Sen- Self Interest
o Talks about dignity and deontology
Property right Arguments
Society brings out
Civil society brings peace and security
Contract simply doesn’t work in contract of the war.
Property mix the labour with the commons
Add value to commons then makes you entitle to it and become a property
Supports Division labour, Supports self interest
Against Division of Labour, Alienation
Against Locke’s idea.
o Locke’s idea can be capitalism Aleienation of the
alienation from others
Original “Veil of ignorance.”
o You are disadvantaged you don’t know if you’re the minority or the
o That’s why it is rational to have distribution because you don’t know
what side you are. Therefore Rawl said it is not a violation of freedom.
Object of original of agreement is the principal of justice.
Kind of supports Kant’s idea of deontology.
Entitlement Theory Takes Locke’s idea and develop more … Nozick idea is “if you aqcurie things
justely then you are entitle to it, when you transfer to somebody then that
person is entitle to what you transfer. So justice go all the way through.”
o Weir Chamberlin
o Compare to a person works a lot and compare to another that do not
works at all.
o Redistribution is by the state.. by taxing us. He think that’s it’s a
violation of freedom. The government tax you is too take away some
of you away.
3 Principal of Justice
Disagree with each other in different principal
Nozick Supports Locke point of view
1. Agrees on Liberty Principal
2. Difference Principal
Wehane & Radin
She said if you're firing people you have to give them a reason, because youre
not firing a robot. (They’re all human – Basic Human rights)
Wehane support “Due Process”
Wehane is wrong
Wehane Disagrees with Epstein
o No you fire a person, yo