Textbook Notes (280,000)
CA (170,000)
McGill (5,000)
Chapter Eco

RELG 270 Chapter Notes - Chapter Eco: Scientific Method, Citta, Implicate And Explicate Order


Department
Religious Studies
Course Code
RELG 270
Professor
Eliza Rosenberg
Chapter
Eco

This preview shows pages 1-3. to view the full 9 pages of the document.
Grounding Religion: A Field Guide to Study of
Religion and Ecology
Whitney(A.(Bauman(
!
"#$%$&'!()!*!+,-.!+/*+!/*)!0,,1!)+23(,3!4$-!52(+,!)$.,!+(.,6!*13!%(7,!-,%(&($16!(+!()!
0,)+!213,-)+$$3!*)!*!0-$*3!(3,*!+/*+!#$8,-)!%$+!$4!+,--(+$-'!*13!+/*+!#*1!0,!0,1+!*13!
)/*9,3!(1!8*-($2)!:*');!"-1)+!<*,#7,%6!*!=,-.*1!0($%$&()+6!0,%(,8,3!+/*+!0'!)+23'(1&!
1*+2-,6!/,!:$2%3!-,8,*%!+/,!$-3,-!$4!1*+2-,!*13!+/,!8(-+2,)!0'!:/(#/!/2.*1)!#*1!
%(8,!/*-.$1($2)%'!:(+/!(+;!>1!$-3,-!:$-3)6!+/,!)+23'!$4!$-&*1().)!:$2%3!%,*3!/(.!+$!
+/,!#$).(#!+-2+/;!?,$9%,!/*8,!0,,1!*-&2(1&!*0$2+!,#$%$&'!!!:/*+!3$,)!(+!.,*1!*13!
/$:!#*1!(+!0,!0,)+!2),3@!!
A/-,,!.*B$-!*-&2.,1+)!-,&*-3(1&!+/,!3,0*+,C!
D/$!/*)!+/,!*2+/$-(+'!+$!3$!,#$%$&'@!E2+/$-(+'!$4!,F9,-+)!8,-)2)!#$..$1!
+*)7!$4!+/,!9,$9%,!
D/*+!#*1!,#$%$&'!+,%%!2)!*0$2+!G1*+2-,!(+),%4H@!I*+2-,!*)!:/$%,!8,-)2)!
%(.(+*+($1)!$4!1*+2-,!*13!#2%+2-,!
<$:!3$,)!,#$%$&'!(14%2,1#,!-,%(&($1@!E%-,*3'!*!9*-+!$4!-,%(&($1!$-!+!/*)!+$!
-,)/*9,!-,%(&($1!
A/,),!#$1#,9+)!*-,!$08($2)%'!.$-,!#$.9%,F!+/*1!(+!),,.)6!*13!+/,!$08($2)!)$%2+($1!
:$2%3!0,!*!#$.0(1*+($1!$4!0$+/!9,-)9,#+(8,);!!
!
Science!and!Morality!
A/,!)#(,1#,!$4!,#$%$&'!()!0*),3!$1!+/,!(3,*!+/*+!,8,-'!9*-+!$4!+/,!1*+2-*%!:$-%3!()!
