Midterm Notes.docx

10 Pages
178 Views
Unlock Document

Department
Political Science
Course
POLB92H3
Professor
Lucan Way
Semester
Fall

Description
POLB92 MIDTERM NOTES Basic Terms ● State → Central apparatus of political or coercive power in a particular national territory (police, military, welfare office) ○ Maintains order, and service to the citizens ● Regime→ Set of rules by which political power is allocated ○ Democracy, monarchy, who possesses the biggest gun ● Government→ Group of people in power at the time ○ Changes the most often, the most impermanent ● Dependent Variable → What are you trying to explain? ● Independent Variable → The factors that you think explain the outcome ○ e.g. I'm hungry because not eaten all day. IV is not eating and DV is hunger. ● Correlational Analysis → Looking for relationships between the Independent Variable and the Dependent Variable ○ Primary concern is increasing number of observations to gain statistical significance ○ Hard to incorporate time ○ BUT: Meaningless correlations? ● Case Study → We are identifying the causal mechanisms ○ Detailed analysis of individual case ○ Focus on the time ○ BUT: Is it relevant to other cases? Revolution ● Violent, rare, impactful ● Structural Explanation ○ Long term factors that don't easily change ○ Very PREDICTABLE (limited number of possible outcomes) ○ Misery and poverty causes revolution ■ People have nothing to lose but their chains. BUT! ● Misery actually breeds passivity. They are barely surviving and you don't have time to go out and protest. You just focus on surviving. ● Lack of resources for rebellion. Don't know how to influence the wealthy and important (no cultural capital). Lack of education. ● Low expectations. Enduring poverty makes their condition seem like a fact of life. ● Marxist Theory ○ Class based analysis: haves vs. have nots ○ Feudalism REVOLUTION Capitalism REVOLUTION Communism ○ Change is violent and conflict. People don't give up without a fight. ○ Two types: ■ Bourgeois revolution where feudalism and elite is replaced by capitalism ● Wealth is based on land and birth. Power is centralized in a small elite. ● Rise of capitalism ● Creating a competitive system that excludes most of the population. ■ Communist revolution ● Desire to reduce costs leads to capitalists to force down wages of the workers ● This in turn revolutionized in dissatisfaction of workers ○ For this to work you don't need values, beliefs etc. All you need is capitalists. ■ A capitalist exists for their own interest (profit driven, but unbeknownst to them, it leads to a revolution. A destruction of their own capitalism. ● Relative Deprivation ○ When does poverty lead to a revolt? Have to look at relative misery instead of absolute misery. Expectations can only be frustrated if they are high and rising. ■ The J-Curve. You have it good, then it goes down. "What?! I thought things were getting better!" ● e.g. Boston Red Sox. The fans were upset when they don't get a cup, because they are used to them winning. ■ Revolutions require much more than dashed expectations ● Collective Action Problem ○ Any sort of collective action is individually irrational. The individual impact on the broader outcome is minimal. It requires risk and effort. Where people who don't rebel don’t get punished. ○ Solve this by... ■ Leadership ■ Organization. (e.g. In the US they used churches to facilitate the civil rights movement) ● Skocpol’s Theory of Revolution --NOTES ○ State is relatively autonomous. An act in its own right, not just a support for the dominant class. ○ Make the states vulnerable to breakdown to external pressure--fall behind on military and lost wars ○ Agrarian bureaucracy: state in rural country that depends heavily on landed elite or aristocracy. Power is to the elite, and they face modernization crisis. ○ Monarchs seek resources for war/modernization cause split in upper class ○ Rebellious peasants + revolutionary elite = Revolution. ○ BUT! ■ Leadership? → Someone must sell the revolutionary project to the masses ■ Ideology? ● Voluntarist Theory of Revolution ○ Depends on the action of a particular person or event ○ UNPREDICTABLE or contingent ○ Condition for revolution is everywhere, but there isn't always a leader to catalyze or spark ● Diffusion --NOTES ○ Example of revolutionary success in one country inspires opposition in another Origins of French Revolution ● Voluntarist Approach ○ Mistakes by Louis XVI ■ Decision to help the American Revolution which then causes deficit ■ Radicalizes the Parlements in 1788 by arresting the members of the Paris Parlement, which lead to the calling of Estates General ● Structuralist response? Only did this because he needed taxes due to being bankrupt. Driven by structural needs to get more money ● King then fled the country