Textbook Notes (367,936)
Canada (161,516)
POLI 211 (29)

Pg. 1-37.docx

14 Pages
Unlock Document

Political Science
POLI 211
Fillippo Sabetti

What is comparative politics? Sept.9.12 Pages 1-37 Intro - State = organization that possesses sovereignty over a territory and its people - No two states are ruled the same - Comparativists: political scientists who study/compare the politics of different countries - Not always possible to design a country as one sees fit but it is possible to understand why countries are developed/ruled a certain way - Gain this understanding via range of political responses to global opportunities and constraints Comparative politics and political science - Comparative politics = major subfield of political science - Closely related to international relations and political theory - First comparativists were political theorists (i.e. ancient Greek political theorists Plato and Aristotle) - Different political orders: 1. Aristocracy: the rule of the best 2. Oligarchy: the rule of the few 3. Democracy: the rule of the people 4. Tyranny: the rule of the tyrant - Plato & Aristotle tried to explain which type of government was best - Contemporary political scientists follow first comparativists, writing about different political orders and analyze the structure of ideas about each order - Comparativists suspend their normal evaluations of the world so to describe the political world (social scientists must give systematic objective explanations) - Comparativists try to understand/identify general conditions (social, economic, ideological, institutional, and international) of democracies that appear, become unstable, collapse into a dictatorship, and sometimes reemerge as a democracy - Relationship between comparative politics and international relations: social scientists, trace their roots to ancient Greek political theory - Thuscydides: he attempted to understand the origins and consequences of Peloponnesian Wars between Greek city-states - Comparativists acknowledge wars/international trade but concentrate on politics within countries than between them (i.e. domestic politics) - International relations sthcialists = foreign politics - Last quarter of the 20 century: international relations specialists now recognize what happens within a country affects their behavior with other countries (i.e. would there have been World War 2 without the election of the Nazis in 1932? Not for sure, but politics within Germany affected the politics between the EU in the 30s) - War, preparing for war, and trade influence domestic politics (i.e. gun trade internationally what happens between countries affects what happens within them too) - International environment provides political challengers that countries must respond to - Countries responses lead to a new kind of domestic institutional order that other countries find appealing or threatening, and they in turn respond How comparativists practice their craft: concepts and methods 1. Regime types - If we accept the fact that there are different political orders in the world: what are their main characteristics, why do they appear, and when do they - Most analysis of countries looks at why democracy took root or did not - Classification of countries into regime types is difficult - Comparativists dont simply accept the word of rulers that its political institutions are democratic - Comparativists consider democracy to have these traits: competitiveness, multiparty elections, freedom of speech and assembly, and rule of law - Communist traits: party seeks to transform the society it rules according to the tenets of Marxist-Leninist ideology - Real countries dont abide solely by all the characteristics of one single regime - Not all democracies are totally free and fair - i.e. should we declassify China as a communist country if they allow the market to rule their economy? - If comparativists can agree on what regime types look like they can understand why they exists in one place and not another 2. Tools of analysis: interests, identities, and institutions - Comparativists usually disagree on how to best evaluate the conditions that produce the political regime types - First comparativists believe that: material interests matter most, people are rational calculators, they organize politically when it serves their interests, they support political regime types that suit them most - To gain better knowledge of politics in a country one must study the structure of material interests - Major interests in democratic states are organized into: interest groups, trade unions, social movements, and political parties - In non-demographic places it may be illegal for individuals to come together in interest groups/competing political parties - Second comparativists believe that: there are no objective interests outside of food and shelter, interests are influenced by individuals identities, its better to focus on dominant identity of a given society - Religion and ethnicity are two common forms that identity takes, they are predictors of how people vote and what policies they favor (i.e. most Jews in the US vote democratic and most southerners vote Republican) - Modern societies generate new identities based on gender, sexual orientation, and care for the environment too - Democratic societies now focus on womens rights, gay rights, and environmental movements - Identity politics are important in nondemocratic societies too (i.e. communist revolutionaries believed that building a better society would allow for people to define themselves in new ways) - Third comparativists believe that: material interests and identities dont solely determine how a countrys politics work, institutions are the most important aspect, long-term/authoritative rules and procedures structure how power flows - Democracies have institutions for electing their leaders, channeling flow of legislation, and determining whether or not laws are just - first-past-the-post (parliamentary leaders are elected in a single-member district like in the US) vs. proportional representation (parliamentary leaders are elected in a multi-member district like in Germany) - Communist partys most important institution is the communist state: small party cells at all political levels spread throughout the society, with elaborate institutions for economic planning and administration - Secret police institution: Iran (an Islamic republic) has an elected parliament and an unelected Supreme Revolutionary Council of religious leaders, they have the right to declare invalid legislation that contradicts Islamic law - Institutions shape the political arena and influence what kinds of policies are enacted - Three ways of studying the determinants of politics: 1. Interests stress the importance of a countrys middle class (poorer countries have smaller middle classes + diminished chances for sustaining democracy) 2. Identities presence/absence of democracy dependent on the strength of a populations commitment to representative government and democratic participation 3. Institutions focus on which political arrangements best ensure elections, freedom of speech, and rule of law will continue to be practiced - Comparativists use these three ways to determine why countries are democratic or nondemocratic and why they have certain public policies (i.e. the size of welfare or healthcare programs) - i.e. public policy of healthcare in the US: why is it mostly private? It is the exception to the general rule of democratic societies having government funded healthcare, analysis based on interests may point to influence of important groups (insurance companies and doctors), comparativists will compare US interests, identities, and institutions with those of other countries to find out the answer - Basic questions answered by comparing the three ways: why do some democratic countries have only two parties, why do minority ethnic groups mobilize politically and during some eras, why do some people enter politics via elections and some via terrorism, why/when do revolutions occur
More Less

Related notes for POLI 211

Log In


Join OneClass

Access over 10 million pages of study
documents for 1.3 million courses.

Sign up

Join to view


By registering, I agree to the Terms and Privacy Policies
Already have an account?
Just a few more details

So we can recommend you notes for your school.

Reset Password

Please enter below the email address you registered with and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Add your courses

Get notes from the top students in your class.