#$11,#+,3!+$!$+/,-!9*-+);!J$!+$!#$.9%,+,%'!213,-)+*13!9%*1+)!$-!*1(.*%)6!:,!.2)+!
*%)$!%$$7!*+!+/,(-!(1+,-*#+($1)!:(+/!$+/,-!$-&*1().)!*13!+/,!)2--$213(1&);!A/,!)+23'!
$4!,#$%$&'!1$:!+,13)!+$!4$#2)!$1!+/,!#$1),52,1#,)!$1!*!9*-+(#2%*-!)9,#(,)!$-!
%$#*+($16!-*+/,-!+/*1!+/,!#$1),52,1#,!$1!1*+2-,!*)!*!:/$%,!K/$:!&%$0*%!:*-.(1&!
*44,#+)!9$%*-!0,*-)!(1)+,*3!$4!+-'(1&!+$!213,-)+*13!#%(.*+,!#/*1&,!*)!*!:/$%,L;!>+!()!
2),3!*)!*!3$.(1*1+!:$-%38(,:!$4!+/,!D,)+!:/,-,!(13(8(32*%)!*-,!),9*-*+,3!4-$.!
1*+2-,!*13!3()+(1#+($1)!*-,!.*3,!0,+:,,1!)9,#(,);!!
M$142#(*1!)#/$%*-!N$21&O#/*1!P$!)+*+,)C!
"#$%$&'!.2)+!0,!0*),3!$1!+/,!-,#(9-$#(+'!0,+:,,1!.*1!*13!1*+2-,Q!/2.*1)!
.2)+!0,!213,-)+$$3!(1!%(&/+!$4!+/,(-!21(8,-),!*13!1$+!0*),3!$1!+/,(-!+/$2&/+)!
$1!+/,!21(8,-),;!A/()!*-&2.,1+!0-(1&)!0*#7!+/,!(3,*!$4!+/,!:,06!:/,-,!
,8,-'+/(1&!()!#$11,#+,36!*13!,8,-'+/(1&!#*.,!4-$.!+/,!)*.,!#$).(#!0(-+/;!
D,!3$1R+!$1%'!/*8,!+$!-,*%(S,!+/,!,18(-$1.,1+*%!9-$0%,.)!)2--$213(1&!2)!
*13!9-$8(3,!*!)$%2+($16!:,!/*8,!+$!*##,9+!0,(1&!9*-+!$4!+/,!,18(-$1.,1+6!*13!
:,!,F()+!(1!*1!,F#/*1&,!$4!.*++,-!*13!,1,-&';!
E%%,1!*13!<$,7)+-*R)!+/,$-(,)C!
"#$%$&'!()!1$+!*0$2+!*)),-+(1&!4213*.,1+*%!+-2+/)!*13!.$-*%)!
T$3,%(1&!*13!.,*)2-(1&!)')+,.)!*)!:,%%!*)!9$))(0%,!
"8,-'+/(1&!()!1$+!#$11,#+,3!02+!+/,-,!()!.(1(.*%!*.$21+!$4!#$11,#+($1)!+/*+!
#*1!0,!2),3!+$!)2--$&*+,!+/,!:/$%,!)')+,.!(1+$!*!).*%%,-!.$3,%!
A/,),!+:$!*99-$*#/,)!*-,!(1!)$.,!:*'!-,%*+,3!*13!1$+!.2+2*%%'!,F#%2)(8,;!T*1'!
-,%(&($1)!#/*-*#+,-(S,!,#$%$&'!*)!/$%'!*13!,8,-'+/(1&!/*8(1&!+/,(-!$:1!9%*#,!(1!