in 1791 ○ Marie Antoinette spent loads of jewels and money while the French nation was bankrupt ○ Robespierre as inspiration behind Great Terror ■ No structural reason for Robespierre’s role and inspiration to exist ■ Obsession with his notion of virtue ○ Marat with ideology, became martyr ○ Bad weather causing a bad harvest ● Structuralist Approach (Marx) ○ Rise of bourgeoisie ○ Elimination of barriers to capitalism ■ Role of commercial class in revolution ● Rise of the third estate by the Estates General ● 98% of population on had 33% of the vote. They said no to voting by order (class and birthright) and yes to voting by head ○ Revolution supported by middle class (artisans and shopkeepers) ■ Impact: ● Strengthened private property ● Barriers to national market is eliminated ○ Problems with Marx? ■ Blurred lines of conflict: It wasn’t the case where only the Third Estate supported voting by head. A minority of aristocrats and clergy supported it. One of the initial moments was in fact 30 aristocrats. ■ Conflicts within the ruling class just as intense as the conflict between classes ● Why was the Estate General called in the first place? Because there was conflicts between the aristocrats and the king due to taxation. ● Conflict within the elite allows the lower classes to emerge. ■ Revolution strengthened the state (created a bureaucracy) not the entrepreneurs ● Skocpol’s Theory ○ Weakened French State ■ Why was the state weak enough to all the masses to win? ■ International competition from stronger foreign powers. France has to raise money (taxes) to compete with England. ■ Efforts at reform ■ Strong resistance or rebellion by aristocracy or other elites ■ Opening for peasant rebellion → Allie with the urban radicals → Change in social order/revolution ■ International pressures ● Lost wars (Seven Years War, War of Austrian Succession) ● American Revolution (The state is overwhelmed due to loans) ○ Weak revenue in raising capacities ■ Louis the XVI’s power is actually decentralised. So many people had the right to not pay taxes. ■ Privileges: If you were able to purchase a position, you are basically exempted from tax ■ Venal Offices: where he sold bureaucratic positions (short term cash, long term = you’re stuck with them till you buy them out) ● Ineffective administration, are they even good at their job?! ● A key to a good government is able to fire people ■ He’s saving money to support the aristocrat’s interests. Need money to keep the system. BUT Aristocracy is resistant to taxes and tax reform “screw you I want to keep my money” ■ Parlements ● Nobles refuse to give up privileges ■ Estates General ● 1787 Parlement of Paris ○ Refuse to register stamp and land tax to pay off debt ○ They were then exiled by the king ○ Parlements rally behind Paris, and the king calls for Estates General ● Skocpol: Why was the general called in the first place? It is a function of the weak state, whose not even able to tax their nobility. ● Marx: Role of commercial class in revolution ○ Rise of the third estate by the Estates General ○ 98% of population on had 33% of the vote. They said no to voting by order (class and birthright) and yes to voting by head ● ON THE MIDTERM. Skocpol vs. Marx on Estates General. ■ French peasantry had ownership had large portions of land passed on within family ● Carry out their own affairs (had heavy rents or controls) ● They are in the position to carry out massive rebellions → Downfall of French social system ○ BUT! ■ Very little room for agency (Marie Antoinette, Louis XVI, Robespierre) ■ No theory of urban revolts, key to the revolution ■ No ideology, that we can understand the French revolution without enlightenment ideas 1848 Revolutions Structural Causes of 1848 ● Marx: Communist Revolution ○ Rise of the proletariat against “bourgeois monarch” ○ Bourgeoisie vs. workers/suffrage ■ In Frankfurt, liberals opposed to universal male suffrage only for the wealthy. Why did they not want workers? What would the radicals do? They want to eliminate the privileges (private property). ■ Opposition by liberals to efforts to thwart mechanization ○ BUT: ■ France is much less industrialized than Great Britain where there was no revolution (totally against Marx’s prediction) ■ Classes take different sides, many radicals were artisans who fight alongside proletariat, some bourgeoisie support workers. ■ Protests in areas (Danube) untouched by industrialization, education, liberal ideas ● Economic Depression ○ Food supply shock of 1845 all through Europe ○ Revolution does not occur in GB and Sweden because there was less economic shock ○ BUT: ■ Bumper
More Less

Related notes for POLB92H3

Log In


OR

Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


OR

By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.


Submit