Study Guides (248,409)
United States (123,378)
Biology (217)
BIOL 2301 (12)
Strauss (4)

bio paper 3.doc

5 Pages
Unlock Document

BIOL 2301

Missy Johnson BIO U409 Professor Strauss 12/04/06 Genetic Testing: Implications for the Future of Medicine The technologies of modern day science are slowly changing the face of medicine. Genetic testing, screening and profiling of newborns will highlight new ethical and social issues and bring about significant changes in the practice of medicine. There are notable benefits and risks associated with any kind of genetic testing. It must be determined; however, whether or not the benefits of such testing outweigh the risks. This will be a pressing issue in medicine for years to come as technology progresses. Genetic testing, screening and profiling are three different modern technologies used as preemptive measures for finding and treating disease (5). As opposed to screening whose aim is to identify a group of people who are at risk for a certain disease, genetic testing is done on an individual to identify a certain gene variant (5). Testing is done on the basis of family history or symptoms that have already presented themselves (5). Screening is done in order to identify risks to a certain group of people in order to come up with preventative measures to reduce the risk of contracting a disease (5). Newborn screening for serious genetic defects is becoming more and more commonplace throughout hospitals in the country (4). Florida provides screening for newborns for five metabolic disorders free of charge (4). It is likely that this type of screening could grow into entire genetic profiling of all newborns (5). In contrast, genetic profiling is the analyzing of a person’s entire genome in order to find any variants in their genetic code (5). More ethical issues are raised with general use of genetic profiling that with testing or screening. If genetic profiling is used extensively throughout the population many ethical and moral issues regarding consent would be raised (5). Genetic testing, screening and profiling would raise many questions about the moral and ethical implications of genetic testing. Genetic testing and screening are not as controversial as genetic profiling (5). They can be used more widely at the current time as they are more financially feasible (5). In addition to the problems associated with the high cost of general use of genetic profiling there are also many practical issues with this technique of predicting disease (5). The relationship between genetic variation and polygenetic disorders is not well enough understood in order to be useful in general use of genetic profiling (5). Genetic variants can also be affected by outside factors which would make a genetic profile less clear-cut (5). In cases where there is more than one variant that can cause a disease, genetic profiling would be less helpful than other tests used to identify many variants (5). Finally, there is the issue of consent from the parent for the testing of a child. It is the opinion of some that a child should only be tested if it gives some immediate advantage to the child in preventing or controlling a disease (5). Although it could reveal possible problems for the child, it is debatable whether or not the parent has the right to make the decision to test the child or whether it should be done when the child is old enough to give their own informed consent(5). Some may not want to live knowing that they have an incurable disease (5). Even if the disease is preventable, the knowledge that they have it will not necessarily motivate them to change their lifestyle in order to prevent it (5). Also, other relevant issues are brought up concerning parents and their choice whether or not to keep a child after finding out the child’s risk for disease (1). Already embryos are being specifically selected based on genetic screening results (1). This brings up the moral issues associated with engineering a child for specific features (1). It could be deemed normal to screen embryos for severe genetic defects, but it is debatable whether this will be taken too far in the future such that embryos are being selected for even the most trivial advantages (1). There are many benefits associated with general use of genetic testing. Diseases that may be contracted by a person could be detected early and treatment could be started quickly (4). However, at this time, many treatable disorders are not being tested for (4). Either way, the results of this testing could affect a child’s fate to be born or not, depending on the choice of the parents (4). It is not the aim of genetic profiling to engineer children in future generations (3). It is possible though, that the information given to parents will affect their decision to keep their child if it has a variant for a disease (3). It is possible though, to discove
More Less

Related notes for BIOL 2301

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.