Only pages 1-3 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

1*+2-,6!02+!+/,!)#(,1#,!$4!,#$%$&'!),,)!1*+2-,!*)!,8$%8(1&!*13!(1!#$1)+*1+!#/*1&,;!
"#$%$&'!()!0$+/!*!)203(8()($1!$4!)#(,1#,!B2)+!*)!.2#/!*)!(+!()!+/,!21(8,-)*%!+-2+/!
*0$2+!1*+2-,;!
!
Nature!as!Common!and!Contested!Ground!
U1!$1,!/*136!/2.*1)!*-,!#$1)(3,-,3!),9*-*+,!4-$.!+/,!-,)+!$4!1*+2-,!)(1#,!+/,'!
/*8,!+*7,1!*!3$.(1*1+!-$%,6!*-,!#*9*0%,!$4!#$1)#($2)1,))!*13!3,#()($1!.*7(1&6!*3!
$1!+/,!$+/,-!/*136!+/,'!*-,!)9,#(,)!%(7,!$+/,-)!+/*+!/*8,!,8$%8,3!4-$.!$+/,-!
#-,*+2-,);!"8,1!+/$2&/!+/,(-!+,#/1$%$&'!/*)!*1!(.9*#+!$1!+/,!,18(-$1.,1+6!+/,'!*-,!
1$+!+/,!$1%'!$1,)!K0,*8,-)!*13!3*.)6!*%&*,!*13!-(8,-)6!9$%%(1*+($1L;!A/,-,!*-,!*%)$!
$+/,-!0,(1&)6!%(7,!3$%9/(1)6!+/*+!/(1+!+$!%*1&2*&,6!&-(,46!*13!$+/,-!)$9/()+(#*+,3!:*'!
$4!%(4,;!V,,9!(1!.(13!+/*+!:/,+/,-!:,!213,-)+*13!1*+2-,!3()+(1#+!$-!-,%*+,3!+$!
/2.*1!#2%+2-,6!+/,!(3,*!$4!1*+2-,!()!*!9-$32#+!$4!/2.*1!#2%+2-,;!
A/,!:$-3!G1*+2-,H!:*)!(18,1+,3!0'!/2.*1)!
>+!()!*!+,-.!+/*+!/*)!*!%$+!$4!9$:,-!
>+!()!*!9*+-(*-#/*%!+,-.!K:$.*1R)!9%*#,!()!(1!+/,!/$.,!*##$-3(1&!+$!1*+2-,L!
J$!1*+2-,!()!1$+!B2+)!*!-,*%(+'!0,'$13!/2.*1!#2%+2-,6!02+!(+!()!*%)$!:/*+!/2.*1)!/*8,!
2),3!+$!)/*9,!*13!B2)+(4'!+/,(-!#2%+2-,6!)$!()!1*+2-,!-,*%%'!),9*-*+,;!D/,1!:,!+/(17!
*0$2+!,#$%$&'!),-($2)%'6!:,!.2)+!+*7,!1$+/(1&!4$-!&-*1+,3;!
!
Ecologies!and!Religions!
W,)9(+,!+/,!3,0*+,!-,&*-3(1&!+/,!+,-.)!1*+2-,!*13!,#$%$&'6!:,!*%%!*&-,,3!+/*+!+/,-,!
()!*!1,,3!+$!)+23'!+/,.;!D/,1!()!#$.,)!+$!-,%(&($1!*13!,#$%$&'6!:,!-,4,-!+$!+/,!
3,0*+,!$4!:/,+/,-!+-*3(+($1)!)/$2%3!0,!.$3(4(,36!#/*1&,36!$-!%,4+!*)!(+!()@!J$.,!+-'!
+$!)+23'!M/-()+(*1(+'!KW,D(++L!*13!)+*+,)!+/*+!,#$%$&'!/*)!*%:*')!0,,1!*!9*-+!$4!
1*+2-,6!$+/,-)!K<,)),%!*13!P2,+/,-L!+-'!+$!-,4$-.!(+6!*13!$+/,-)!KA*'%$-L!4$#2),)!$1!
G&-,,1!-,%(&($1H!:/,-,!*1(.().)!()!*1!,)),1+(*%!9*-+;!
!
Complexities!in!Religion!and!Ecology!
A/,!9$(1+!(1!213,-)+*13(1&!,#$%$&'!()!1$+!+$!3,+,-.(1,!:/(#/!9,-)9,#+(8,!()!-(&/+6!
02+!+$!0,!*0%,!+$!213,-)+*13!+/,!#$.9%,F(+(,)!0,/(13!,*#/!$4!+/,!-,*)$1(1&6!0,#*2),6!
*)!.,1+($1,3!,*-%(,-6!+/,!*1):,-!()!.$)+!%(7,%'!*!#$.9%,F!#$.0(1*+($1!$4!*%%!$4!+/,),!
+/$2&/+);!
!
Green Critiques of Science and Knowledge
Peter(Hay(
!
The!Green!Critique!of!Mechanistic!Science!
X$-!)$.,!9,$9%,6!+/,!)+*+2)!$4!)#(,1#,!()!1$+!9-$0%,.*+(#Q!+/,'!0,%(,8,!+/*+!
,18(-$1.,1+*%!9-$0%,.)!*-,!+,#/1$%$&(#*%!(1!1*+2-,!*13!)#(,1#,!:(%%!0,!*0%,!+$!
#$.,!29!:(+/!)$%2+($1!+$!+/,!3(%,..*;!U+/,-)!)+(%%!0,%(,8,!(1!+/,!(3,*)!*13!(3,*%)!$4!
)#(,1#,6!02+!+/(17!+/*+!)#(,1#,!)/$2%3!0,!-,#$1)+-2#+,3!(1!*!:*'!+/*+!()!3(44,-,1+!
4-$.!$2-!#2--,1+!3$.(1*1+!+-,13;!!
Y*),3!$1!M$+&-$8,!*13!W244R)!+*0%,6!(+!#*1!0,!*-&2,3!+/*+!3,)9(+,!+/,!.*1'!
#$.9%,F(+(,)!*13!12*1#,)!+/*+!*-,!$8,-%$$7,36!,18(-$1.,1+*%()+)!)+(%%!),,!)#(,1#,!*)!
*1!,1+(+'!0,'$13!-,3,.9+($1;!E%)$6!+/,!0,%(,4!+/*+!/2.*1)!*-,!)29,-($-!+$!$+/,-!%(4,!

Only pages 1-3 are available for preview. Some parts have been intentionally blurred.

4$-.)!%,*3)!+/,.!+$!,F9,-(.,1+!$1!$+/,-!1$1O/2.*1!0,(1&)!4$-!+,#/1$%$&(#*%!
*38*1#,.,1+;!!
Z$/1!P$3.*1C!
A/,-($9/(%(*C!)$.,!0,*)+)!*13!/2.*1)!*-,!#%$),%'!-,%*+,3!K,52*%!(1!)$.,!
),1),L!
A/,-($9/$0(*C!+/,!4,*-!$4!0,*)+)!:/$!*-,!8($%,1+!*13!(--*+($1*%6!*13!:/$.!
.*1!-,),.0%,)!$1%'!:/,1!:(#7,3!
U1%'!+/,!-*+($1*%!)$2%!)2-8(8,)!3,*+/6!02+!*%%!%(8(1&!0,(1&)!+-'!+$!-,*#/!4-$!
(..$-+*%(+'!+/-$2&/!-,9-$32#+($1!
W,)#*-+,)!
T(13!8);!T*++,-!
J(F+/!W()#$2-),C!.*7,!2)!G.*)+,-)!*13!9-$#,))$-)!$4!1*+2-,H!
"F9,-(.,1+*%!)#(,1#,!:*)!4$213,3!$1!*#+)!$1!1$1O/2.*1!1*+2-,!*13!
M*-+,)(*1!9/(%$)$9/'!%,&(+(.(S,)!+/()!1$+($1!
J$!+/,!#-(+(52,!$1!)#(,1#,!()!)$.,+(.,!52(+,!,F+-,.,6!:*1+(1&!2)!+$!#$.9%,+,%'!
*0*13$1!.$3,-1!)#(,1#,6!02+!+/,-,!,F()+!+/,!&-,,1!-,)9$1),!+/*+!)+*+,)!+/*+!)#(,1#,!
)/$2%3!)+*'6!02+!/*)!+$!-,9-($-(+(S,!*13!-,#$1)+-2#+)!+/,(-!4$213*+($1);!!
!
The!‘New!Physics’!in!Environmental!Thoughts!
T$)+!*))2.,!,#$%$&'!()!+/,!)+23'!$4!,18(-$1.,1+6!02+!1,:!9/')(#)!()!)$.,+/(1&!+/*+!
()!0,(1&!(1#%23,3;!!
I,:!?/')(#)!
I,:+$1R)!+/,$-'!$4!&-*8(+'!
"(1)+,(1R)!+/,$-'!$4!-,%*+(8(+'!
M/*$)!*13!U-3,-!+/,$-'!
W*8(3!Y$/.R)!+/,$-'C!1$+($1!$4!(.9%(#*+,!$-3,-!:/,-,!+/,!+$+*%(+'!$4!
,F()+,1#,!()!,14$%3,3!:(+/!,*#/!-,&($1!$4!)9*#,!*13!+(.,!)$!+/*+!:/$%,1,))!
9,-.,*+,)!*%%;!
!
Ecology:!the!‘Subversive!Science’!
A/,!=-,,1!.$8,.,1+!()!+/,!,#$%$&'!.$8,.,1+C!(+)!*#+($1O)/*9(1&!9-(1#(9%,)!*-,!
,#$%$&(#*%%'!)$2-#,3;!E!)#(,1#,!+/*+!(&1$-,)!,#$%$&'!()!0*)(1&!(+),%4!$1!4-*&.,1+)!$4!
71$:%,3&,!-*+/,-!+/*1!+/,!,1+(-,!71$:%,3&,!9$$%;!!T$)+!:(%%!0,%(,8,!+/*+!)#(,1#,!()!
3,,9%'!(.9%(#*+,3!(1!,18(-$1.,1+*%!9-$0%,.)!02+!+/*+!()!+/,!,F+,1+!$4!(+;!!
E1!,#$%$&(#*%!.$3,%!$4!)#(,1#,!()!1$+!$1,!$4!/(,-*-#/'!:/,-,!3$.(1*1#,!()!
+/,!.*(1!#$1#,9+6!02+!-*+/,-!$4!(1+,-3,9,13,1#(,);!!
Y*--'!M$..$1,-R)!4$2-!%*:)!$4!,#$%$&'!
o "8,-'+/(1&!)()!#$11,#+,3!+$!,8,-'+/(1&!,%),!
o "8,-'+/(1&!.2)+!&$!)$.,:/,-,!
o I*+2-,!71$:)!0,)+!
o A/,-,!()!1$!)2#/!+/(1&!*)!*!4-,,!%21#/!
!
Gaia!
A/,!=*(*!/'9$+/,)()!)+*+,)!+/*+!%(4,!$1!,*-+/!#$O$-3(1*+,)6!-,&2%*+,)6!*13!),%4O
#$--,#+)!(1!)2#/!*!:*'!+/*+!(+!()!.*(1+*(1,3!,8,1!+/-$2&/!)20)+*1+(*%!*%+,-*+($1)!+$!
+/,!&,$%$&(#*%!*13!#/,.(#*%!#$13(+($1)!+/*+!)2)+*(1!(+;!>+!-*(),)!#$1+-$8,-)(,)!
You're Reading a Preview

Unlock to view full version