from a B to an A!

Leah — University of Toronto
Saarim — University of Michigan

Balancing social life With academics can be difficult, that is why I'm so glad that OneClass is out there where I can find the top notes for all of my classes. Now I can be the all-star student I want to be.

Saarim — University of Michigan
Jenna — University of Wisconsin

As a college student living on a college budget, I love how easy it is to earn gift cards just by submitting my notes.

Jenna — University of Wisconsin
Anne — University of California

OneClass has allowed me to catch up with my most difficult course! #lifesaver

Anne — University of California
Description
Capitalism vs Socialism: History and Predictions. In Western Democracies there has always been a stigma about Socialism. Far too often it is associated with Communism and the ideals behind it often disregarded before they are even considered. In contrast, Capitalism has always been the blessed child of Democracy and Liberalism and due to its promise of individual success it has always been accepted with wide open embraces. Both Capitalism and Socialism are not just economic systems but they reflect ideologies of the people they represent. Throughout history we have been plagued by various economic and natural disasters and each of these two systems has been affected. Both systems have dealt with different crises in their own way, and it would make in interesting comparison how each situation was dealt with. This of course refers to the fall of the Stock Market in 1929 and the Ukrainian famine. In order to successfully compare and analyze these two systems one has to do it from a perspective of someone who has lived in both systems. It is fairly easy to theorize and analyze, but one has to be affected by both systems, both physically and intellectually, to judge and predict on the topic at hand. Both systems have their advantages, while Socialism has many advocates among scholars, intellectuals and academics, Capitalism also has many supporters. Some of these supporters are entrepreneurs, leaders and intellectuals as well. What separate us from animals are our values and our morals. We are a society driven by excess, individual success and ultimately greed, we have swapped our values for personal gain and this is a result of, mostly, Capitalist ideals. Socialism on the other hand is a system driven by equality and although morally sound it is very unstable once put into practice. In order to support this more needs to be said on each and one must come to a conclusion from the information provided. Socialism as a movement arose somewhere between 1825 and 1850. It was a response to remarkable changes brought on by the Industrial Revolution. The Industrial Revolution was an extreme change in the life of a common worker in Britain. Britain as a Society was mostly agricultural and somewhere between mid 18th and 19th century this changed. The number of factories suddenly rose in urban Britain and as the demand for jobs was raised, more people moved away from the rural areas. Technological advances directly influenced the Industrial rise; an example could be the invention of steam power. Steam power paved the way for the rail and that in turn sped up the transportation of goods, which in turn expanded the industry. This sudden change brought on a new class of people. These people who had been up till then agricultural workers were now living in an urban area and had nothing to live off except their labor. This sudden exodus of people from the rural areas forced some families, which were living in same villages, to now crowd themselves in shacks, which were built in slums. Very quickly the situation in the cities became dire. The cities became crime havens, diseases reached epidemic levels and poverty among the working class was a fact. Socialism was a response to these effects of Industrialization. Three main influences contributed to socialism: the ideas of Robert Owen, the development of trade unions, and Chartism. These three movements contributed to the rise of Socialism as a response to Capitalism, but the writings of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels were fundamental in establishing Socialism as a movement. Although their ideas have been changed and argued for over a century, they represent the basis of Socialist thought. One should keep in mind that not all Socialists are Marxists, Karl Marx presented a more extreme view of what Socialism should be. Marx believed Socialism would eventually bring about the fall of governments. He wrote that governments represent the means by which a dominant class exploits another class. Marx also believed that competition for profit would mean that fewer and fewer people would control the means of production and that an increasing number of people would be exploited. The system (Capitalist) would in addition withhold resources, which would in turn bring on poverty. This would eventually lead to revolution of the proletariat (Karl Marx). The working class would take over the production until all needs have been satisfied and this would bring on the fall of the government. Although the theory Marx predicted has not been fulfilled, some of his ideas influenced non-Marxist Socialism. Compared to non-Marxist Socialism this may be viewed as revolutionary, because the change would be sudden and extreme. Most Socialists believe that change is necessary but should be done legally. This change should, for example, be done through proper channels, like the parliament, and should not be forced upon the people if they do not wish so. History cannot provide us with successful Socialist states, but learning how the biggest Socialist economies failed can teach us what needs to be done to do it successfully the next time. Russia was the first state to be www.notesolution.com
More Less
Unlock Document


Only page 1 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

Unlock Document
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version

Unlock Document

Log In


OR

Don't have an account?

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit